Helpless (Hamilton song): Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
m →top: adjust bold |
m CQ |
||
| Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
===Historical differences=== |
===Historical differences=== |
||
Although the musical ''Hamilton'' is based on true events, Miranda does use some dramatic license in retelling the story. In the case of the song |
Although the musical ''Hamilton'' is based on true events, Miranda does use some dramatic license in retelling the story. In the case of the song "Helpless" the main differences are: |
||
*Eliza was alone in Morristown when she first met Hamilton in early February 1780, a guest of her paternal aunt Gertrude and her husband Doctor [[John Cochran (military physician) |John Cochran]].<ref name= chernow>{{cite book|last=Chernow|first=Ron|title=Alexander Hamilton|publisher=Penguin Books|isbn=978-1-59420-009-0|year=2004}}, chapter "The Lovesick Colonel"</ref> |
*Eliza was alone in Morristown when she first met Hamilton in early February 1780, a guest of her paternal aunt Gertrude and her husband Doctor [[John Cochran (military physician) |John Cochran]].<ref name= chernow>{{cite book|last=Chernow|first=Ron|title=Alexander Hamilton|publisher=Penguin Books|isbn=978-1-59420-009-0|year=2004}}, chapter "The Lovesick Colonel"</ref> |
||
*Angelica had eloped and got married with [[John Barker Church]] 3 years before she first met Hamilton at her |
*Angelica had eloped and got married with [[John Barker Church]] 3 years before she first met Hamilton at her sister's wedding in December 1780, when she was already mother of 2 of her 8 children with Church. <ref name= chernow>{{cite book|last=Chernow|first=Ron|title=Alexander Hamilton|publisher=Penguin Books|isbn=978-1-59420-009-0|year=2004}}, chapter "The Lovesick Colonel"</ref> |
||
==Style== |
==Style== |
||
''[[The Huffington Post|Huffington Post]]'' described the song as "equal parts [[Cole Porter]] and [[Ja Rule]], a sweet [[Pop music|Pop]]/[[Rhythm and blues|R&B]] tune".<ref name="huffingtonpost.com">{{cite web|url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-logan/i-have-an-opinion-on-ever_b_8223496.html|title=I Have an Opinion on Every Song in "Hamilton"|date=1 October 2015|work=The Huffington Post}}</ref> [[Phillipa Soo]] said that inspirations for the song include [[Beyoncé]], [[Alicia Keys]], and [[Etta James]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.refinery29.com/2015/09/94375/on-the-verge-phillipa-soo-hamilton-star|title=Phillipa Soo Alexander Hamilton Hip Hop Musical|author=Esther Zuckerman|date=25 September 2015|work=Refinery29}}</ref> Musical director [[Alex Lacamoire]] explained "The Beyoncé reference is 'Stressin'! Blessin'!' sounds like 'Houston rocket!' [in "[[Countdown (Beyoncé song)|Countdown]]"]. We asked the girls to deliver it like that."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.vulture.com/2016/01/hamilton-alex-lacamoire-interview.html|title=Nerding Out With |
''[[The Huffington Post|Huffington Post]]'' described the song as "equal parts [[Cole Porter]] and [[Ja Rule]], a sweet [[Pop music|Pop]]/[[Rhythm and blues|R&B]] tune".<ref name="huffingtonpost.com">{{cite web|url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-logan/i-have-an-opinion-on-ever_b_8223496.html|title=I Have an Opinion on Every Song in "Hamilton"|date=1 October 2015|work=The Huffington Post}}</ref> [[Phillipa Soo]] said that inspirations for the song include [[Beyoncé]], [[Alicia Keys]], and [[Etta James]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.refinery29.com/2015/09/94375/on-the-verge-phillipa-soo-hamilton-star|title=Phillipa Soo Alexander Hamilton Hip Hop Musical|author=Esther Zuckerman|date=25 September 2015|work=Refinery29}}</ref> Musical director [[Alex Lacamoire]] explained "The Beyoncé reference is 'Stressin'! Blessin'!' sounds like 'Houston rocket!' [in "[[Countdown (Beyoncé song)|Countdown]]"]. We asked the girls to deliver it like that."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.vulture.com/2016/01/hamilton-alex-lacamoire-interview.html|title=Nerding Out With Hamilton's Musical Director -- Vulture|work=Vulture}}</ref> ''[[Slate (magazine)|Slate]]'' said the "big R&B love song" drew inspiration from Beyoncé's "Countdown" due to its "half-rapped, half-sung cadences", and added that the lyrics "the boy is mine" is a lyrical reference to a [[The Boy Is Mine (song)|song of the same name]] by [[Brandy Norwood|Brandy]] and [[Monica (singer)|Monica]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2015/09/24/hamilton_s_hip_hop_references_all_the_rap_and_r_b_allusions_in_lin_manuel.html|title=Hamilton's hip-hop references: All the rap and R&B allusions in Lin-Manuel Miranda's Broadway musical.|work=Slate Magazine}}</ref> According to [[NPR]], the song also includes a [[hip hop]] reference in the form of a lyrical nod to [[Trina]] and [[Mannie Fresh]]'s song "Da Club."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.npr.org/2015/09/21/440925873/first-listen-cast-recording-hamilton|title=Review: Cast Recording, 'Hamilton'|date=21 September 2015|work=NPR.org}}</ref> GCAdvocate notes that in "[[Satisfied (Hamilton song)|Satisfied]]," Eliza's "assertive, clever sister [[Angelica Schuyler Church|Angelica Schuyler]] raps and remixes"Helpless".<ref name="gcadvocate.com">{{cite web|url=http://gcadvocate.com/2015/11/16/racializing-the-american-revolution-review-of-the-broadway-musical-hamilton/|title=Racializing the American Revolution Review of the Broadway Musical Hamilton - The Advocate|work=The Advocate}}</ref> The [[Los Angeles Times|LA Times]] said the song had "the flair of [[Destiny's Child]]".<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/arts/la-ca-cm-hamilton-hip-hop-notebook-20151031-column.html|title=Review: 'Hamilton' is a watershed musical that sets a Founding Father's tale to hip-hop - LA Times|author=Los Angeles Times|date=4 November 2015|work=latimes.com}}</ref> The Man Eater also likens Eliza's vocal stylings to "the style of Beyoncé".<ref>{{cite web|url=http://move.themaneater.com/stories/2015/10/14/hamilton-cast-album-remember/#.VuGAHPl97IU|title='Hamilton' is a cast album to remember – MOVE Magazine|publisher=}}</ref> |
||
==Critical reception== |
==Critical reception== |
||
The ''Huffington Post'' wrote that the song "manages to combine banter, storytelling, and Alexander mentioning again how smart he is".<ref name="huffingtonpost.com"/> GCAdvocate was impressed that " |
The ''Huffington Post'' wrote that the song "manages to combine banter, storytelling, and Alexander mentioning again how smart he is".<ref name="huffingtonpost.com"/> GCAdvocate was impressed that "Soo's repetitive 'I do''s in the pop song foreshadows their wedding" which occurs at the end of the song.<ref name="gcadvocate.com"/> ''[[The Hollywood Reporter]]'' wrote that "'Helpless' measures up to the most irresistible pop songs about love at first sight in the way it captures the sheer giddiness and joy of a romantic thunderbolt".<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/critics-notebook-why-hamilton-counts-818677|title=Critic's Notebook: Why 'Hamilton' Counts as a Legitimate Game Changer|author=David Rooney|date=31 August 2015|work=The Hollywood Reporter}}</ref> [[The Washington Post|The ''Washington Post'']] said the song was "a divinely refined [[Girl group|girl-group]] treatment of Hamilton's courtship of Eliza".<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/theater_dance/hamilton-making-ecstatic-history/2015/08/06/6bc85fb4-3b72-11e5-8e98-115a3cf7d7ae_story.html|title='Hamilton': Making ecstatic history|author=Peter Marks|date=6 August 2015|work=Washington Post}}</ref> ''[[The American Conservative]]'' said the song is "a gorgeous song where helplessness is a child's terror but also a lover's rapture".<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/hamilton-and-the-romance-of-government/|title='Hamilton' and the Romance of Government|work=The American Conservative}}</ref> |
||
== ''Hamilton Mixtape'' version == |
== ''Hamilton Mixtape'' version == |
||
"Helpless" is performed on ''[[The Hamilton Mixtape]]'' by [[Ashanti (singer)|Ashanti]] and [[Ja Rule]], both of whom Miranda cites as inspirations for the composition of the song. |
"Helpless" is performed on ''[[The Hamilton Mixtape]]'' by [[Ashanti (singer)|Ashanti]] and [[Ja Rule]], both of whom Miranda cites as inspirations for the composition of the song. |
||
"Ashanti and Ja Rule were in my head when I was writing 'Helpless,'" Miranda told ''[[Entertainment Weekly]]''. "It has the structure of an Ashanti-Ja Rule song: two verses, two choruses, a guest rap feature, then back to the chorus and around." |
|||
Of getting Ashanti and Ja Rule to perform the song for the mixtape, producer Ahmir |
Of getting Ashanti and Ja Rule to perform the song for the mixtape, producer Ahmir "Questlove" Thompson told the magazine: <blockquote>"When it came down to figuring out these songs [on the ''Mixtape''], I was just like, 'Dude, this is the white elephant in the room: Are you guys really not gonna go after Ja Rule and Ashanti?' You ''wrote'' it for them. You might as well just have them do it.'" When they agreed, Thompson says, "I was happy as hell."<ref>{{Cite news|url=http://www.ew.com/article/2016/11/30/hamilton-mixtape-lin-manuel-miranda-stories-songs|title=Inside the Making of 'The Hamilton Mixtape'|newspaper=Entertainment Weekly's EW.com|access-date=2016-12-03}}</ref></blockquote> |
||
==References== |
==References== |
||
Revision as of 08:19, 29 November 2017
| "Helpless" | |
|---|---|
| Song |
"Helpless" is the tenth song from Act 1 of the musical Hamilton, based on the life of Alexander Hamilton, which premiered on Broadway in 2015. Lin-Manuel Miranda wrote both the music and lyrics to the song.
Synopsis
This song focuses on the romance and eventual wedding of Eliza Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton. Eliza is introduced to Hamilton by her sister Angelica during a ball held while the Army is stationed in Morristown for the Winter in early 1780. They immediately start a correspondence and Hamilton wastes no time in asking Eliza's father Philip Schuyler for his permission to marry his daughter, which is granted. Hamilton shares with Eliza his concerns regarding his orphanhood and lack of wealth and station, but Eliza dismisses them and the song ends on the notes of the nuptial march played at their wedding.
Historical differences
Although the musical Hamilton is based on true events, Miranda does use some dramatic license in retelling the story. In the case of the song "Helpless" the main differences are:
- Eliza was alone in Morristown when she first met Hamilton in early February 1780, a guest of her paternal aunt Gertrude and her husband Doctor John Cochran.[1]
- Angelica had eloped and got married with John Barker Church 3 years before she first met Hamilton at her sister's wedding in December 1780, when she was already mother of 2 of her 8 children with Church. [1]
Style
Huffington Post described the song as "equal parts Cole Porter and Ja Rule, a sweet Pop/R&B tune".[2] Phillipa Soo said that inspirations for the song include Beyoncé, Alicia Keys, and Etta James.[3] Musical director Alex Lacamoire explained "The Beyoncé reference is 'Stressin'! Blessin'!' sounds like 'Houston rocket!' [in "Countdown"]. We asked the girls to deliver it like that."[4] Slate said the "big R&B love song" drew inspiration from Beyoncé's "Countdown" due to its "half-rapped, half-sung cadences", and added that the lyrics "the boy is mine" is a lyrical reference to a song of the same name by Brandy and Monica.[5] According to NPR, the song also includes a hip hop reference in the form of a lyrical nod to Trina and Mannie Fresh's song "Da Club."[6] GCAdvocate notes that in "Satisfied," Eliza's "assertive, clever sister Angelica Schuyler raps and remixes"Helpless".[7] The LA Times said the song had "the flair of Destiny's Child".[8] The Man Eater also likens Eliza's vocal stylings to "the style of Beyoncé".[9]
Critical reception
The Huffington Post wrote that the song "manages to combine banter, storytelling, and Alexander mentioning again how smart he is".[2] GCAdvocate was impressed that "Soo's repetitive 'I dos in the pop song foreshadows their wedding" which occurs at the end of the song.[7] The Hollywood Reporter wrote that "'Helpless' measures up to the most irresistible pop songs about love at first sight in the way it captures the sheer giddiness and joy of a romantic thunderbolt".[10] The Washington Post said the song was "a divinely refined girl-group treatment of Hamilton's courtship of Eliza".[11] The American Conservative said the song is "a gorgeous song where helplessness is a child's terror but also a lover's rapture".[12]
Hamilton Mixtape version
"Helpless" is performed on The Hamilton Mixtape by Ashanti and Ja Rule, both of whom Miranda cites as inspirations for the composition of the song.
"Ashanti and Ja Rule were in my head when I was writing 'Helpless,'" Miranda told Entertainment Weekly. "It has the structure of an Ashanti-Ja Rule song: two verses, two choruses, a guest rap feature, then back to the chorus and around."
Of getting Ashanti and Ja Rule to perform the song for the mixtape, producer Ahmir "Questlove" Thompson told the magazine:
"When it came down to figuring out these songs [on the Mixtape], I was just like, 'Dude, this is the white elephant in the room: Are you guys really not gonna go after Ja Rule and Ashanti?' You wrote it for them. You might as well just have them do it.'" When they agreed, Thompson says, "I was happy as hell."[13]
References
- ^ a b Chernow, Ron (2004). Alexander Hamilton. Penguin Books. ISBN 978-1-59420-009-0., chapter "The Lovesick Colonel"
- ^ a b "I Have an Opinion on Every Song in "Hamilton"". The Huffington Post. 1 October 2015.
- ^ Esther Zuckerman (25 September 2015). "Phillipa Soo Alexander Hamilton Hip Hop Musical". Refinery29.
- ^ "Nerding Out With Hamilton's Musical Director -- Vulture". Vulture.
- ^ "Hamilton's hip-hop references: All the rap and R&B allusions in Lin-Manuel Miranda's Broadway musical". Slate Magazine.
- ^ "Review: Cast Recording, 'Hamilton'". NPR.org. 21 September 2015.
- ^ a b "Racializing the American Revolution Review of the Broadway Musical Hamilton - The Advocate". The Advocate.
- ^ Los Angeles Times (4 November 2015). "Review: 'Hamilton' is a watershed musical that sets a Founding Father's tale to hip-hop - LA Times". latimes.com.
- ^ "'Hamilton' is a cast album to remember – MOVE Magazine".
- ^ David Rooney (31 August 2015). "Critic's Notebook: Why 'Hamilton' Counts as a Legitimate Game Changer". The Hollywood Reporter.
- ^ Peter Marks (6 August 2015). "'Hamilton': Making ecstatic history". Washington Post.
- ^ "'Hamilton' and the Romance of Government". The American Conservative.
- ^ "Inside the Making of 'The Hamilton Mixtape'". Entertainment Weekly's EW.com. Retrieved 2016-12-03.