Talk:Pimentel (surname): Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Origins of the surname versus prevalence: new section |
editing |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
<ref>{{cite web|title=Holocaust Survivors and Victims Database|url=https://www.ushmm.org/online/hsv/person_advance_search.php?NameSearch__SourceSrchGrp=&NameSearch__SourceId=&NameSearch__sort=score&NameSearch__MaxPageDocs=25&NameSearch__lname=Pimentel&NameSearch__lname_accuracy=&NameSearch__fname=&NameSearch__fname_accuracy=&NameSearch__lname_maiden=&NameSearch__lname_maiden_accuracy=&NameSearch__Query=&NameSearch__SourceId=&NameSearch__year_birth=&NameSearch__year_birth_accuracy=&NameSearch__year_death=&NameSearch__year_death_accuracy=&NameSearch__year=&NameSearch__year_accuracy=&NameSearch__place=&NameSearch__place_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_birth=&NameSearch__place_birth_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_birth_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_birth_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_prewar=&NameSearch__place_prewar_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_prewar_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_prewar_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_wartime=&NameSearch__place_wartime_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_wartime_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_wartime_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_death=&NameSearch__place_death_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_death_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_death_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__meta_333=&NameSearch__meta_259=|website=United States Holocaust Memorial Museum|accessdate=29 October 2016}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|last1=Fuks|first1=comp. by L.|last2=Fuks-Mansfeld|first2=R. G.|title=Hebrew and Judaic manuscripts in Amsterdam public collections|date=1975|publisher=Brill|location=Leiden|isbn=9789004042711|page=272}}</ref> |
<ref>{{cite web|title=Holocaust Survivors and Victims Database|url=https://www.ushmm.org/online/hsv/person_advance_search.php?NameSearch__SourceSrchGrp=&NameSearch__SourceId=&NameSearch__sort=score&NameSearch__MaxPageDocs=25&NameSearch__lname=Pimentel&NameSearch__lname_accuracy=&NameSearch__fname=&NameSearch__fname_accuracy=&NameSearch__lname_maiden=&NameSearch__lname_maiden_accuracy=&NameSearch__Query=&NameSearch__SourceId=&NameSearch__year_birth=&NameSearch__year_birth_accuracy=&NameSearch__year_death=&NameSearch__year_death_accuracy=&NameSearch__year=&NameSearch__year_accuracy=&NameSearch__place=&NameSearch__place_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_birth=&NameSearch__place_birth_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_birth_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_birth_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_prewar=&NameSearch__place_prewar_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_prewar_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_prewar_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_wartime=&NameSearch__place_wartime_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_wartime_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_wartime_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__place_death=&NameSearch__place_death_accuracy=&NameSearch__place_death_IsGeoExpand_cb_1=expand&NameSearch__place_death_IsGeoExpand_cb_0=&NameSearch__meta_333=&NameSearch__meta_259=|website=United States Holocaust Memorial Museum|accessdate=29 October 2016}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|last1=Fuks|first1=comp. by L.|last2=Fuks-Mansfeld|first2=R. G.|title=Hebrew and Judaic manuscripts in Amsterdam public collections|date=1975|publisher=Brill|location=Leiden|isbn=9789004042711|page=272}}</ref> |
||
[[User:Mglxyz|Mglxyz]] ([[User talk:Mglxyz|talk]]) 01:04, 29 October 2016 (UTC) |
[[User:Mglxyz|Mglxyz]] ([[User talk:Mglxyz|talk]]) 01:04, 29 October 2016 (UTC) |
||
{{reflist talk}} |
|||
:There is no more reason to add Brazil as there is Spain or Portugal. Some editor thinks these countries have a higher than average occurrence of the surname, like Smith in the US or Patel in India. An additional paragraph on the origins of the surname, with sources, would be welcome. Most of these types of articles are just lists of people. Please don't take this personally, lot's of things added to WP incorrectly in the past, and will be in the future. There's a 12,000 article backlog to be reviewed at the moment. When I review a new addition, I try to get it right, and it helps you in the long run to be a good contributor. What we are all striving for. [[User:Cotton2|Cotton2]] ([[User talk:Cotton2|talk]]) 01:29, 29 October 2016 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 01:30, 29 October 2016
 | Text and/or other creative content from Pimentel was copied or moved into Pimentel (surname) with this edit. The former page's history now serves to provide attribution for that content in the latter page, and it must not be deleted as long as the latter page exists. |
Origins of the surname versus prevalence
"You are misreading the article. Nowhere does it state the surname originated in Brazil. It says the surname derived from a Portuguese word. I'm sure it is a surname in Brazil, maybe common." -Cotton2
This is, indeed, a surname that is common in Brazil. It can be found throughout the Americas and the world. All we could ultimately prove is that the surname is of European origin, first recorded in what is today modern Spain/Portugal (more or less "Iberia" with the exception of Andorra, etc.)
This is why it is not strange to list the surname as being of Portuguese or Spanish origin, but it is quite strange to point out only one of the many countries where this surname has spread to (Brazil). This edit was only made recently and does not provide sources either.
It is also important to revert the removal of the Sehphardi Jewish aspect of this surname. I only added references that support this association, but would be happy to do more research. [1][2] Mglxyz (talk) 01:04, 29 October 2016 (UTC)
References
- ^ "Holocaust Survivors and Victims Database". United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Retrieved 29 October 2016.
- ^ Fuks, comp. by L.; Fuks-Mansfeld, R. G. (1975). Hebrew and Judaic manuscripts in Amsterdam public collections. Leiden: Brill. p. 272. ISBN 9789004042711.
- There is no more reason to add Brazil as there is Spain or Portugal. Some editor thinks these countries have a higher than average occurrence of the surname, like Smith in the US or Patel in India. An additional paragraph on the origins of the surname, with sources, would be welcome. Most of these types of articles are just lists of people. Please don't take this personally, lot's of things added to WP incorrectly in the past, and will be in the future. There's a 12,000 article backlog to be reviewed at the moment. When I review a new addition, I try to get it right, and it helps you in the long run to be a good contributor. What we are all striving for. Cotton2 (talk) 01:29, 29 October 2016 (UTC)