Jump to content

David Stoll (anthropologist): Difference between revisions

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 2: Line 2:
'''David Stoll''' is an [[United States|American]] anthropologist. In his book ''Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans'', Stoll describes inconsistencies he found between his fieldwork and the memoir that [[Nobel Peace Prize]] laureate [[Rigoberta Menchú]] written with [[Elizabeth Burgos]]. Additionally, Stoll criticized many Western academics in their interpretation of Menchú's story, claiming that such academics romanticize guerrillas in Latin America.<ref>Stoll, David ''Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans'', 1999</ref> [[The New York Times]] featured his controversial findings about Menchú on their front page.
'''David Stoll''' is an [[United States|American]] anthropologist. In his book ''Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans'', Stoll describes inconsistencies he found between his fieldwork and the memoir that [[Nobel Peace Prize]] laureate [[Rigoberta Menchú]] written with [[Elizabeth Burgos]]. Additionally, Stoll criticized many Western academics in their interpretation of Menchú's story, claiming that such academics romanticize guerrillas in Latin America.<ref>Stoll, David ''Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans'', 1999</ref> [[The New York Times]] featured his controversial findings about Menchú on their front page.


Stoll's position on Menchu has been criticized for evincing bias in support of the Guatemalan Military, and for neglecting important data that contradicted his thesis. In her critique on Stoll's work, ''The Silencing of Maya Women from Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu'', anthropologist Victoria Sanford highlights inaccuracies in Stoll's book, and states that he used highly questionable sources as research informants. <ref> Sanford, Victoria PhD. "The Silencing of Maya Women From Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu", pp. 135-143; see p.142 for critique on Stoll's informant, Alfonso Riviera. [http://www.fygeditores.com/sanford/doc/Selected_Guatemala/2000%20The%20silencing%20of%20Maya%20women%20from%20mama%20maquinto%20rigobert.pdf]</ref>
Stoll's position on Menchu has been criticized for evincing bias in support of the Guatemalan Military and for neglecting important data that contradicted his thesis. In her critique on Stoll's work, ''The Silencing of Maya Women from Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu'', anthropologist Victoria Sanford highlights inaccuracies in Stoll's book, and claims that he used highly questionable sources as research informants. <ref> Sanford, Victoria PhD. "The Silencing of Maya Women From Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu", pp. 135-143; see p.142 for critique on Stoll's informant, Alfonso Riviera. [http://www.fygeditores.com/sanford/doc/Selected_Guatemala/2000%20The%20silencing%20of%20Maya%20women%20from%20mama%20maquinto%20rigobert.pdf]</ref>


Stoll continues to carry out research in the Guatemalan highlands, most recently focusing on [[immigration]], [[microcredit]], and what he argues is a [[financial bubble]] created by the two. He teaches at [[Middlebury College]].
Stoll continues to carry out research in the Guatemalan highlands, most recently focusing on [[immigration]], [[microcredit]], and what he argues is a [[financial bubble]] created by the two. He teaches at [[Middlebury College]].

Revision as of 01:05, 24 January 2016

For the English composer and educator, see David Stoll (composer).

David Stoll is an American anthropologist. In his book Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans, Stoll describes inconsistencies he found between his fieldwork and the memoir that Nobel Peace Prize laureate Rigoberta Menchú written with Elizabeth Burgos. Additionally, Stoll criticized many Western academics in their interpretation of Menchú's story, claiming that such academics romanticize guerrillas in Latin America.[1] The New York Times featured his controversial findings about Menchú on their front page.

Stoll's position on Menchu has been criticized for evincing bias in support of the Guatemalan Military and for neglecting important data that contradicted his thesis. In her critique on Stoll's work, The Silencing of Maya Women from Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu, anthropologist Victoria Sanford highlights inaccuracies in Stoll's book, and claims that he used highly questionable sources as research informants. [2]

Stoll continues to carry out research in the Guatemalan highlands, most recently focusing on immigration, microcredit, and what he argues is a financial bubble created by the two. He teaches at Middlebury College.

Publications

  • Fishers of Men or Founders of Empire? (1983), about the Wycliffe Bible Translators
  • Is Latin America Turning Protestant? (1990)
  • Between Two Armies in the Ixil Towns of Guatemala
  • Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans (1999)
  • TARNISHED LAUREATE: Nobel Winner Accused of Stretching the Truth (1999)
  • El Norte or Bust: How Migration Fever and Microcredit Produced a Financial Crash in a Latin American Town (2012)

References

  1. ^ Stoll, David Rigoberta Menchú and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans, 1999
  2. ^ Sanford, Victoria PhD. "The Silencing of Maya Women From Mama Maquin to Rigoberta Menchu", pp. 135-143; see p.142 for critique on Stoll's informant, Alfonso Riviera. [1]

Stub icon

This article about an American anthropologist is a stub. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it.

Template:Persondata

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=David_Stoll_(anthropologist)&oldid=701350650"