Talk:Aiyanar

Peer review

The Peer review is written taken into considering Good article criteria

• The article uses "Ayyanar" and "Aiyanar" alternatively. Stick to one spelling
• Add inline references
• File:AN4248.JPG needs a formal description on img page, also a formal information template saying who the creator is explicitly.

--Redtigerxyz ^Talk 06:24, 1 January 2009 (UTC)

• Harihara putra needs a separate article, he is not same Harihara, the combined form of Vishnu-Shiva. Harihara-putra as a Sanskrit compound (samaas) means "son of Vishnu and Hara" and has no relation to Harihara. --Redtigerxyz ^Talk 16:15, 7 January 2009 (UTC)

Very poor grammar

The grammar, especially in the "Worship" section, is far below acceptable levels for an encyclopedic or even casual read. Whole paragraphs are nearly unreadable. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 71.197.7.208 (talk) 22:01, 23 October 2012 (UTC)

Shasta (deity)

Shasta is the sanskritized form of Tamil சாத்தன் (Cāttaṉ). There are no any significant differences between Shasta and Aiyanar since their iconographies and myths are exactly the same. Even Ayyappan, the Keralite god, who is non other than one form (according to the faith 'avatar') of Aiyanar, can be merged with this page. But, he can also be categorized as an unique deity predominantly resides in Sabarimala. I recommend to merge Shasta (deity) with this page, Aiyanar. --5anan27 (talk) 08:00, 19 August 2017 (UTC)

• Oppose Shasta is identified with various regional deities the Tamil Aiyanar, Ayyappa of Kerala and even Murugan. The iconography as well as the mythology of Aiyanar and Ayyappa is distinct.--Redtigerxyz ^Talk 13:59, 19 August 2017 (UTC)

Could you please explain with references in which aspects Aiyanar differs from Sashta and Aiyappan? Kindly note that all three wiki articles already have the proofs to conclude that Ayyappan, Aiyanar and Shasta (Dharmasashta) are synonyms of the same deity. Please google. It provides hundreds of temples of this deity with the substitutes Ayyanar, Ayyappan, Sastha, Dharmasastha and Aiyan. For your information,

1. "Sashta is called as Hariharaputra (Tamil Arikaraputtiraṉ), son of Mohini and Shiva. So does Aiyanar. Ayyappan is the avatar of Hariharaputra". - says Sabarimala Sthala Puranam and Tamil Kanda Puranam
2. All three deities are native to Southern India.
3. For the iconography, compare Pooranai, putkalai samedha Aiyanar of Tamil Nadu with Purna Pushkalamba sametha Dharmasastha of Kerala (look at the phrase "Swamiye Saranam ayyappa"), Dharmasashta of Kerala and a Sashta sculpture from Tamil Nadu
4. There is a probability that the deity Sashta could be borrowed from Buddhism. But there are no any chances to affiliate him with Murugan.

Please clarify. --5anan27 (talk) 08:38, 20 August 2017 (UTC)

• Strong Oppose - The deities Shasta, Ayyapan and Aiyanar have different mythologies and are all notable in their own right. Unless there is a strong reference to link these 3 deities, this is WP:OR and has no chance of even a single mention in any of these articles. Most of the references you raised above are blogspots and references that are not reliable. King Prithviraj II (talk) 19:00, 23 August 2017 (UTC)
• Oppose - Rudra is often identified with Shiva, however each deity has separate articles. 2.51.18.247 (talk) 12:15, 26 August 2017 (UTC)

• Clarify

So, is it enough to conclude WP:OR just by saying :"have different mythologies" and "blogspots and references are not reliable"? Yes. I selected comparable clear depictions from blogspots for specifying the similarities. Please argue with references. Don't ignore everything by just telling this is reliable and that is not reliable. And dear IP number 2.51.18.247, this discussion is on Shasta, Aiyanar and Ayyappan and nothing to do with either Shiva or Rudra. Separate wiki articles will never determine whether these deities are same or not.

Has no chance of even a single mention in any of these articles? Did you read them actually? Ok. Check these.
I. present Ayyappan article has this image of Aiyanar and following passage is extracted from the same article.:

“ Ayyappan, also known as ...Shasta or Dharma Shasta....the son of Shiva and Mohini......Other important temples are Kulathupuzha Sastha Temple, Aryankavu Sastha Temple, Achankovil Sree Dharmasastha Temple... ”

II. Following passage is extracted from current Aiyanar article:

“ Another name for the deity is Ayyānar-Śāstā or Śāstā. The Śāstā cult is particularly well developed in the state of Kerala....Dharma-Śāstā is used to describe Ayyappan. Śāstā also has a sanskritising legend that makes him the son of a union between Shiva and the female form of Vishnu. ”

III. And finally a part from Shasta:

“ ...Aiyanar is used as another name of the deity Shasta. The earliest reference to Aiynar-Shasta is from the Arcot district.... dated to the 3rd century C.E. They read "Ayanappa; a shrine to Cattan....Brahmanda Purana mentions Shasta as harihara suta or son of Siva and Narayana (Vishnu).... Legends indicate that Shasta is the son of a union between Shiva and the female form of Vishnu, namely Mohini. ”

IV. Shasta and Aiyappan pages had same images until I asked for a merging request. Check this version of Ayyappan and present Shasta page.
V. Huge number of edits appear from an IP number converting all sources which claim the similarities of Ayyappan with Aiyanar as well as Shasta.
VI. And there is a problem with blogspot references. No? Check wikimedia category of Aiyanar and category of Sashta. Please compare the iconographies.

I undid the deleted merging requests. Nothing urgent. We can discuss and come to a decision calmly. --5anan27 (talk) 08:59, 1 September 2017 (UTC)