Talk:Gregory method: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
←Created page with 'Should this be a redirect to the single transferable vote page? The Gregory method is also quite a common term for determining climate sensitivity. I'm not s...' |
A proposal / draft to have a separate page that describes the Gregory method in regard to Single Transferable Vote |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Should this be a redirect to the single transferable vote page? The Gregory method is also quite a common term for determining [[climate sensitivity]]. I'm not sure whether one of the two is more common than the other one. If they are approximately equally common, this should be a disambiguation page, right? [[User:Femkemilene|Femke Nijsse]] ([[User talk:Femkemilene|talk]]) 08:52, 26 March 2019 (UTC) |
Should this be a redirect to the single transferable vote page? The Gregory method is also quite a common term for determining [[climate sensitivity]]. I'm not sure whether one of the two is more common than the other one. If they are approximately equally common, this should be a disambiguation page, right? [[User:Femkemilene|Femke Nijsse]] ([[User talk:Femkemilene|talk]]) 08:52, 26 March 2019 (UTC) |
||
I agree that Gregory method in regard to STV shall deserve its own page, since there are multiple variations of this method used in practice, such as Tasmanian Hare-Clark ( a.k.a. "simple Gregory" ), "inclusive Gregory" used at present in Australian Senate, and "weighted inclusive Gregory", which, if I'm not mistaken, is at present in use in Western Australia. |
|||
Such a page shall supposedly: |
|||
* describe the difference in these variations, possibly suggesting an explanation why these may exist ( in essence, the correct way to do calculations is the Weighted Gregory Method, however, it is rather difficult for manual calculations without a computer, and therefore various approximations exist historically ) |
|||
* clear any possible confusion in terminology: e.g. there is a Hare-Clark ''electoral system'', which uses Clark's variation of the Hare method in regard to transferring ''surplus votes'' -- and is based on the method suggested by J.B. Gregory ( as ascribed by E.J. Nanson ); furthermore, it uses a so-called "simplified" Gregory method, based on Droop's suggestion ( not to be confused with ''Droop quota'' ), see below ; |
|||
* do proper internal linking ( e.f. refer to [[ Hare–Clark_electoral_system | Hare-Clark page ]], [[ Counting_single_transferable_votes | STV counting ]], [[ History_and_use_of_the_single_transferable_vote#Australia | Australian section ]] on the page describing the history of the Single Transferable Vote, and may be some other pages referred in the latter section. |
|||
* add external links as well -- most importantly to [http://www.prsa.org.au/tas_poll_report_1909.pdf ''section 20'' of Tasmanian Report of Committee on General Election 1909 ], which explains "the last parcel" method and gives the necessary attributions, -- along with other important references from [http://www.prsa.org.au www.prsa.org.au] ( e.g. [http://www.prsa.org.au/gregoryj.htm#original 1 ] , [https://www.prsa.org.au/hareclar.htm 2 ], [https://www.prsa.org.au/history.htm 3 ], etc ) |
|||
--[[User:Thread13|Thread13]] ([[User talk:Thread13|talk]]) 02:25, 30 July 2019 (UTC) |
|||
Latest revision as of 02:25, 30 July 2019
Should this be a redirect to the single transferable vote page? The Gregory method is also quite a common term for determining climate sensitivity. I'm not sure whether one of the two is more common than the other one. If they are approximately equally common, this should be a disambiguation page, right? Femke Nijsse (talk) 08:52, 26 March 2019 (UTC)
I agree that Gregory method in regard to STV shall deserve its own page, since there are multiple variations of this method used in practice, such as Tasmanian Hare-Clark ( a.k.a. "simple Gregory" ), "inclusive Gregory" used at present in Australian Senate, and "weighted inclusive Gregory", which, if I'm not mistaken, is at present in use in Western Australia.
Such a page shall supposedly:
- describe the difference in these variations, possibly suggesting an explanation why these may exist ( in essence, the correct way to do calculations is the Weighted Gregory Method, however, it is rather difficult for manual calculations without a computer, and therefore various approximations exist historically )
- clear any possible confusion in terminology: e.g. there is a Hare-Clark electoral system, which uses Clark's variation of the Hare method in regard to transferring surplus votes -- and is based on the method suggested by J.B. Gregory ( as ascribed by E.J. Nanson ); furthermore, it uses a so-called "simplified" Gregory method, based on Droop's suggestion ( not to be confused with Droop quota ), see below ;
- do proper internal linking ( e.f. refer to Hare-Clark page , STV counting , Australian section on the page describing the history of the Single Transferable Vote, and may be some other pages referred in the latter section.
- add external links as well -- most importantly to section 20 of Tasmanian Report of Committee on General Election 1909 , which explains "the last parcel" method and gives the necessary attributions, -- along with other important references from www.prsa.org.au ( e.g. 1 , 2 , 3 , etc )