Talk:Mohali: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Bunty.Gill (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Unofficial Mohali image== |
|||
:Hi Sukh, and thanks for the friendly welcome. I see that you have removed the logo banner for Mohali, and while respecting your right to do so, I am afraid I have taken issue with it, and would like to lobby for its return. I understand that no other city pages have an opening banner. While this convention seems to be universal, sometimes you must think in new ways to better the end product. As Wikipedia is not a traditional encyclopedia, I do not feel that articles must adhere to the rules set out by paper encyclopedias. It is web-based, and in my experience, web pages with creative title banners reflecting the subject matter (Mohali), as well as its context (India) create more of an aesthetic appeal. The banner does not break any wikipedia rules ([[Wikipedia:Be bold in updating pages]]), looks nice, and accurately introduces the subject in a way that words cannot. [[User:Jaskaramdeep|Jaskaramdeep]] 19:59, 31 March 2006 (UTC) |
|||
::I ''personally'' think it's inappropriate. Not because it's a banner or logo, but because it's not an official banner or logo. It would be much more appropriate to have a seal, or motto or something like that on the right hand side. |
|||
::You're welcome to get input from other Wikipedians and I won't object if there is a consensus. However, I doubt other people would like it if I got a London logo, slapped a red bus on one side and a beefeater on the other, and stuck it at the top of [[London]]! I hope you appreciate my point. |
|||
::PS - If you have any pictures of Chandigarh/Mohali they would be appreciated! Thanks. [[User:Sukh|Sukh]] | <span style="color: green;" lang="pa">ਸੁਖ</span> | [[User talk:Sukh|Talk]] 20:56, 31 March 2006 (UTC) |
|||
:::The thing is, I've racked through hundreds of websites trying to find exactly that, without success. The only motto I could find was "The IT capital of India", and that can't be right; that's Bangalore. I'm assuming hyperbole with the London reference, but still the point can be made that if London didn't already have a coat of arms, it wouldn't be inappropriate to have the word LONDON flanked by an English flag and a Unicorn. Nonetheless, I'll ask around if you still feel it's wrong, just let me know [[User:Jaskaramdeep|Jaskaramdeep]] 21:20, 31 March 2006 (UTC) |
|||
''The above text pasted from [[User talk:Jaskaramdeep]]. - [[User:Draeco|Draeco]] 23:56, 31 March 2006 (UTC)'' |
|||
:The dispute is whether or not to include [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Mohali_logo.png Image:Mohali logo.png], created by [[User:Jaskaramdeep]], as a part of the Mohali article à la [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Mohali&oldid=46344238 this edit]. I'd like to commend both parties for maintaining great [[WP:EQ|Wikiquette]], and Jaskaramdeep in particluar for contributing robustly to the development of the article. As for my opinion: despite the creator's artistic skill and good intentions, the image remains unofficial and unconnected to Mohali except through himself. Therefore the image should '''not be included'''. - [[User:Draeco|Draeco]] 06:29, 1 April 2006 (UTC) |
|||
==About Daljit Singh == |
|||
I don't see how that para was relevant to an article on Mohali as such, and not PCA stadium. [[User:Buntygill|Buntygill]] 18:24, 19 July 2006 (UTC) |
|||