Talk:Les Six: Difference between revisions
details on this plagiarization? (DW wrote this article, by the way...) |
Boeuf sur le toit? |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
:You mean the content of this article is a direct copy of those liner notes? Is it the entire article that has been copied, or just a portion? If I'm understanding you correctly, then whatever has been copied certainly needs to be taken out of this article - that CD came out before this article was started (at least according to [http://classical.onino.co.uk/classical/durey_songs.html], the CD came out in May 2002; our article was started November of that year), so there's no doubt that it has been copied from there, I'm afraid. --[[User:Camembert|Camembert]] |
:You mean the content of this article is a direct copy of those liner notes? Is it the entire article that has been copied, or just a portion? If I'm understanding you correctly, then whatever has been copied certainly needs to be taken out of this article - that CD came out before this article was started (at least according to [http://classical.onino.co.uk/classical/durey_songs.html], the CD came out in May 2002; our article was started November of that year), so there's no doubt that it has been copied from there, I'm afraid. --[[User:Camembert|Camembert]] |
||
---- |
|||
Regarding ''Le boeuf sur le toit'': I thought the composition was named after the bar and not the other way around? Could somebody confirm this? --[[User:Francis Schonken|Francis Schonken]] 10:36, 21 Jul 2004 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 10:36, 21 July 2004
A very well written page - a model to most of us! User:David Martland
Isn't it more of a famous painting than a famous photo? User:Aezram
- Indeed it is - I've changed the wording. Does anybody know who the painting is by? It would be good to add that info. --Camembert
Well written - a model to most of us? My God, don't tell Zoe, she helped get the writer banned because she didn't like how he did his pages! 64.228.30.74 04:37 10 Jun 2003 (UTC)
- Not liking how somebody "does" "their" pages is not a reason to be banned, and it wasn't the reason in this case. This user was banned for a number of reasons, not least among them his extremely aggressive attitude which led to him calling all sorts of people all sorts of names. He's still banned, incidentally. --Camembert
He's the same guy that User:Ortolan88 also said created a model page for his List of Famous Canadians. But, I read where he called someone a moron. Unacceptable, there is no one at Wikipedia who ever demonstrated that kind of intellect. Sure is a good thing you got rid of that abuser before he screwed things up and made more "model pages." 64.228.30.30 03:46 11 Jun 2003 (UTC)
The information for the painting is as follows:
1. Le Groupe des Six, 1922 by Jacques-Emile Blanche. In the center, pianist Marcelle Meyer; from bottom to top: Germaine Tailleferre, Darius Milhaud, Arthur Honegger, Jean Wiener; on the right: Georges Auric, Francis Poulenc, Jean Cocteau. Here Jean Wiener, pianist, replaces Louis Durey who left the group in 1921.
Information describing Les Six is taken directly from the liner notes for Graham Johnson and Francois Le Roux's Hyperion CD: Songs by Louis Durey. Who, exactly, is plagiarizing whom?
- You mean the content of this article is a direct copy of those liner notes? Is it the entire article that has been copied, or just a portion? If I'm understanding you correctly, then whatever has been copied certainly needs to be taken out of this article - that CD came out before this article was started (at least according to [1], the CD came out in May 2002; our article was started November of that year), so there's no doubt that it has been copied from there, I'm afraid. --Camembert
Regarding Le boeuf sur le toit: I thought the composition was named after the bar and not the other way around? Could somebody confirm this? --Francis Schonken 10:36, 21 Jul 2004 (UTC)