Jump to content

No Heaven for Gunga Din: Difference between revisions

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
m Removed deprecated parameter(s) from Template:Div col using DeprecatedFixerBot. Questions? See Template:Div col#Usage of "cols" parameter or msg TSD! (please mention that this is task #2!))
Use harvard citation rather than acronym NHfGD for book
Line 16: Line 16:
| congress =
| congress =
}}
}}
'''''No Heaven for Gunga Din; consisting of The British and American Officer's Book''''', is a fable by [[Ali Mirdrekvandi]]<ref>"Mirdrekvandi" is the publisher's spelling, corresponding to Ali's own spelling in manuscript ({{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|p=3}}). {{Harvtxt|Zaehner|1965}} and {{Harvtxt|Motamedi-Fraser|2013}} use "Mirdrakvandi". The English sub-titles in the documentary {{Harv|Nematpour|2013}} show several variations ("Ali Mirderikvandi", "Mir Derkvandi"), but says "Ali Derikvandi" is his real name. The documentary also shows an envelope with the author's own spelling: "Mir Drekvandi-Ali". It appears that "Mir" is actually a title, equivalent to "Mr." in English, "Drekvandi" (or "Derikvandi") means "from the Derikvand tribe", with "Ali" being his personal name.</ref> (but who "preferred to be called Gunga Din"<ref>From the book (p. 7) hereafter cited as "'''NHfGD'''". "Gunga Din" is from the name of the Indian water-carrier portrayed in the [[Gunga Din|poem]] of the same name by [[Rudyard Kipling]]. Poem and book have a common theme regarding the treatment of native servants by colonial military officers.</ref>), edited by John Hemming, who also wrote the introduction. Published in 1965 by [[Victor Gollancz Ltd]] (London) and [[E. P. Dutton|E. P. Dutton &amp; Company]] (New York), and in six other languages.<ref>Hindi, Japanese, Swedish, French, German, and Persian, according to {{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref>
'''''No Heaven for Gunga Din; consisting of The British and American Officer's Book''''', is a fable by [[Ali Mirdrekvandi]]<ref>"Mirdrekvandi" is the publisher's spelling, corresponding to Ali's own spelling in manuscript ({{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|p=3}}). {{Harvtxt|Zaehner|1965}} and {{Harvtxt|Motamedi-Fraser|2013}} use "Mirdrakvandi". The English sub-titles in the documentary {{Harv|Nematpour|2013}} show several variations ("Ali Mirderikvandi", "Mir Derkvandi"), but says "Ali Derikvandi" is his real name. The documentary also shows an envelope with the author's own spelling: "Mir Drekvandi-Ali". It appears that "Mir" is actually a title, equivalent to "Mr." in English, "Drekvandi" (or "Derikvandi") means "from the Derikvand tribe", with "Ali" being his personal name.</ref> (but who "preferred to be called Gunga Din"<ref>{{harvnb|Mirdrekvandi|1965|p=7}}. "Gunga Din" is from the name of the Indian water-carrier portrayed in the [[Gunga Din|poem]] of the same name by [[Rudyard Kipling]]. Poem and book have a common theme regarding the treatment of native servants by colonial military officers.</ref>), edited by John Hemming, who also wrote the introduction. Published in 1965 by [[Victor Gollancz Ltd]] (London) and [[E. P. Dutton|E. P. Dutton &amp; Company]] (New York), and in six other languages.<ref>Hindi, Japanese, Swedish, French, German, and Persian, according to {{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref>


In the foreword Professor [[Robert Charles Zaehner|R. C. Zaehner]] (of All Souls College, Oxford) says Ali Mirdrekvandi was an Iranian peasant who had taught himself to read and write [[Persian language|Persian]], and then English when British and American troops arrived during World War II.<ref>{{Harvnb|NHfGD|p=7}}.</ref> The book's author is the subject of a 2013 documentary by Gholamreza Nematpour.<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref>
In the foreword Professor [[Robert Charles Zaehner|R. C. Zaehner]] (of All Souls College, Oxford) says Ali Mirdrekvandi was an Iranian peasant who had taught himself to read and write [[Persian language|Persian]], and then English when British and American troops arrived during World War II.{{sfn|Mirdrekvandi|1965|p=7}} The book's author is the subject of a 2013 documentary by Gholamreza Nematpour.<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref>


==Author==
==Author==
{{Main|Ali Mirdrekvandi}}
{{Main|Ali Mirdrekvandi}}
''The British and American Officer's Book'' was written by Mirdrekvandi while working at an officers' mess in Tehran during World War II, then given to Hemming (then a British officer), who was mentoring him.<ref>{{Harvnb|NHfGD|pp=19–20}}.</ref> Hemming's last contact with Mirdrekvandi was in 1949. At the time of publication the author's history and current circumstances were unknown.<ref>{{Harvnb|NHfGD|p=8}}.</ref> Some sources have asserted that Mirdrekvandi was fictional, and the story actually written by Hemming or Zaehner.<ref>{{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|pp=10–11}}. Zaehner is said to have been involved in the 1953 coup against [[Mohammad Mossadegh]] by the British and American governments. {{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|p=14}}.</ref>
''The British and American Officer's Book'' was written by Mirdrekvandi while working at an officers' mess in Tehran during World War II, then given to Hemming (then a British officer), who was mentoring him.{{sfn|Mirdrekvandi|1965|pp=19–20}} Hemming's last contact with Mirdrekvandi was in 1949. At the time of publication the author's history and current circumstances were unknown.{{sfn|Mirdrekvandi|1965|p=8}} Some sources have asserted that Mirdrekvandi was fictional, and the story actually written by Hemming or Zaehner.<ref>{{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|pp=10–11}}. Zaehner is said to have been involved in the 1953 coup against [[Mohammad Mossadegh]] by the British and American governments. {{Harvnb|Motamedi-Fraser|2013|p=14}}.</ref>


On publication of the book in 1965 the Iranian press instituted a public search for Mirdrekvandi, characterized as a "missing millionaire".<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}. The actual book royalties being held for him came to {{GBP|2,248|link=yes}}, less costs.</ref> His brother, a former classmate, and others who recalled him were found, with the additional information that was he born some time in 1916–1918 in a village in [[Lorestan Province]] in western Iran.<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref> According to one source<ref>Phillip Kreyenbroek, in {{Harvnb|Zaehner|1992|p=65}}.</ref> he was raised by his grandfather after his parents were "taken away by soldiers" and never heard of again. This would have been around the time the [[Pahlavi dynasty]] had crushed a rebellion by the nomadic Lurs of [[Lorestan#History|Lorestan]]. Young Ali's talents were noted, and he was sent to a school for sons of tribal leaders to "not to learn banditry and robbery."<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref> He reportedly left school after a dispute with the son of the school director, and was working for a railway when [[Anglo-Soviet Invasion of Iran|British and Soviet forces entered Iran]] at the beginning of World War II.
On publication of the book in 1965 the Iranian press instituted a public search for Mirdrekvandi, characterized as a "missing millionaire".<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}. The actual book royalties being held for him came to {{GBP|2,248|link=yes}}, less costs.</ref> His brother, a former classmate, and others who recalled him were found, with the additional information that was he born some time in 1916–1918 in a village in [[Lorestan Province]] in western Iran.<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref> According to one source<ref>Phillip Kreyenbroek, in {{Harvnb|Zaehner|1992|p=65}}.</ref> he was raised by his grandfather after his parents were "taken away by soldiers" and never heard of again. This would have been around the time the [[Pahlavi dynasty]] had crushed a rebellion by the nomadic Lurs of [[Lorestan#History|Lorestan]]. Young Ali's talents were noted, and he was sent to a school for sons of tribal leaders to "not to learn banditry and robbery."<ref>{{Harvnb|Nematpour|2013}}.</ref> He reportedly left school after a dispute with the son of the school director, and was working for a railway when [[Anglo-Soviet Invasion of Iran|British and Soviet forces entered Iran]] at the beginning of World War II.
Line 29: Line 29:


== Story ==
== Story ==
The story is told in somewhat broken English with an often curious choice of words (such as "steepy" for a steep place<ref>Zaehner suggests that Mirdrekvandi's odd language was not so much from ignorance as "he just thought his own way of saying things was better." {{Harvnb|NHfGD|p=7}}</ref>). Mirdrekvandi's English has been described as "often very comic, ... almost always felicitous."<ref>{{Harvnb|Zaehner|1992|p=75}}.</ref> The story lacks the sophisticated style of modern writing, being more like the narrative style of ancient ballads.
The story is told in somewhat broken English with an often curious choice of words (such as "steepy" for a steep place<ref>Zaehner suggests that Mirdrekvandi's odd language was not so much from ignorance as "he just thought his own way of saying things was better." {{harvnb|Mirdrekvandi|1965|p=7}}</ref>). Mirdrekvandi's English has been described as "often very comic, ... almost always felicitous."<ref>{{Harvnb|Zaehner|1992|p=75}}.</ref> The story lacks the sophisticated style of modern writing, being more like the narrative style of ancient ballads.


The story has been described as "a kind of [[Pilgrim's Progress]]"<ref>{{Harvnb|NHfGD}}, back cover.</ref> as the 82 officers trek across the Milky Way seeking Heaven "with General Burke their commander in their front and Gunga Din their servant in their behind."<ref>{{Harvnb|NHfGD|p=27}}.</ref> Along the way various stories are told, such as the traveler who, wanting to see how blind people walk, closed his eyes for a section, and so missed some money certain angels had left on the side of the road for him.
The story has been described as "a kind of [[Pilgrim's Progress]]"{{sfn|Mirdrekvandi|1965|loc=back cover}} as the 82 officers trek across the Milky Way seeking Heaven "with General Burke their commander in their front and Gunga Din their servant in their behind."{{sfn|Mirdrekvandi|1965|p=27}} Along the way various stories are told, such as the traveler who, wanting to see how blind people walk, closed his eyes for a section, and so missed some money certain angels had left on the side of the road for him.


When they reach the gate of Heaven they find it is guarded by M.P.s (Military Police), who prevent them from entering without Freedom Passes. For these they must go to the Judgement-Field and be judged. Fearing they will be condemned to Hell they become outlaws in a forest on the border of Heaven, giving the Heaven M.P.s much trouble for eight years. Eventually [[Adam]] is asked to deal with his children, and he arranges for them to be judged.
When they reach the gate of Heaven they find it is guarded by M.P.s (Military Police), who prevent them from entering without Freedom Passes. For these they must go to the Judgement-Field and be judged. Fearing they will be condemned to Hell they become outlaws in a forest on the border of Heaven, giving the Heaven M.P.s much trouble for eight years. Eventually [[Adam]] is asked to deal with his children, and he arranges for them to be judged.
Line 45: Line 45:


*{{Cite book
*{{Cite book
|ref= CITEREFNHfGD
|ref=harv
|first1= Ali |last1= Mirdrekvandi
|first1= Ali |last1= Mirdrekvandi
|date= 1965
|date= 1965

Revision as of 10:32, 30 July 2018

Cover of Dutton edition
AuthorAli Mirdrekvandi
علی میردریکوندی
Cover artistLeo and Diane Dillon
LanguageEnglish
GenreFable
Published1965 (E. P. Dutton & Company)
Pages128
OCLC366963

No Heaven for Gunga Din; consisting of The British and American Officer's Book, is a fable by Ali Mirdrekvandi[1] (but who "preferred to be called Gunga Din"[2]), edited by John Hemming, who also wrote the introduction. Published in 1965 by Victor Gollancz Ltd (London) and E. P. Dutton & Company (New York), and in six other languages.[3]

In the foreword Professor R. C. Zaehner (of All Souls College, Oxford) says Ali Mirdrekvandi was an Iranian peasant who had taught himself to read and write Persian, and then English when British and American troops arrived during World War II.[4] The book's author is the subject of a 2013 documentary by Gholamreza Nematpour.[5]

Author

Main article: Ali Mirdrekvandi

The British and American Officer's Book was written by Mirdrekvandi while working at an officers' mess in Tehran during World War II, then given to Hemming (then a British officer), who was mentoring him.[6] Hemming's last contact with Mirdrekvandi was in 1949. At the time of publication the author's history and current circumstances were unknown.[7] Some sources have asserted that Mirdrekvandi was fictional, and the story actually written by Hemming or Zaehner.[8]

On publication of the book in 1965 the Iranian press instituted a public search for Mirdrekvandi, characterized as a "missing millionaire".[9] His brother, a former classmate, and others who recalled him were found, with the additional information that was he born some time in 1916–1918 in a village in Lorestan Province in western Iran.[10] According to one source[11] he was raised by his grandfather after his parents were "taken away by soldiers" and never heard of again. This would have been around the time the Pahlavi dynasty had crushed a rebellion by the nomadic Lurs of Lorestan. Young Ali's talents were noted, and he was sent to a school for sons of tribal leaders to "not to learn banditry and robbery."[12] He reportedly left school after a dispute with the son of the school director, and was working for a railway when British and Soviet forces entered Iran at the beginning of World War II.

It was subsequently discovered that Derikvandi had been living in impoverished circumstances in the town of Borujerd, where he was notable for reading many English language books. He is reported as having died on November 26, 1964, just prior to the publication of his book.[13]

Story

The story is told in somewhat broken English with an often curious choice of words (such as "steepy" for a steep place[14]). Mirdrekvandi's English has been described as "often very comic, ... almost always felicitous."[15] The story lacks the sophisticated style of modern writing, being more like the narrative style of ancient ballads.

The story has been described as "a kind of Pilgrim's Progress"[16] as the 82 officers trek across the Milky Way seeking Heaven "with General Burke their commander in their front and Gunga Din their servant in their behind."[17] Along the way various stories are told, such as the traveler who, wanting to see how blind people walk, closed his eyes for a section, and so missed some money certain angels had left on the side of the road for him.

When they reach the gate of Heaven they find it is guarded by M.P.s (Military Police), who prevent them from entering without Freedom Passes. For these they must go to the Judgement-Field and be judged. Fearing they will be condemned to Hell they become outlaws in a forest on the border of Heaven, giving the Heaven M.P.s much trouble for eight years. Eventually Adam is asked to deal with his children, and he arranges for them to be judged.

At the Judgement Field the officers' sins are forgiven on the condition of spending 14 minutes in purgatory. Gunga Din, however, is condemned to Hell for forty earthly years. After suffering bad dreams the officers appeal on his behalf. The story ends with the Children of Man agitating for changes in how Heaven and Hell are run.

Notes

  1. ^ "Mirdrekvandi" is the publisher's spelling, corresponding to Ali's own spelling in manuscript (Motamedi-Fraser 2013, p. 3). Zaehner (1965) and Motamedi-Fraser (2013) use "Mirdrakvandi". The English sub-titles in the documentary (Nematpour 2013) show several variations ("Ali Mirderikvandi", "Mir Derkvandi"), but says "Ali Derikvandi" is his real name. The documentary also shows an envelope with the author's own spelling: "Mir Drekvandi-Ali". It appears that "Mir" is actually a title, equivalent to "Mr." in English, "Drekvandi" (or "Derikvandi") means "from the Derikvand tribe", with "Ali" being his personal name.
  2. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, p. 7. "Gunga Din" is from the name of the Indian water-carrier portrayed in the poem of the same name by Rudyard Kipling. Poem and book have a common theme regarding the treatment of native servants by colonial military officers.
  3. ^ Hindi, Japanese, Swedish, French, German, and Persian, according to Nematpour 2013.
  4. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, p. 7.
  5. ^ Nematpour 2013.
  6. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, pp. 19–20.
  7. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, p. 8.
  8. ^ Motamedi-Fraser 2013, pp. 10–11. Zaehner is said to have been involved in the 1953 coup against Mohammad Mossadegh by the British and American governments. Motamedi-Fraser 2013, p. 14.
  9. ^ Nematpour 2013. The actual book royalties being held for him came to £2,248, less costs.
  10. ^ Nematpour 2013.
  11. ^ Phillip Kreyenbroek, in Zaehner 1992, p. 65.
  12. ^ Nematpour 2013.
  13. ^ Nematpour 2013.
  14. ^ Zaehner suggests that Mirdrekvandi's odd language was not so much from ignorance as "he just thought his own way of saying things was better." Mirdrekvandi 1965, p. 7
  15. ^ Zaehner 1992, p. 75.
  16. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, back cover.
  17. ^ Mirdrekvandi 1965, p. 27.

Sources

  • Mirdrekvandi, Ali (1965). No Heaven for Gunga Din. E. P. Dutton & Company. LCCN 65023748. {{cite book}}: Invalid |ref=harv (help) Edited and introduction by John Hemming, foreword by Professor R. C. Zaehner.

Book reviews

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=No_Heaven_for_Gunga_Din&oldid=852636944"