Jump to content

Ethiopian nationalism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 196.191.189.195 (talk) at 01:38, 28 June 2023. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This article is about civic nationalism in Ethiopia. For more, see Ethiopianism.

Ethiopian nationalism, also referred to as Ethiopianism or Ethiopianness (Template:Lang-am, Ityop̣p̣yawinnät), according to its proponents, asserts that Ethiopians are a nation and promotes the social equality of all component ethnic groups. Ethiopian people as a whole regardless of ethnicity constitute sovereignty as one polity. Ethiopian nationalism is a type of civic nationalism in that it is multi-ethnic in nature and promotes multiculturalism.[1][2][3][4]

Opponents of Ethiopian nationalism, on the other hand, claim that for more than a century, it was a vehicle through which a supposed Amhara ruling elite used to pursue an assimilation policy and consolidated power.[5][1][2][3][4]

There are varying perspectives on the definition and history of Ethiopian nationalism.[3][4]

File:Flag of Ancient Ethiopia (Blank).svg
The plain green, yellow and red flag of historical Ethiopia and the Ethiopian Community.[6][7][8]

Perspectives

Proponents

The view espoused by Ethiopian nationalists is that Ethiopian civic nationalism is in contrast to and in opposition against ethno-nationalist supremacism fueled by ethnic federalist policies introduced by the EPRDF in which Ethiopian nationalists claim that regional subdivisions of the state were segregated according to ethnicity brought about by the partitioning and dissolution of traditionally multi-ethnic regions causing the internal displacement of people through internal population transfers.[9][2][10][11][12] However, there has been opposition to multi-ethnic Ethiopian civic nationalism from ethnic nationalist and separatists groups as seen in the surge of ethnic tensions between various Ethiopian ethnic groups and political parties most notably among the most populous ethnic groups in the country such as the Amhara, Oromo, Somali, and Tigray peoples, most of whom who have separatist movements among their ranks,[13] and conflict between Ethiopia and various ethnic groups that make up the Eritrean population with Eritrean Provincial Separatists vying for and later accomplishing the independence of Eritrea (who had already formed their own region specific Eritrean Nationalism and national identity of the Eritreans which has keen similarities to that of Ethiopian civic nationalism because of its multi-ethnic nature). In the aftermath of the Shewan Neftenya[14][15][16][17] period that occurred, as a result of feudal lords from Shewa settling in the southern regions, other ethnic groups assimilated into the royal court culture by adopting the Amharic language, Orthodox Christianity, and other aristocratic cultural traits. The Amhara culture-influenced royal court culture dominated throughout the eras of military and monarchic rule.[18] Both peasant Amhara culture and Ethiopian Empire royal court culture have heavily influenced each other; this Ethiopian royal court culture (that influenced and was influenced by Amhara culture) but is separate from traditional peasant Amhara culture, dominated throughout the eras of military and monarchic rule. The difference between the average Amhara people (generally those of the peasant class) and high status royal court class (which was multi-ethnic but adopted the Amharic language) are described by Siegfried Pausewang says that "the term Amhara relates in contemporary Ethiopia to two different and distinct social groups. The ethnic group of the Amhara, mostly a peasant population, is different from a mixed group of urban people coming from different ethnic background, who have adopted Amharic as a common language and identify themselves as Ethiopians".[19] Due to language and certain cultural similarities, the multi-ethnic ruling class of the military and monarchic era has erroneously been described as an Amhara ruling class, in addition to the questionable existence of an ethnic group known as the Amhara people during the time periods in question,[20][21][22][23][24][25] has erroneously made the terms interchangeable.[19]

Opponents

Opponents of Ethiopian nationalism claim that it is a political ideology centered on the unification of Ethiopian identity through forced assimilation into Amhara culture. Critics claim that the ideology was promulgated throughout ancient history, from Ethiopian Empire and the Derg rule.[26][1][27][13] For more than a century, Amhara ruling elite used this ideology to pursue an assimilation policy and consolidate power.[28] The conflict started between Abyssinia, ruled by Amhara ethnic groups, and various subjugated ethnic groups such as Oromo, Sidama, and Tigray. In 1991 Eritrea achieved independence as the Derg collapsed and the TPLF assumed power and created an ethnic-federal state.[29] The Amhara culture dominated throughout the eras of military and monarchic rule. Both the Haile Selassie and Derg governments relocated numerous Amharas into southern Ethiopia including the present-day Oromia Region, where they served in government administration, courts, church and even in schools, where Oromo textswere eliminated and replaced by Amharic.[30][31][32] As a result of these steps, ethnic tensions surged against the Neftenyasystem where the Oromo, Somali, and Tigray peoples, each of whom had formed separatist movements such as the OLF, TPLF, ELF and ONLF struggled to leave the Ethiopian Empire, which led to the Ethiopian Civil War.[13] Oromo ethnic nationalists and Ethiopian civic nationalists continue to have conflicting narratives over the status of Addis Ababa. Oromo ethnic nationalist claim that Addis Ababa should be ceded to Oromia Region and/or lead by Oromo people, while Ethiopian civic nationalists believe that it should stay as an independent city with leadership open to all people regardless of component ethnicity.[33] The Abyssinian elites perceived the Oromo identity and languages as hindrances to Ethiopian national identity expansion.[34]

Originated from throughout ancient history, the Aksumite Empire was the first kingdom for their unified civilization and social integration to adopt the name "Ethiopia" under Ezana's reign in 4th century.[35][1][36][13] For more than a century, Amhara ruling elite used the ideology to pursue an assimilation policy and consolidate power.[37] Moreover, the notion of Ethiopian integrity was reinforced by Battle of Adwa, an important event where Ethiopia defied European colonization by defeating Italy in 1896.[38]

Impact

The Second Italo-Ethiopian War and subsequent Italian occupation of Ethiopia appeared to be foreign aggression and civil war that leads to ethnic faction expressed by student movements.[39][40] Following the abolition of monarchy and overthrow of Haile Selassie by communist military junta Derg in 1974, Ethiopia underwent several conflicts and civil wars that persists up to today, and the 1991 downfall of the Derg and the raise of the Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) and its ethnic nationalist policies promoted continuum violence and thwarted the Ethiopian unity.[41]

History

Painting depicting the Battle of Adwa of 1896 where Ethiopian forces were victorious over invading Italian forces. The victory is cherished as an example of Ethiopia upholding its independence against European colonial powers and is annually celebrated in Ethiopia in Victory at Adwa Day.

The origin of the concept of an Ethiopian nation formed by Ethiopian nationalists is believed to have begun with the Aksumite Kingdom in the 4th century A.D.[1] The Aksumite Kingdom was a predominantly Christian state that at the height of its power controlled the northern Ethiopian Highlands, Eritrea, and the coastal regions of Southern Arabia.[1] The Aksumite Kingdom was responsible for the development of the religious movement that became the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church.[1] However, the expansion of Islam in the 7th century caused Aksumite Kingdom to decline. Most of the lowland populations converted to Islam, while the highland people remained Christian.[1] Since the Aksumite people were divided between the Christian highlanders and Islamic lowlanders, religious and tribal tensions and rivalries between the people intensified.[1] The Aksumite society morphed into a loose confederation of city-states that maintained the language of Aksum.[1]

The establishment of modern Ethiopia was mainly led by Amhara emperors Tewodros II of Gondar and Menelik II of Shewa. Tewodros governed from 1855 to 1868 and was followed by Yohannes IV, who was from Tigray and was emperor from 1869 to 1889. He managed to expand his authority into Eritrea. Yohannes was followed by Menelik, who governed from 1889 to 1913 and repelled the Italian invasion of 1896.[1]

Ethiopia, unlike the rest of Africa, had never been colonized in the Scramble for Africa.[1] The country was accepted as the first independent African-governed state at the League of Nations in 1922.[1] Ethiopia was occupied by Italy after the Second Italo-Ethiopian War but was liberated by the Allies during World War II.[1]

After the Second World War, Ethiopia annexed Eritrea.[13] However, ethnic tensions peaked between the Amhara and the Eritrean, Oromo, Somali, and Tigray peoples, each of whom had formed separatist movements dedicated to leaving Amhara-dominated Ethiopia.[13] After the overthrow of the Ethiopian monarchy by the Derg military junta, the country became aligned with the Soviet Union and Cuba after the United States failed to support it in its military struggle with Somali separatists in the Ogaden region.[13] After the end of the military government in Ethiopia in 1993, Eritrea separated from Ethiopia.[13]

Legacy of independence

See also: Battle of Adwa

In March 1896, a definitive battle took place between the forces of colonial Italy and those of the Ethiopian Empire in a north Ethiopian town called Adwa. The battle was short but extremely violent, with tens of thousands of deaths. At the time, Emperor Menelik II had mobilized and conscripted the Ethiopian people, regardless of class and ethnicities. The mobilization drive led millions of Ethiopian citizens to march from their towns, villages, and cities into the Northern Highlands for the preservation of their nation. The battle would end in a decisive victory for Ethiopia, giving the country with a unique legacy of independence in the face of European aggression.[42]

The Battle of Adwa is the foundation of Ethiopian nationalist ideology. For many Ethiopians, the threat of foreign invasion is the rallying cry for patriotic sacrifices and nationalist ideologues. By the time the battle of Adwa took place, almost all of Africa was dominated by European forces. Ethiopian independence broke the mold of European superiority and provided a beacon of hope for African and black nations and peoples around the world. For many Ethiopians, the moment represents a transitional moment, in which the nation realized its teleological doctrine. While the first war against Italy was a uniting war, the 1934 invasion by Benito Mussolini was extremely divisive. Upon observation on the Ethiopian nation, Charles McClellan argues that the Italo-Abyssinian war of 1934 was in fact "as much a civil war as one against foreign aggression."[43] He also argues the political and factional differences which emerged in Ethiopia prior to the war were not resolved by the Italian invasion but instead amplified. This, in the authors' opinion, led to an era of bitter factionalism which would "define the dynamics of post-war Ethiopian politics."[43]

Era of ethnic federalism

See also: Ethnic federalism § Ethiopia
The Lion of Judah flag, symbolic representation of Ethiopian Empire under Haile Selassie's administration.

In 1991, the TPLF had gained almost complete control of the national government, leveraging its power to concentrate wealth and development into the Tigray Region. The hegemonic rule of the Tigray people in Ethiopia was in many ways a reaction to the predominance Amharas had in media and governance. The hegemonic rule of a few ethnic groups or in some cases, a single ethnic group has marginalized many groups within Ethiopia and has led to a cycle of violence and retribution. In the early 1990s, the TPLF believed that through an ethnic federalist state system, one in which regions were assigned and divided by the ethnic population, they could:[44]

reduc[e] the inter-ethnic conflict that has divided Ethiopian society for centuries; promot[e] equitable material conditions in all areas of the country; and improv[e] the efficiency and effectiveness of public sector performance at the field level. They argued they could use political and administrative devolution to promote these objectives without threatening other important objectives, such as economic growth and political stability.

While these regions were not given "extensive sub-national control over technical policies, laws, regulations, and tax," their creation lent credibility to the different independence and ethnic nationalist movements around the country.[44] For Ethiopian nationalists, this credibility has emboldened different groups, giving them more cohesion, whilst corroding national unity and notions of Pan-Ethiopianism. The increased autonomy of these groups contrasted with the increased repression by Tigray elites created a situation in which the ruling class was both empowering groups through greater ethnic cohesion, but transparently stifling their political will. As shown by the 2005 elections, the TPLF use of violent repression to subdue detractors of the ruling coalition only had the effect of radicalizing ethnic parties and increasing ethnic divisions. Many Ethiopian nationalists view the system of ethnic federalism as having made governing in Ethiopia a zero-sum game. To win power in Ethiopia is to deny any other ethnic group significant power. By expelling notions of Ethiopianism or multi-ethnic Ethiopian national identity from the national political dialogue, the TPLF has increased the ethnic breaks and created a system revolving around ethnic affiliation, devoid of political ideology. In 2015, after a master plan was unveiled to expand the boundaries of the Ethiopian capital Addis Ababa into Oromia in 2014, thousands of Oromo Youth Liberation Movement members took to the streets to demand increased political representation, an end to the TPLF-sponsored Master Plan, and avenues of dissent.[45] Although the ruling party tried to blunt these protests through physical force, the protests only grew. Amharas "angered by an unfulfilled demand to retake control of some of their lands" launched protests consisting of mostly Oromos and Amharas (but also other Ethiopians) demanding proportional political representation and influence.[45] After a 10-month state of emergency imposed by the TPLF, which saw the abdication of prime minister Hailemariam Desalegn and Abiy Amhed—was selected by the ruling EPDRF coalition as the next prime minister due to his mixed Oromo-Amhara ethnic ancestry with a preference for his Oromo identity. Since Abiy took power, he has taken up major reforms allowing back political dissidents, releasing some political prisoners, and liberalizing the economy.[46] While his drive to reform and democratize the nation has garnered him support across the country, he still has not addressed the fundamental issues of the ethnic federalist system, which in the Pan-Ethiopians' opinion is the root cause for ethno-nationalist politics and tensions. Ethiopian nationalists believe that ethnic federalism must be ended to shift Ethiopian politics from ethnic patronage to ideology, it must be ended to induce national cohesion and blunt sectarian loyalty, and through the blunting of ethnic cohesion induce an era of unity and prosperity.

Abiy and the Prosperity Party have been seen as supporters of Ethiopian civic nationalism due to the merger of the Oromo Democratic Party with the ethnicity-based Amhara Democratic Party, Argoba People's Democratic Organization, Benishangul-Gumuz People's Democratic Unity Front, Ethiopian Somali People's Democratic Party, Gambela People's Democratic Movement, Afar National Democratic Party, Hareri National League, and the Southern Ethiopian People's Democratic Movement political parties into the new multi-ethnic Prosperity Party, thus moving these predecessor parties away from their ethnic nationalist and pro-ethnic federalism past into a party that promotes Ethiopian national identity, and non-ethnicity based federalism. All of these goals are seen by opponents as steps towards taking political powers based on group rights away from the various ethnic groups. Proponents of the merger see it as a way to move Ethiopian politics and governmental administration away from ethnicity-based identity politics, supporting the individual rights of each person. This outlook more intensely mitigates rising ethnic nationalism, fosters national unity and solidarity, and creates inclusive democratic process involving political parties of several ethnic groups and regions that were once deemed too inferior by the Tigray People's Liberation Front-led Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front regime. Eventually, proponents hope to see the transition a to one-party dominated coalition government or be full partakers in revolutionary democracy because of their largely pastoralist way of life.[47][48][49][50][51]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Motyl 2001, pp. 149.
  2. ^ a b c "Ethiopia Forum: Challenges and Prospects for Constitutional Democracy in Ethiopia" (PDF). African Studies Center. Michigan State University. Retrieved 29 May 2023.
  3. ^ a b c "The Pitfalls of the Ethiopian Elites' War of Narratives: Part I". Centre for Human Rights & Legal Pluralism. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  4. ^ a b c "The Pitfalls of the Ethiopian Elites' War of Narratives: Part II". Centre for Human Rights & Legal Pluralism. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  5. ^ Kefale, Asnake (20 October 2014). "Ethnic Decentralization and the Challenges of Inclusive Governance in Multiethnic Cities: The Case of Dire Dawa, Ethiopia". Regional & Federal Studies. 24 (5): 589–605. doi:10.1080/13597566.2014.971772. S2CID 154137709.
  6. ^ "Military Notes". Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 41 (235): 1184–1192. September 1897. doi:10.1080/03071849709416067. red yellow, and green, p. 1190, at Google Books
  7. ^ Flag Research Center Firefly The Flag Bulletin, Volume 27 – Google Books" Flag Research Center, 1988. p. 11.[title incomplete]
  8. ^ Lentakis, Michael B. (2005). Ethiopia: A View from Within. Janus Publishing Company Lim. p. 11. ISBN 978-1-85756-558-4.
  9. ^ Gebreluel, Goitom. "Should Ethiopia stick with ethnic federalism?". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  10. ^ Nixon, Rob (1993). "Of Balkans and Bantustans". Transition (60): 4–26. doi:10.2307/2934915. ISSN 0041-1191.
  11. ^ "The Pitfalls of the Ethiopian Elites' War of Narratives: Part I". Centre for Human Rights & Legal Pluralism. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  12. ^ "The Pitfalls of the Ethiopian Elites' War of Narratives: Part II". Centre for Human Rights & Legal Pluralism. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  13. ^ a b c d e f g h Motyl 2001, pp. 150.
  14. ^ "Context and Updates on Current Issues in Ethiopia". Embassy of Ethiopia, London. 2020-07-08. Retrieved 2020-12-16.
  15. ^ Nicolas, Andrea (November 2007). "Founded in Memory of the 'Good Old Times': The Clan Assembly of Hiddii, in Eastern Shewa, Ethiopia". Journal of Eastern African Studies. 1 (3): 484–497. doi:10.1080/17531050701625490. ISSN 1753-1055.
  16. ^ +ECADF (2013-07-29). "Fiction and Facts on Oromos of Ethiopia". Retrieved 2021-01-22.
  17. ^ "How Ethiopia's ruling coalition created a playbook for disinformation · Global Voices Advox". Retrieved 2021-01-22.
  18. ^ Pausewang, Siegfried (2005). "The two-faced Amhara identity". Scrinium. 1 (1): 273-286. doi:10.1163/18177565-90000138.
  19. ^ a b Pausewang, Siegfried (2005). "The two-faced Amhara identity". Scrinium. 1 (1): 273–286. doi:10.1163/18177565-90000138.
  20. ^ Cohen, Gideon P. E. (2000). "Language and Ethnic Boundaries: Perceptions of Identity Expressed through Attitudes towards the Use of Language Education in Southern Ethiopia". Northeast African Studies. 7 (3): 189–206. doi:10.1353/nas.2005.0004. JSTOR 41931261. S2CID 144103747.
  21. ^ Tazebew, Tezera (2021). "Amhara nationalism: The empire strikes back". African Affairs. 120 (479): 297–313. doi:10.1093/afraf/adaa029.
  22. ^ Yates, Brian J. (2017). "Ethnicity as a Hindrance for Understanding Ethiopian History: An Argument Against an Ethnic Late Nineteenth Century". History in Africa. 44: 101–131. doi:10.1017/hia.2016.13. S2CID 164336903.
  23. ^ Gashaw, Solomon (1993). "Nationalism and Ethnic Conflict in Ethiopia". In Young, Crawford (ed.). The Rising Tide of Cultural Pluralism: The Nation-State at Bay?. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press. pp. 138–157. ISBN 978-0-299-13884-4
  24. ^ Teka, Tegegne (1998). "Amhara ethnicity in the making". In Salih, M.A. Mohamed; Markakis, John (eds.). Ethnicity and the State in Eastern Africa. Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikaininstutet. pp. 116–126. ISBN 978-91-7106-418-9
  25. ^ Taddese, Takkele (1994). "Do the Amhara Exist as a Distinct Ethnic Group?". In Marcus, Harold G. (ed.). New Trends in Ethiopian Studies: Papers of the 12th International Conference of Ethiopian Studies. II. Lawrenceville, NJ: Red Sea Press. pp. 168–186. ISBN 978-1-56902-015-9.
  26. ^ Ethiopia urgently needs inclusive national dialogue, March 30, 2021
  27. ^ Ethiopia: Defining Amhara nationalism for a better country, September 27, 2020
  28. ^ Ethnic Decentralization and the Challenges of Inclusive Governance in Multiethnic Cities: The Case of Dire Dawa, Ethiopia, retrieved December 20, 2014
  29. ^ Chronology for Amhara in Ethiopia, 2004
  30. ^ OROMO CONTINUE TO FLEE VIOLENCE, September 1981
  31. ^ Country Information Report ethiopia, August 12, 2020
  32. ^ Ethiopia. Status of Amharas, March 1, 1993
  33. ^ What is driving Ethiopia's ethnic conflicts? (PDF), retrieved November 28, 2019
  34. ^ The Politics of Linguistic Homogenization in Ethiopia and the Conflict over the Status of "Afaan Oromoo", July 1970
  35. ^ Ethiopia urgently needs inclusive national dialogue, March 30, 2021
  36. ^ Moges, Zola (27 September 2020). "Ethiopia: Defining Amhara nationalism for a better country". The Africa Report.
  37. ^ Kefale, Asnake (20 October 2014). "Ethnic Decentralization and the Challenges of Inclusive Governance in Multiethnic Cities: The Case of Dire Dawa, Ethiopia". Regional & Federal Studies. 24 (5): 589–605. doi:10.1080/13597566.2014.971772. S2CID 154137709.
  38. ^ McClellan, Charles (1996). "Observations on the Ethiopian Nation, Its Nationalism, and the Italo-Ethiopian War". Northeast African Studies. 3 (1): 57–86. doi:10.1353/nas.1996.0004. S2CID 145417431. Project MUSE 399037.
  39. ^ McClellan, Charles (1996). "Observations on the Ethiopian Nation, Its Nationalism, and the Italo-Ethiopian War". Northeast African Studies. 3 (1): 57–86. doi:10.1353/nas.1996.0004. S2CID 145417431. Project MUSE 399037.
  40. ^ Toggia, Pietro; Zegeye, Abebe (2013-10-18). Ethiopia in Transit: Millennial Quest for Stability and Continuity. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-98207-4.
  41. ^ Bach, Jean-Nicolas (16 June 2014). "EPRDF's Nation-Building: Tinkering with convictions and pragmatism". Cadernos de Estudos Africanos (27). doi:10.4000/cea.1501.
  42. ^ Jonas, Raymond (2011). The Battle of Adwa: African Victory in the Age of Empire. Harvard University Press. doi:10.2307/j.ctt24hjxj. ISBN 978-0-674-05274-1. JSTOR j.ctt24hjxj. S2CID 253127159.[page needed]
  43. ^ a b McClellan, Charles (1996). "Observations on the Ethiopian Nation, Its Nationalism, and the Italo-Ethiopian War". Northeast African Studies. 3 (1): 57–86. doi:10.1353/nas.1996.0004. JSTOR 41931125. S2CID 145417431.
  44. ^ a b Cohen, John M. (1995). "'Ethnic Federalism' in Ethiopia". Northeast African Studies. 2 (2): 157–188. doi:10.1353/nas.1995.0016. JSTOR 41931208. S2CID 154783804.
  45. ^ a b Kestler-D'Amours, Jillian (20 February 2018). "Ethiopia: Mass protests 'rooted in country's history'". Aljazeera. Retrieved 8 November 2021.
  46. ^ Burke, Jason (8 July 2018). "'These changes are unprecedented': how Abiy is upending Ethiopian politics". The Guardian.
  47. ^ Allo, Awol K. "How Abiy Ahmed's Ethiopia-first nationalism led to civil war". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 2021-01-20.
  48. ^ "Context and Updates on Current Issues in Ethiopia". Embassy of Ethiopia, London. 2020-07-08. Retrieved 2020-12-16.
  49. ^ Gedamu, Yohannes (13 December 2019). "The new political party of Ethiopia's Abiy holds much promise but faces significant hurdles". Quartz Africa. Retrieved 2021-01-20.
  50. ^ Gebreluel, Goitom (23 December 2019). "Ethiopia's prime minister wants to change the ruling coalition. Who's getting left out?". Washington Post.
  51. ^ Mamdani, Mahmood (3 January 2019). "The Trouble With Ethiopia's Ethnic Federalism". The New York Times.

Bibliography

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Ethiopian_nationalism&oldid=1162267805"