Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Military historiography task force/Article alerts/Archive 1

Archives

This is an archive of previous Article Alert reports. This page is automatically updated by AAlertBot. Entries and content can be added/removed/changed manually, as long as {{anchor|archivebottom}} and the workflow anchors {{anchor|AfD}}/{{anchor|AfDbottom}}, {{anchor|GAN}}/{{anchor|GANbottom}}, etc. aren't removed.

AfD

14 May 2011 – Gareth Glover AfDed by Peripitus was deleted; see discussion
08 Aug 2012 – Aryeh Yitzhaki AfDed by Nefariousski was deleted; discussion
18 Nov 2012 – Bibliography of American Civil War Union military unit histories AfDed by Razr Nation was closed as keep by Lord Roem on 27 Nov 2012; discussion
18 Nov 2012 – Bibliography of the American Civil War AfDed by Razr Nation was closed as keep by Vacation9 on 24 Nov 2012; discussion
18 Nov 2012 – Bibliography of American Civil War Confederate Unit histories AfDed by Razr Nation was closed as keep by Tom Morris on 03 Dec 2012; discussion
11 Feb 2014 – The Soldier and the State AfDed by Casprings was closed as keep by DavidLeighEllis on 18 Feb 2014; discussion
05 Oct 2014 – The First Book of Napoleon AfDed by FyzixFighter was deleted; discussion
25 Mar 2015 – One Woman's War: Da (Mother) AfDed by Mehran was closed as keep by Postdlf on 08 Apr 2015; discussion
13 Jun 2015 – File (formation) AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as keep by DavidLeighEllis on 19 Jun 2015; discussion
25 Apr 2016 – Waffen-SS im Einsatz AfDed by KDS4444 was closed as keep by Northamerica1000 on 11 May 2016; discussion
12 Jun 2016 – Patricia Driscoll (executive) AfDed by DGG was closed as delete by Steve Smith on 27 Jun 2016; discussion
14 Aug 2016 – Harris Mayer AfDed by MSJapan was closed as keep by SwisterTwister on 31 Aug 2016; discussion
04 Sep 2017 – Annus Mirabilis of 1759 AfDed by Neve-selbert was closed as merge by Northamerica1000 on 10 Sep 2017; discussion
27 Dec 2017 – List of Religious Wars AfDed by TheLongTone was closed as delete by DGG on 05 Jan 2018; discussion
02 Jan 2018 – My Journey into the Heart of Terror: Ten Days in the Islamic State AfDed by Elektricity was closed as keep by Ivecos on 03 Jan 2018; discussion
23 Oct 2018 – European Civil War AfDed by RandomIntrigue was closed as keep by Szzuk on 30 Oct 2018; discussion
20 Nov 2018 – David Bashow AfDed by Bearcat was closed as no consensus by RoySmith on 14 Dec 2018; discussion
22 Nov 2018 – Christa Ehrmann-Hämmerle AfDed by Onel5969 was closed as keep by Michig on 15 Dec 2018; discussion
14 Jan 2019 – Richard Newcomb AfDed by Szzuk was closed as keep by Tone on 21 Jan 2019; discussion
02 Oct 2019 – Ahmadiyya Jabrayilov AfDed by IntoThinAir was closed as keep by RoySmith on 10 Oct 2019; discussion
21 Dec 2019 – Joel Hayward AfDed by Stuartyeates was closed as keep by Tone on 28 Dec 2019; discussion
11 May 2020 – Stephen Wertheim AfDed by Subreal111 was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 18 May 2020; discussion
19 Aug 2020 – Pritzker Military Presents AfDed by Normal Op was closed as delete by Sandstein on 17 Sep 2020; discussion
19 Aug 2020 – Pritzker Military Presents AfDed by Normal Op was closed as delete by Sandstein on 17 Sep 2020; discussion
16 Jan 2021 – Christopher Story AfDed by Jdcooper was closed as delete by Daniel on 07 Feb 2021; discussion
14 Mar 2021 – Lars Gyllenhaal AfDed by Eddie891 was closed as delete by Ixfd64 on 22 Mar 2021; discussion
08 Apr 2021 – Robert D. Cherry AfDed by Snooganssnoogans was closed as keep by Eddie891 on 15 Apr 2021; discussion
23 Jul 2021 – The Pike & Shot Society AfDed by Eddie891 was closed as delete by Daniel on 30 Jul 2021; discussion

RM

20 May 2011 – Winged Victory move request by Kauffner was closed; see discussion
10 Oct 2011 – Timeline of World War II (1945) move request by Whoop whoop pull up was closed; discussion
27 Apr 2013 – Lebor Gabála Érenn move request by Thejmii was closed; discussion
02 Aug 2015 – Armchair General move request by GregKaye was closed; discussion
05 Sep 2015 – Melian dialogue move request by Kurzon was closed; discussion
20 Jun 2016 – Oyneg Shabbos move request by IZAK was closed; discussion
07 Jul 2018 – Beslan (book) move request by Roman Spinner was closed; discussion
09 Sep 2018 – Waging War: The Clash Between Presidents and Congress, 1776 to ISIS move request by Hhkohh was closed; discussion
11 Sep 2018 – Counter-Revolutionary Violence move request by Hhkohh was closed; discussion
16 Mar 2019 – Soviet offensive plans controversy move request by K.e.coffman was closed; discussion
13 May 2019 – Counter-Revolutionary Violence: Bloodbaths in Fact & Propaganda move request by Sam Sailor was closed; discussion
20 Aug 2019 – First Encirclement Campaign against Jiangxi Soviet move request to First encirclement campaign against the Jiangxi Soviet by Dicklyon was moved to First encirclement campaign against the Jiangxi Soviet by Newslinger on 27 Aug 2019; discussion
19 Sep 2019 – Jack Hadley move request to Jack Hadley Black History Museum by Kolya Butternut was not moved; discussion
05 Jun 2020 – History of the Jews and the Crusades move request to History of Jews and the Crusades by Mysterymanblue was not moved; discussion
10 Feb 2021 – Volodymyr Kubiyovych move request to Volodymyr Kubijovyč by Mzajac was closed to Volodymyr Kubijovyč by StraussInTheHouse on 23 Feb 2021; discussion
12 May 2021 – Jack Granatstein move request to J. L. Granatstein by Buidhe was closed; discussion
03 Oct 2021 – Italiani brava gente move request to Myth of the good Italian by Super Dromaeosaurus was not moved; discussion
31 Jan 2022 – Lost Cause of the Confederacy move request to Lost cause of the Confederacy by Cinderella157 was not moved; discussion
10 Feb 2021 – Volodymyr Kubiyovych move request to Volodymyr Kubijovyč by Mzajac was closed to Volodymyr Kubijovyč by StraussInTheHouse on 23 Feb 2021; discussion
08 Aug 2022 – The Longest Day (book) move request to The Longest Day (history book) by Roman Spinner was closed; discussion
26 Aug 2022 – Fiasco (book) move request to Fiasco (2006 book) by Piotrus was closed; discussion

PROD

25 Jun 2011 – Peter W. Wilkinson PRODed by Jim Sweeney was deleted
04 Mar 2012 – Bruce Taylor (historian) PRODed by MelanieN and endorsed by Bearian on 05 Mar 2012 was deleted
23 May 2012 – Iraq: Opposing Viewpoints PRODed by Suriel1981 was deleted
29 May 2014 – 1805 Club PRODed by ChrisGualtieri was deproded by Dual Freq on 01 Jun 2014
28 Sep 2014 – The First Book of Napoleon PRODed by FyzixFighter was deproded by 174.52.79.53 on 29 Sep 2014
29 Apr 2015 – Patricia Driscoll (business executive) PRODed by John at Lancelotlinc was deproded by Sadads on 07 May 2015
undated – Alexander Mikaberidze PRODed was deproded by Wikimandia on 11 Feb 2016
13 Jul 2016 – Sami Rihana PRODed by Gbawden was deproded by David Gerard on 21 Jul 2016
13 Jul 2016 – Sami Rihana PRODed by Gbawden was deproded by David Gerard on 21 Jul 2016
20 Aug 2017 – Ronnie E. Ford PRODed by DrStrauss was deleted
22 Nov 2018 – Robin Schäfer PRODed by Hydronium Hydroxide was deleted
05 Nov 2019 – Russia: War, Peace and Diplomacy PRODed by Creffett was deproded by MarkZusab on 05 Nov 2019
18 Aug 2020 – Military Blunders PRODed by Piotrus and endorsed by Doghouse09 on 24 Aug 2020 was deleted
02 Jan 2021 – The Pike & Shot Society PRODed by Eddie891 was deleted
12 Jan 2021 – Cross and Cockade PRODed by Theredproject was deproded by Georgejdorner on 15 Jan 2021
27 Jun 2021 – Indian Defence Review PRODed by Rammuni BadaUdasin was deleted
02 Jan 2022 – Black Edelweiss PRODed by Brigade Piron was deleted
15 Jan 2022 – Shattered Sword PRODed by GraemeLeggett was deproded by Ljleppan on 16 Jan 2022
26 May 2022 – Estimates of opposing forces in the Battle of Borodino PRODed by ActivelyDisinterested was deproded by DGG on 30 May 2022

FAC

10 Aug 2011 – John Treloar (museum administrator) FA nominated by Nick-D was promoted; discussion
26 Aug 2011 – Rupert Downes FA nominated by Hawkeye7 was not promoted; discussion
03 Oct 2014 – Smyth Report FA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted; discussion
12 Jan 2016 – World War II FA nominated by CatcherStorm was closed; discussion
08 Oct 2021 – Milorad Ekmečić FA nominated by Peacemaker67 was not promoted; discussion
09 Jul 2022 – Rupert Downes FA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted; discussion

GAR

03 Aug 2011 – David Irving nominated for GA review by Guid123 was closed; discussion
30 Mar 2020 – Panzer Aces nominated for GA reassessment by Mujinga was closed; discussion

GAN

11 Nov 2011 – The End: Hitler's Germany 1944–45 GA nominated by The Last Angry Man was not promoted; discussion
11 Nov 2011 – The End: Hitler's Germany 1944-45 GA nominated by The Last Angry Man was closed; discussion
09 Jan 2012 – British Alpine Hannibal Expedition GA nominated by Stephan Schulz was promoted; discussion
30 Jun 2013 – Smyth Report GA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted; discussion
30 Jun 2013 – Smyth Report GA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted; discussion
11 Nov 2013 – A Glorious Way to Die GA nominated by Bruce1ee was promoted; discussion
10 Oct 2013 – Frederick H. Dyer GA nominated by MarcusBritish was promoted; discussion
05 Mar 2014 – Encyclopedia of the Central Intelligence Agency GA nominated by Cirt was promoted; discussion
24 Oct 2014 – The Utility of Force GA nominated by HJ Mitchell was promoted; discussion
07 Feb 2015 – Philip J. Cohen GA nominated by Peacemaker67 was not promoted; discussion
02 Jan 2015 – Educating the Disfranchised and Disinherited GA nominated by Czar was promoted; discussion
22 May 2015 – One Woman's War: Da (Mother) GA nominated by Mhhossein was not promoted; discussion
05 Mar 2015 – Ikuhiko Hata GA nominated by CurtisNaito was promoted; discussion
12 Mar 2015 – The Description of Britain GA nominated by LlywelynII was not promoted; discussion
02 Sep 2015 – One Woman's War: Da (Mother) GA nominated by Mhhossein was not promoted; discussion
30 May 2016 – Margaret Gowing GA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted by Ian Rose; discussion
10 Apr 2017 – Peter Edwards (historian) GA nominated by Abraham, B.S. was promoted by Krishna Chaitanya Velaga; discussion
28 Jun 2017 – Lorna Arnold GA nominated by Hawkeye7 was promoted by Jackyd101; discussion
16 Apr 2018 – Ronald Smelser GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Gog the Mild; discussion
11 Oct 2018 – Ernst Klink GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Catrìona; discussion
11 Oct 2018 – Felix Römer GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Catrìona; discussion
05 Nov 2018 – Panzer Aces (book series) GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Catrìona; discussion
05 Nov 2018 – Wolfram Wette GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Sturmvogel 66; discussion
29 Mar 2019 – Ian Eaves GA nominated by Usernameunique was promoted by Sturmvogel 66; discussion
15 Mar 2019 – Geoffrey P. Megargee GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Harrias; discussion
02 Sep 2019 – Helmut Krausnick GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by CPA-5; discussion
20 Jan 2020 – The Myth of the Eastern Front GA nominated by K.e.coffman was promoted by Buidhe; discussion
01 Apr 2020 – Making a New World GA nominated by Hunter Kahn was promoted by Kyle Peake; discussion
06 Apr 2020 – Len Deighton GA nominated by SchroCat was not promoted by Gatoclass; discussion
23 May 2020 – The Holocaust in Bohemia and Moravia (book) GA nominated by Buidhe was promoted by Eddie891; discussion
25 Jul 2020 – Milorad Ekmečić GA nominated by Peacemaker67 was promoted by Eddie891; discussion
31 Oct 2020 – Price's Lost Campaign: The 1864 Invasion of Missouri GA nominated by Hog Farm was promoted by Gog the Mild; discussion
03 Nov 2020 – Shenandoah 1862 GA nominated by Hog Farm was promoted by SL93; discussion
03 Jul 2021 – The Last Hurrah: Sterling Price's Missouri Expedition of 1864 GA nominated by Hog Farm was promoted by Kusma; discussion
20 Sep 2021 – Malcolm Ross (journalist) GA nominated by Zawed was promoted by The Rambling Man; discussion
28 Oct 2021 – Tolkien and the Great War GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted by KeeperOfThePeace; discussion

FfD

30 Aug 2012 – File:2005 Canadian quarter Year of the Veteran.png FfDed by Stefan2 was closed; discussion

RfC

05 Feb 2013 – Guns, Germs, and Steel RfC by The Devil's Advocate was closed; discussion
03 Jul 2014 – List of wars and anthropogenic disasters by death toll RfC by Fauzan was closed; discussion
undated – World War II RfC was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – David Irving RfC by Nekdolan was closed; discussion
09 Jan 2017 – Philip J. Cohen RfC by Peacemaker67 was closed; discussion
09 Jan 2018 – Carroll Quigley RfC by Owlsmcgee was closed; discussion
23 Jan 2019 – Guns, Germs, and Steel RfC by TAlphaM was closed; discussion
11 Mar 2019 – Guns, Germs, and Steel RfC by Cunard was closed; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Peter Arnett RfC by Coretheapple was closed; discussion
24 Sep 2020 – World War II RfC by E-960 was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2020 – Hungary in World War II RfC by LordRogalDorn was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2020 – Hungary in World War II RfC by LordRogalDorn was closed; discussion
12 Aug 2021 – Arthur Conan Doyle RfC by Skyerise was closed; discussion

ACR

07 Feb 2013 – Troop engagements of the American Civil War, 1863 put up for A-Class review by Wild Wolf was closed; discussion
29 Oct 2014 – The Utility of Force put up for A-Class review by HJ Mitchell was closed; discussion
11 May 2015 – List of United States Army campaigns during World War II put up for A-Class review by Tomandjerry211 was closed; discussion
undated – Milorad Ekmečić put up for A-Class review was closed
undated – Milorad Ekmečić put up for A-Class review was closed
undated – Price's Lost Campaign: The 1864 Invasion of Missouri put up for A-Class review was closed

PR

26 Mar 2013 – World War II put up for PR by Aunva6 was closed; discussion

FLC

23 Jul 2015 – List of United States Army campaigns during World War II FL nominated by Tomandjerry211 (alt) was closed; discussion

RfD

06 Jul 2018 – Rise of Assyria →Assyria RfDed by Mr. Guye was closed; discussion
15 Feb 2020 – Military elite →Elite RfDed by 93.225.157.88 was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Flavio Josefo →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Mattatyahu ben Yosef →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Josephus bar Mathias →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Joseph ben Matityahu →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Joseph Ben Mattias →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion
04 Mar 2022 – Joseph Ben Matthias →Josephus RfDed by Avilich was closed; discussion

AFC

23 Jul 2019 – Draft:History of Aviation in Bălți submitted for AfC by Aviapassion was declined by DGG on 31 Jul 2019
17 Sep 2019 – Draft:Ervin L. Jordan, Jr. submitted for AfC by Srcollier94 was declined by Missvain on 15 Jan 2020
28 Mar 2021 – Draft:Gregory J. W. Urwin submitted for AfC by FloridaArmy was moved to Gregory J. W. Urwin by DGG on 06 Apr 2021
undated – Draft:Walter Boardman Kerr submitted for AfC was accepted to Walter Boardman Kerr by Devonian Wombat on 07 Nov 2021
undated – Draft:Gregory J. W. Urwin submitted for AfC was moved to Gregory J. W. Urwin by DGG on 06 Apr 2021

MRG

25 May 2019 – List of wars and anthropogenic disasters by death toll proposed for merging to List of wars by death toll by Jack90s15 was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2019 – Military junta proposed for merging to Military dictatorship by Coffeeandcrumbs was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2019 – Military dictatorship proposed for merging to Military junta by Coffeeandcrumbs was closed; discussion
18 Oct 2019 – Principles of war (initially Principles of warfare) proposed for merging to Principles of warfare by Wbm1058 was closed; discussion
18 Oct 2019 – Principles of war (initially Principles of warfare) proposed for merging to Principles of warfare by Wbm1058 was closed; discussion
10 Mar 2021 – Narrative of the Expedition of an American Squadron to the China Seas and Japan proposed for merging to Perry Expedition by Fayenatic london was closed; discussion

CfD

24 Jan 2020 – Category:Maritime history topical overviews CfDed by DexDor was closed; discussion
07 Jul 2022 – Category:Military in fiction CfDed by Zxcvbnm was closed; discussion

SPL

17 Nov 2020 – List of revolutions and rebellions proposed for splitting by CPA-5 was closed; discussion
02 May 2021 – Posidonius proposed for splitting by Fgnievinski was closed; discussion

AAlertBot is coded by Hellknowz and co-operated with Headbomb. Discuss? / Report bug? / Request feature?