Jump to content

Talk:Violence against women in Ukraine: Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Piramidion (talk | contribs)
Piramidion (talk | contribs)
Line 11: Line 11:
Also the first sentence of the lead section seems to be misinterpreting the source, here's an abstract:
Also the first sentence of the lead section seems to be misinterpreting the source, here's an abstract:
{{tqb|The apparent '''acceptance of violence''' as a fact of family life in Ukraine characterizes it as an entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereotypes. }}
{{tqb|The apparent '''acceptance of violence''' as a fact of family life in Ukraine characterizes it as an entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereotypes. }}
The source says about "acceptance of violence" being an entrenched social problem while the article distorts its meaning, so that "violence against women" becomes an "entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereoptypes". --[[User talk:Piramidion|<tt style="color:#057021;font-family:Sans Serif">Piramidion</tt>]] 18:43, 17 March 2020 (UTC)
The source says about "acceptance of violence" being an entrenched social problem while the article distorts its meaning, so that only "violence against women" becomes an "entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereoptypes" ([[Violence_against_men#Female_violence_against_men|violence against men]] is also engendered by those very stereotypes) --[[User talk:Piramidion|<tt style="color:#057021;font-family:Sans Serif">Piramidion</tt>]] 18:43, 17 March 2020 (UTC)

Revision as of 18:49, 17 March 2020

Outdated

Aside from being non-neutral, the article is also outdated, based mostly on the 2000 Kobelyanska papers, which are somewhat biased too. For example, it says that "According to data from NGOs, one-third of young jobless women in Ukraine have become involved in some capacity in the illegal sex business." Which data, from which NGOs? Why doesn't the wiki article elaborate on the present day statistics? Why doesn't it mention that it's the data "as of..." 1999? 2000? Why does the wiki article talk about the abundance of (soft) pornography in Ukraine if it's been banned since 2009? --Piramidion 00:33, 17 March 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Also the first sentence of the lead section seems to be misinterpreting the source, here's an abstract:

The apparent acceptance of violence as a fact of family life in Ukraine characterizes it as an entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereotypes.

The source says about "acceptance of violence" being an entrenched social problem while the article distorts its meaning, so that only "violence against women" becomes an "entrenched social problem engendered by traditional male and female stereoptypes" (violence against men is also engendered by those very stereotypes) --Piramidion 18:43, 17 March 2020 (UTC)[reply]