Jump to content

Interfaith marriage in Judaism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 174.98.170.14 (talk) at 11:25, 5 September 2024 (→Ancient times). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The Wedding Feast of Samson by Rembrandt, depicting the marriage of Samson and Delilah.

Interfaith marriage in Judaism (also called mixed marriage or intermarriage) was historically looked upon with very strong disfavor by Jewish leaders, and it remains a controversial issue among them today. Many Jews followed the Talmud and all of resulting Jewish law Halakha until the advent of new Jewish movements following the Jewish Enlightenment resulted in the "Haskala"; in Halakha marriage between a Jew and a gentile is both prohibited, and also void under Jewish law.[1]

A 2020 survey conducted in the United States by the Pew Research Center found that 42% of all currently married Jewish respondents indicated they have a non-Jewish spouse. Among those who had married since 2010, 61% were intermarried and the percent increases to 72% when Orthodox Jews were excluded from the data.[2]

Ancient times

The Hebrew Bible contains numerous examples of interethnic marriage. Numerous figures, such as Abraham, Moses, and David, are described taking non-Israelite women as wives or consorts, and the books of Ezra–Nehemiah describe widespread intermarriage of Jews and Samaritans, and to a lesser extent, Philistines. Interfaith marriage, on the other hand, was almost universally condemned, as it was perceived that such a union could result in the perversion or abandonment of Israelite religion. Since the notion of these interethnic marriages were inextricably tied to the potential mixing of Israelite and foreign religions, the biblical text uses the condition of having "foreign" spouses to illustrate the concerns surrounding interfaith unions.[3][4]

The Bible contains numerous laws which either forbid or restrict interethnic, and thus interfaith, marriage: ancient Israelites were forbidden from intermarrying with any one of seven "nations" that also dwelt within the "Land of Israel".[5] Israelites were permitted to take foreign female prisoners of war as wives, but only under specific conditions: the women could not have come from any city within the Land of Israel, as these cities may have been inhabited by the aforementioned nations, the captive woman was to be a virgin;[6] and was not allowed to have any sexual relations with her captor until after she had mourned her absent parents for a full month; if a soldier became tired of her, he was to give her freedom if she asked for it; he was not to sell her or enslave her since this was a marriage under compulsion.[7][8][9] Also the Torah has an example that a Jewish soldier should not marry a captive non jewish woman as a wife because the son would rebel against his father as happens to King David and Absalom,Cite error: There are <ref> tags on this page without content in them (see the help page).Woman captured in war[10]

The crisis of the Babylonian exile renewed concerns for maintaining the "purity" of the ethnic Israelite population. Ezra is described as exhorting his fellow Jews to send away their "foreign" wives and children,[11] and under his tutelage intermarriage came to be highly discouraged.[12]

Later laws and rulings

The Talmud holds that a marriage between a Jew and a non-Jew is both prohibited and also does not constitute a marriage under Jewish law – the non-Jew would need to convert in order for the marriage to be legal.[1] From biblical times until the Middle Ages, exogamy (marriage outside the community) was common, as was conversion to Judaism.[13]

In Europe, Medieval Christian rulers regarded unions between Jews and Christians unfavourably, and repeatedly prohibited them under penalty of death.[14][15][16]

Gradually, however, many countries removed these restrictions, and marriage between Jews and Christians (and Muslims) began to occur. In 1236, Moses of Coucy induced the Jews bespoused by such marriages to dissolve them.[17] In 1807, Napoleon's Grand Sanhedrin declared that such marriages although not valid under Jewish law were civilly valid and should not be treated as anathema.[18] In 1844, the 1807 ruling was extended by the Rabbinical Conference of Brunswick to include any adherent of a monotheistic religion,[18] but they also altered it to forbid marriages involving those who lived in states that would prevent children of the marriage from being raised Jewish.[18] This conference was highly controversial; one of its resolutions called on its members to abolish the Kol Nidre prayer, which opens the Yom Kippur service.[19] One member of the Brunswick Conference later changed his opinion, becoming an opponent of intermarriage.[20]

Traditional Judaism does not consider marriage between a Jew by birth and a convert as an intermarriage.[21][22] Hence, all the Biblical passages that appear to support intermarriages, such as that of Joseph to Asenath, and that of Ruth to Boaz, were regarded by the classical rabbis as having occurred only after the foreign spouse had converted to Judaism.[23] Some opinions, however, still considered Canaanites forbidden to marry even after conversion; this did not necessarily apply to their children.[24] The Shulchan Aruch and its commentaries[25] bring various opinions as to whether intermarriage is a Torah prohibition and when the prohibition is rabbinic.

A foundling – a person who was abandoned as a child without their parents being identified – was classified as a non-Jew, in relation to intermarriage, if they had been found in an area where at least one non-Jew lived (even if there were hundreds of Jews in the area, and just one non-Jew);[26] this drastically contrasts with the treatment by other areas of Jewish religion, in which a foundling was classified as Jewish if the majority of the people were Jewish in the area in which the foundling was found.[26] If the mother was known, but not the father, the child was treated as a foundling, unless the mother claimed that the child was an Israelite (the claim would be given the benefit of the doubt).[27][28][29]

Marriages between Jews and "German-blooded" people were banned in Nazi Germany under the Nuremberg Laws.[30]

Modern attitudes

The Talmud and later classical sources of Jewish law are clear that the institution of Jewish marriage, kiddushin, can only be effected between Jews.

All branches of Orthodox Judaism follow the historic Jewish attitudes to intermarriage, and therefore refuse to accept that intermarriages would have any validity or legitimacy, and strictly forbid sexual intercourse with a member of a different faith. Orthodox rabbis refuse to officiate at interfaith weddings, and also try to avoid assisting them in other ways. Secular intermarriage is seen as a deliberate rejection of Judaism, and an intermarried person is effectively cut off from most of the Orthodox community,[citation needed] although some Chabad-Lubavitch[31] and Modern Orthodox Jews[citation needed] do reach out to intermarried Jews, especially Jewish women (because Orthodox Jewish law considers the children of Jewish women to be Jews regardless of the father's status).[32] For Orthodox Jews marriage of a Jewish man with a Jewish woman is a reunion of two halves of the same Soul;[33] thus for the Orthodox a Jewish man to have any relationship with a "Shiksa" (gentile woman) or a Jewish woman to have any relationship with a goy (gentile man) would be considered a disgrace. Some Orthodox families will sit shiva (Mourning) for someone who has married outside the faith because unless to prevent assimilation both the father and the mother teach both their sons and daughters to accept the Iron Yoke of the Torah,[34] the chances are not good the child will be raised in the Jewish faith; hence the sitting of Shiva is mourning for successive generations of children who will not be raised Jewish. Hence to the Orthodox Jews Intermarriage is the "Silent Holocaust"(see below). The only legal way for children of such relationships to be part of a Jewish community, is for them of their own free will to willingly accept the Iron Yoke of the Torah with help from Orthodox Jewish guidance.

The Conservative Movement in Judaism does not sanction or recognize the Jewish legal validity of intermarriage, but encourages acceptance of the non-Jewish spouse within the family, hoping that such acceptance will lead to the spouse's conversion to Judaism. The Rabbinical Assembly Standards of Rabbinic Practice prohibit Conservative rabbis from officiating at intermarriages, and officially forbade Conservative rabbis from attending intermarriages until 2018.[35] In 1995 the Leadership Council of Conservative Judaism published the following statement on intermarriage:

In the past, intermarriage... was viewed as an act of rebellion, a rejection of Judaism. Jews who intermarried were essentially excommunicated. But now, intermarriage is often the result of living in an open society... If our children end up marrying non-Jews, we should not reject them. We should continue to give our love and by that retain a measure of influence in their lives, Jewishly and otherwise. Life consists of constant growth and our adult children may yet reach a stage when Judaism has new meaning for them. However, the marriage between a Jew and non-Jew is not a celebration for the Jewish community.....[36]


The more liberal American Jewish movements—including Reform, Reconstructionist (collectively organized in the World Union for Progressive Judaism)—do not generally regard the historic corpus and process of Jewish law as intrinsically binding. Progressive rabbinical associations have no firm prohibition against intermarriage; according to a survey of rabbis, conducted in 1985, more than 87% of Reconstructionist rabbis were willing to officiate at interfaith marriages,[37] and in 2003 at least 50% of Reform rabbis were willing to perform interfaith marriages.[38] The Central Conference of American Rabbis, the Reform rabbinical association in North America and the largest Progressive rabbinical association, consistently opposed intermarriage at least until the 1980s, including their members officiating at them, through resolutions and responsa.[39][40][41] In 2015, the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College voted to accept rabbinical students in interfaith relationships, making Reconstructionist Judaism the first type of Judaism to officially allow rabbis in relationships with non-Jewish partners.[42]

Humanistic Judaism is a Jewish movement that offers a nontheistic alternative in contemporary Jewish life, and defines Judaism as the cultural and historical experience of the Jewish people.[citation needed] The Society for Humanistic Judaism answers the question "Is intermarriage contributing to the demise of Judaism?" on its website, stating, "Intermarriage is the positive consequence of a free and open society. If the Jewish community is open, welcoming, embracing, and pluralistic, we will encourage more people to identify with the Jewish people rather than fewer. Intermarriage could contribute to the continuity of the Jewish people."[43]

The largest Reform Synagogue in New York- Central Synagogue, performs "interfaith" marriages. Such marriages are conducted to strengthen Jewish continuity (with the aim that the non-Jewish spouse will convert to Judaism).[44] The 2013 study by Pew Research "What happens when Jews intermarry?" found that children of intermarriage are much more likely to intermarry themselves and much more likely than people with two Jewish parents to describe themselves religiously as atheist, agnostic or just “nothing in particular.” The Study "also suggests" that an increasing percentage of the children of intermarriages are Jewish in adulthood. Among Americans age 65 and older who at the time of the survey said they had one Jewish parent, 25% were Jewish. By contrast, among adults under 30 with one Jewish parent, 59% were Jewish at the time of the survey. Therefore "in this sense, intermarriage may be transmitting Jewish identity to a growing number of Americans.". The survey qualifies that "it is snapshot in time and shows show associations, or linkages, rather than clear causal connections" and it is unknown "whether the large cohort of young adult children of intermarriage who are Jewish today will remain Jewish as they age, marry (and in some cases, intermarry), start families and move through the life cycle".[45]

Prevalence

In a Pew Research poll conducted in 2013 found that religious and non religious Jews 58% of marriages were interfaith, but that there was significant differences in the prevalence of interfaith marriages by denomination. Among Orthodox Jews 2% of marriages were interfaith; among Conservative Jews 27% were interfaith; among Reform Jews 50% were interfaith; and, among Non-Denominational Jews 69% were interfaith. Among those who were religiously Jewish only 36% had interfaith marriages while 79% of Atheist jews have interfaith marriages. Those who had been married longer also had lower rates of intermarriage. The rates of intermarriage have been consistent since 2000 but had decreased from a low of 17% of marriages being interfaith before 1970.[46]

The exact definition of 'interfaith' marriage

Different movements in Judaism have different views on who is a Jew, and thus on what constitutes an interfaith marriage. Unlike Reform Judaism, the Orthodox stream does not accept as Jewish a person whose mother is not Jewish, nor a convert whose conversion was not performed according to classical Jewish law. Conservative Judaism does not accept patrilineal descent. Some Conservative rabbis will accept Reform conversions even absent traditional halachic criteria.

Occasionally, a Jew marries a non-Jew who believes in God as understood by Judaism, and who rejects non-Jewish theologies; Jews sometimes call such people Noahides. Steven Greenberg, an Orthodox Rabbi, has made the controversial proposal that, in these cases, the non-Jewish partner be considered a resident alien – the biblical description of someone who is not Jewish, but who lives within the Jewish community; according to Jewish tradition, such resident aliens share many of the same responsibilities and privileges as the Jewish community in which they reside.[citation needed]

Impact and consequences

In the early 19th century, in some less modernised regions of the world, exogamy was extremely rare—less than 0.1% of the Jews of Algeria, for example, practiced exogamy.[47] In the early 20th century, even in most Germanic regions of central Europe[48] there were still only a mere 5% of Jews marrying non-Jews.[49][50][51] However, the picture was quite different in other locations; the figure was 18% for Berlin,[52] and during the same period, nearly half of all Jews in Australia intermarried.[53]

In more recent times, rates of intermarriage have increased generally; for example, the US National Jewish Population Survey 2000-01 reports that, in the United States of America between 1996 and 2001, nearly half (47%) of Jews who had married during that time period had married non-Jewish partners.[54] The 1990 National Jewish Population Survey reported an intermarriage rate of 52 percent among American Jews.[55] The possibility that this might lead to the gradual dying out of Judaism is regarded by most Jewish leaders, regardless of denomination, as precipitating a crisis.[56] For this reason, as early as the mid 19th century, some senior Jewish leaders denounced intermarriage as a danger to the continued existence of Judaism.[57]

In the United States of America, other causes, such as more people marrying later in life, have combined with intermarriage to cause the Jewish community to decrease dramatically; for every 20 adult Jews, there are now only 17 Jewish children.[citation needed] Some religious conservatives now even speak metaphorically of intermarriage as a silent holocaust. On the other hand, more tolerant and liberal Jews embrace interfaith marriage as an enriching contribution to a multicultural society. Regardless of attitudes to intermarriage, there is now an increasing effort to reach out to descendants of intermarried parents, each Jewish denomination focusing on those it defines as Jewish;[citation needed] secular and non-denominational Jewish organisations have sprung up to bring the descendants of intermarried parents back into the Jewish fold.[58][59]

In some cases, children of a Jewish parent were raised in the non-Jewish parent's religion while maintaining a sense of Jewish ethnicity and identity. An example of such a child is the late Barry Goldwater, who had a Jewish father, but was a lifelong Episcopalian like his mother, though Goldwater rarely referred to himself as Jewish.[60]

Christian–Jewish relations

Main article: Christianity and Judaism

In Christian–Jewish relations, interfaith marriage and the associated phenomenon of Jewish assimilation are a matter of concern for both Jewish and Christian leaders. Most mainstream Christian churches accept and may even promote the conversion of Jews. However, a number of Progressive Christian denominations have publicly declared that they will no longer adhere to this practice. These churches embrace dual-covenant theology.[61][62][63] Additionally, Jewish counter-missionary and anti-missionary organizations like Outreach Judaism encourage Jews to reject conversion to Christianity, while Messianic Jewish organizations like Jews for Jesus actively work to encourage it.[64][65]

Opposition to mixed marriages in Israel

Most Israeli Jews oppose mixed relationships, particularly those between Jewish women and Muslim men. A 2007 opinion survey found that over half of Israeli Jews believed intermarriage is equivalent to "national treason"[citation needed]. In 2005, Ben-Zion Gopstein, a disciple of the ultra-nationalist Meir Kahane, founded the anti-miscegenation organisation Lehava.[66] The group's name is an acronym for “To Prevent Assimilation in the Holy Land”.[67] A group of Jewish "Lehava" men[68] started patrolling the Jerusalem neighborhood of Pisgat Ze'ev in an effort to stop Jewish women from dating Arab men. The municipality of Petah Tikva has also announced an initiative to prevent interfaith relationships, providing a telephone hotline for friends and family to "inform" on Jewish girls who date Arab men as well as psychologists to provide counselling. The city of Kiryat Gat launched a school programme in schools to warn Jewish girls against dating local Bedouin men.[69][70] In November 2019, Lehava leader Gopstein was indicted on charges of incitement to terrorism, violence, and racism.[71] Chemla is also dictated of rescuing Jewish Women from marriage with Arabs[72] Yad L'Achim also opposes Interfaith marriages.[73]

Interfaith marriages are extremely rare in Israel, reaching about two percent of the population. In addition, about 97 percent of Jews in the same Pew Research Center study, conducted in 2014-2015, stated that they would be not be completely comfortable with their child marrying a Muslim while 89 percent expressed similar views when asked about a hypothetical marriage to a Christian.[74]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b Kiddushin 68b
  2. ^ "Jewish Americans In 2020: Marriage, families and children". Pew Research Center. 11 May 2021.
  3. ^ Public Domain This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain: Legends of the Jews pp.100-101
  4. ^ Response of Rabbi Eliezer Zalmanov 08/19/2022
  5. ^ Deuteronomy 20:15-17; Joshua 9:1-2; Joshua 24:12
  6. ^ Numbers:31 17-18; Judges 21:9-21
  7. ^ Deuteronomy 21:10-14
  8. ^ Woman captured in War Aish Torah
  9. ^ The Torah position on Rape
  10. ^ Ask the Rabbi query - Response of Rabbi Eliezer Zalmanov for Chabad.org 22 August 2022
  11. ^ Intermarriage Jewish Encyclopedia
  12. ^ Ezra Chapters 9 and 10
  13. ^ Birenbaum-Carmeli, D.; Inhorn, M.C. (2009). Assisting Reproduction, Testing Genes: Global Encounters with the New Biotechnologies. Fertility, Reproduction and Sexuality: Social and Cultural Perspectives. Berghahn Books. p. 7. ISBN 978-1-84545-941-3. Retrieved 8 July 2023. Going back to biblical times and into the second century BCE through late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, the Jewish collectivity seemed rather amenable to exogamy and conversion. This has changed in later periods
  14. ^ Codex Theodosianus, 16:8, 6
  15. ^ Heinrich Grätz, Geschichte der Juden (=History of the Jews) 4:363; 5:359; 7;27
  16. ^ Leopold Löw, Gesammelte Werke, 2:176
  17. ^ Moses of Coucy, Sefer Mitzvot ha-Gadol, 112
  18. ^ a b c  This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Singer, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). "Intermarriage". The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.
  19. ^ Jewish Encyclopedia, "Conferences, Rabbinical"
  20. ^ Ludwig Philippson, Israelitische Religionslehre (1865), 3:350
  21. ^ Berakhot 28a
  22. ^ Rabbi Yosef Karo, Shulchan Aruch III:4:10
  23. ^ Genesis Rabbah, 65
  24. ^ Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Sanctity, Laws of Prohibited Relations, 12:22 and Maggid Mashnah ad. loc.
  25. ^ III:16:2
  26. ^ a b  This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Singer, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). "Foundling". The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.
  27. ^ Ketubot 13a
  28. ^ Kiddushin 74a
  29. ^ Ketubot (Palestinian Talmud only) 1:9
  30. ^ Strnad, Maximilian (2015). "The Fortune of Survival – Intermarried German Jews in the Dying Breath of the 'Thousand-Year Reich'". Dapim: Studies on the Holocaust. 29 (3): 173–196. doi:10.1080/23256249.2015.1082806. S2CID 163076737.
  31. ^ "New Chabad Representatives Broach Intermarriage Directly". 30 July 2007. Retrieved 5 January 2020.
  32. ^ In laws and Shabbat Law
  33. ^ On Intermarriage Rabbi Eliezer Shemtov
  34. ^ Response of Rabbi Eliezer Zalmanov 08/01/2019
  35. ^ Rabbinical-Assembly. "Update to Standards of Practice". The Rabbinical Assembly. Retrieved 26 April 2022.
  36. ^ Leadership Council of Conservative Judaism, Statement on Intermarriage, Adopted on 7 March 1995
  37. ^ Survey of the American Rabbinate, The Jewish Outreach Institute, [1] Archived 3 September 2009 at the Wayback Machine (retrieved 6 May 2009)
  38. ^ Summary of Rabbinic Center for Research and Counseling 2003 Survey, Irwin H. Fishbein, Rabbi, D. Min., Rabbinic Center for Research and Counseling, [2] (retrieved 6 May 2009)
  39. ^ Reform Judaism and Mixed Marriage Archived 21 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine CCAR Responsa (Vol. XC, 1980, pp. 86–102), American Reform Responsa 146.
  40. ^ Rabbi Officiating at a Mixed Marriage Archived 21 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine CCAR Responsa (Vol. XCII, 1982, pp. 213–215), American Reform Responsa 149.
  41. ^ Prayer for Couple Contemplating Intermarriage Archived 21 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine CCAR Responsa (1979), American Reform Responsa 147.
  42. ^ Lisa Hostein (1 October 2015). "Reconstructionists give green light to intermarried rabbinical students". J. weekly. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
  43. ^ "13 Tough Questions". Shj.org. 13 May 2013. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
  44. ^ Ettinger, Yair (14 January 2019). "'Judaism Shouldn't Have to Stay Alive Only Because Jews Are Afraid of Everything Else'". Haaretz.
  45. ^ "What happens when Jews intermarry?".
  46. ^ "Chapter 2: Intermarriage and Other Demographics". Pew Research Center. 1 October 2013. Retrieved 25 April 2024.
  47. ^ Ricoux, Demography of Algeria, Paris, 1860, p. 71
  48. ^ Prussia, Bavaria, Austria, Bohemia, etc.
  49. ^ Census for Prussian Statistics, 1902, p. 216
  50. ^ Census of the Baverian Kingdom, Statistics Bureaux, 1900, p. 259
  51. ^ Statebook of Austria 8:283, Vienna, 1900
  52. ^ Statistics Yearbook, 1902, p. 61
  53. ^ specifically, 44% in New South Wales; Census of New South Wales, 1901, Bulletin No. 14
  54. ^ "American Jewry Today - Jewish Population Statistics - 2000 NJPS National Jewish Population Survey". Judaism.about.com. 11 June 2009. Archived from the original on 5 June 2011. Retrieved 10 September 2013.
  55. ^ "National Jewish Population Survey: 1990 - My Jewish Learning". Smyjewishlearning.atypica.com. Archived from the original on 7 July 2011. Retrieved 10 September 2013.
  56. ^ What Is Wrong with Intermarriage? Chabad.org
  57. ^ Geiger and Aub,Leipsic Synod 1869; Referate über die der Ersten Synode Gestellten Anträge p. 193
  58. ^ "Beta-Gershom.org".
  59. ^ "Jewish Outreach Institute". joi.org. Archived from the original on 3 February 2011. Retrieved 6 May 2009.
  60. ^ Clymer, Adam (29 May 1998). "Barry Goldwater, Conservative and Individualist, Dies at 89". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 7 March 2013.
  61. ^ Ecumenical Considerations on Jewish-Christian Dialogue (World Council of Churches)
  62. ^ Brockway, Allan R. "Should Christians Attempt to Evangelize Jews?". abrock.com. Archived from the original on 24 January 2010. Retrieved 3 January 2010.
  63. ^ Policies of mainline and liberal Christians towards proselytizing Jews Archived 12 March 2017 at the Wayback Machine (religioustolerance.org)
  64. ^ David Cho, "Conversion Outreach Plan Stirs Outrage: Jews for Jesus Trains 600 for Street Work", The Washington Post, 17 August 2004; Page B01 full text[dead link‍]
  65. ^ "Aishdas Torahnet". Aishdas.org. Retrieved 21 January 2011.
  66. ^ "Israeli press review: Minister calls marriages with non-Jews 'a second Holocaust'". Middle East Eye.
  67. ^ "Racism in Israel". Open Democracy.
  68. ^ Freedman, Seth (29 September 2009). "Israel's vile anti-miscegenation squads". The Guardian.
  69. ^ "'Protecting' Jewish girls from Arabs". The Jerusalem Post. 18 September 2009.
  70. ^ Cook, Jonathan. "Israeli drive to prevent Jewish girls dating Arabs". The National.
  71. ^ Sharon, Jeremy. "Lehava head Bentzi Gopstein indicted for incitement to terror, racism". The Jerusalem Post.
  72. ^ Israel National News Chemla organization: "Jewish women ensnared into marriage with Arabs" 30 November 2023
  73. ^ Gontarz, Nir (22 December 2018). "The Israeli Charity "Helping" Jewish Women in "Arab Captivity"". Haaretz. Retrieved 27 October 2019.
  74. ^ Pew Research Center (8 March 2016). "11. Intergroup marriage and friendship". Retrieved 19 July 2024.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Interfaith_marriage_in_Judaism&oldid=1244156404"