Talk:Gracie Allen/Archive 1

Archive 1

Untitled

This article has been revised many times, but the quality notice keeps reappearing. Would whoever is putting it back please specify which section or sections are in need of "cleaning up"? I have read many less scholarly entries on Wikipedia which are not marked as needing editing. Specific feedback would be helpful here.

I'm not sure when the preceding comment is from, but I tend to agree with what is stated. The article has clear formation and referrences and uses correct grammar and sequence. The tone is not discordant. Im not sure what's being looked for here. I'm not the author, so objectively I feel this article is an asset. A better understanding of what may be lacking should be expressed so it's not a guessing game. TFBCT1 (talk) 11:43, 24 February 2008 (UTC)

I kinda doubt color tv had anything to do with her heterochromia-shame. As you can see from the picture in this article, it's clearly obvious her irides are two different colors even in black-and-white.

Color TV probably didn't, because she was very retired by the time it began to become popular, but according to several of George Burns's books she wasn't bothered by it on TV mainly because it was in black and white. --Dan Moore 23:24, 10 June 2006 (UTC)

Famous Closing

The "Good night, Gracie" legend refuses to die. I have corrected this several times, with some kind soul(s) coming in and "correcting" me every time. Prior to this most recent correction of the facts I watched more than fifty episodes of the Burns & Allen Show on video and DVD. The episodes were from a five-year period, and included both film and kinescope sources. The only episode which deviated from the norm ("Say good night, Gracie." "Good night.") was the January 29, 1953 episode which I quoted in the article. I also refer to specific, published references to back me up. Now that a large number of episodes are commercially available, I hope skeptics will watch for themselves instead of relying on faulty memories of the show. --Fshepinc 08:53, 16 June 2006

I back up this editor, George Burns said the same thing in his biography "Gracie a Love Story" about his wife. He claims they only did it once if ever, but he didn't even remember that, and that they didn't do it largely because nobody thought to do it. 216.201.48.26 (talk) 20:25, 13 February 2008 (UTC)

Thank you, Fshepinc! I'm incredibly surprised and pleased to see someone **finally** get this right. "Goodnight, Gracie" is a misquote on the level of "Play it again, Sam" never having been uttered in Casablanca. "Goodnight, Gracie" was even used once as the supposedly correct answer to a question on Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?, even though there is *no* surviving example of any broadcast where this joke has been used. I've personally, meticulously gone through almost 250 radio shows and 270 of the 291 TV shows looking for this line and can categorically state that if this joke ever was used, it hasn't been heard for over 50 years, because no surviving/publicly available Burns & Allen programs use it. None.

I hesitate to go further, but in fact, George rarely even said "Say goodnight, Gracie." Most of the time it was phrased, "Gracie, say goodnight." Nitpicky, to be sure, but frustrating as it's the *only* thing modern audiences are likely to know about Burns and Allen at all!

You can't prove a negative, so there's no way to ever definitely make this go away. WGaryW (talk) 19:32, 29 April 2011 (UTC)

Family Section: Ronnie and Sandra

In the section on "Family" the article states that Ronnie and Sandy played their famous parents in a skit on the Burns and Allen Television program. While it is true that Ronnie played his father in the skit, Sandra was not the young woman who played Gracie. Sandy was on the show several times, often as the voice of an operator on the telephone. --Sarty 05:56, 15 January 2006 (UTC)Sarty

Absolutely correct. The actress who played Gracie opposite Ronnie as George was Diane Jergens. Harry Von Zell announces her name ("Diane Jergens as Diane") over the closing credits, as he did for every actor in a non-regular part throughout the series. Note that the IMDB has incorrect info, listing Diane as having been played by Judy Clark, with a separate entry for Diane Jergens with no character name specified. Unless the IMDB knows something Harry Von Zell didn't. WGaryW (talk) 19:43, 29 April 2011 (UTC)

Year of birth

I have some strong evidence that she was born in 1895. The all-girls she want to (Star of the Sea in San Francisco) had her in the first graduating class, in 1909. Obviously, she could not have graduated at age 6.--Fallout boy 11:18, 29 January 2006 (UTC)

This mostly agrees with (or at least doesn't significantly contradict) her appearance on the 1900 and 1910 censuses (1900: Assembly District 30, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California [microfilm Series T623, Roll 101, Page 36/Sheet 11A]; 1910: Assembly District 39, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California [microfilm Series T624, Roll 100, Page 145]). In 1900, her month of birth is July, but the year and her age are illegible. In 1910, her age is given as 13. This suggests that her year of birth was 1896 (the census was taken in April), but in any case, it wasn't 1902. Ardric47 04:29, 13 May 2006 (UTC)

Although the year of Gracie's birth is illegible in the microfilm of the 1900 U.S. Census, the Soundex index card of that listing, transcribed directly from the paper original of the census schedule, clearly says Grace Allen was born in 1895. — Walloon 09:33, 30 December 2006 (UTC)

I went to Star of the Sea Academy in San Francisco and used to walk by the alumni photos everyday. Gracie Allen was part of the first graduating class of SSA in 1914. So a birth year of 1895 would make the most sense because she would've been an 18 year old high school graduate in June 1914. As a sidenote, Star was coed when Gracie attended. It didn't become an all-girl school until a few years later. User:71.146.91.13|71.146.91.13]] 09:06, 30 December 2006 (UTC)ms

This remains a bit of a mystery, but I can cite the book "George Burns and Gracie Allen: A Biobibliography" by Clements/Weber as pegging Gracie's birth year at 1895 as well. But you'll find several different birth years for Gracie ranging from 1895 to 1906 depending on which source you look at. The Biobibliography is a meticulously researched academic work, and all the above evidence here is convincing, so 1895 is very likely correct. WGaryW (talk) 21:47, 29 April 2011 (UTC)

It's not possible for someone alive in June 1900 to be born after that month. 1906 and 1902 cannot be correct. That leaves 1895 or 1896.Ryoung122 04:13, 1 October 2011 (UTC)

I'm so glad Wikipedia has places to discuss these things! I just found out, because I kept trying to edit the page and I was doing it wrong. It says on her headstone she was born in 1902, but the geneology says different. Someone above says they saw her graduating class picture though? I guess that would make more sense that she was born in 1896/95 for that matter. Do you guys think the headstone thing was supposed to be funny? Maybe Gracie wanted to have one last immortal joke? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 66.87.112.195 (talk) 20:33, 4 September 2014 (UTC)

Really a boy?

What does it mean "Gracie Allen was educated at the Star of the Sea Convent School as a girl"?

Is it trying to say this is a girls' school? Why is that phrase even in there?

---

To the author of the above comment:

"as a girl" is the same as saying "as a child," basically saying when she was younger.

JaeRae 10:40, 15 April 2006 (UTC)