Gratitude was also co-produced by Maurice White and Charles Stepney. The LP consists of mostly live concert material together with some newly recorded tracks.[1]
With a four out of five star review Kit Aiken of Uncut called Gratitude "a kicking live album".[16] Henry Edwards of the New York Times said "All of the music is carefully tooled, zestfully polished, relentlessly good‐natured rhythmic dance music, an amalgam of rhythm‐and‐blues, jazz and middle‐of‐the‐road pop that the group gleefully shouts, croons, squeals and growls. There's showmanship galore here, but strip that showmanship away and one discovers that Earth, Wind & Fire's music is built around one persistently repeated chord‐and not the world's most interesting chord either."[15] Will Smith of the Omaha World Herald scribed "Gratitude by Earth, Wind & Fire has the soul that so many so-called soul groups lack. The nine-man group manages to keep the interest level high on this two-record set with the inclusion of jazz tinges."[14] Alex Henderson of Allmusic, in a 4.5 out of 5 star review found that "Gratitude is one of EWF's finest accomplishments."[9]
Cliff White of NME called Gratitude "Proof at last that EWF deserve all the acclaim that's been heaped on them in the last couple of years..Now we get to hear them at their very best and it's suddenly apparent that they knock most other "progressive" black groups into a cocked hat.[13] Mike Kalina of the Pittsburgh Post Gazette claimed Gratitude "features a variety of superb rhythm and blues material with plenty of jazz overtones. The group's lyrics may not be the most innovative but they all fit perfectly into the patchwork of funk the group weaves. The musicianship of the group cannot be beat nor can the feeling that this group - my favorite in the R&B idiom - puts out."[18] Tony Green of Spin exclaimed "A frightfully accomplished funk hit machine flexing its muscles live is truly a beautiful thing. And few had as much flex-worthy musical mass as these crossover kings. The White brothers melded proto-Afrocentricism with self help optimism, filling out their sound with Jazz leanings and swelling summer breeze ballads. An album that's capable at any moment of landing an emotional killer blow."[12]Greg Kot of the Chicago Tribune found "an Ellingtonian fusion of styles on this live masterpiece."[17]
”Live Bonus Medley” Recorded Live on February 11, 1978, at Hollywood Sunset Sound Recorders in Hollywood, California for a 1978 TV Variety Special starring Natalie Cole.
[9]
[16]
