Jump to content

War of Liberation (1989–1990)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Lebleblebanon (talk | contribs) at 03:39, 6 October 2024. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

War of Liberation
Part of the Lebanese Civil War
DateMarch 1989 – 13 October 1990
(1 year, 7 months and 5 days)
Location
Greater Beirut region and surroundings, Lebanon
Result Syrian Allied Victory
Belligerents
Lebanese Army (Pro-Aoun Faction)
Supported by
Iraq

 Syria

Lebanese Army (Pro-Hrawi Faction)

Lebanese Forces

Supported by
Iraq[1]
Commanders and leaders
Michel Aoun Surrendered
Issam Abu Jamra Surrendered
Edgar Maalouf Surrendered
Saddam Hussein		 Hafez al-Assad
Ghazi Kanaan
Elias Hrawi
Salim Al-Huss
Émile Lahoud[2]
Élie Hayek
René Moawad †		 Samir Geagea
Boutros Khawand
Hanna Atik
Strength
15,000[3][4] 40,000[4]
10,000[5]		 10,000[6][3]
Casualties and losses
500-750 killed during the fighting
Additionally at least 250 Lebanese unarmed prisoners executed, including civilians[7]

The War of Liberation (Arabic: حرب التحرير) was a sub-conflict within the final phase of the Lebanese Civil War between 1989 and 1990, in which the Lebanese Army loyal to General and Prime Minister Michel Aoun, appointed by previous President Amine Gemayel and headquartered in eastern Beirut, fought against the western Beirut-based Syrian Armed Forces and the Lebanese Army loyal to President Elias Hrawi and Prime Minister Salim Al-Huss, appointed by the Taif Agreement. Aoun launched several offensives against the Lebanese Forces in an attempt to establish his authority over East Beirut. The conflict culminated on 13 October 1990, when the Syrian Army stormed Baabda Palace and other strongholds of Aoun, killing hundreds of Lebanese soldiers and civilians and ousting Aoun, marking the end of the Lebanese Civil War. Aoun survived and moved to France to live in exile.

Background

Main articles: Lebanese Civil War, Syrian occupation of Lebanon, and Taif Agreement

The Lebanese Civil War began in 1975, and in 1976 Syria began an occupation of parts of Lebanon. In 1989, various Lebanese Factions signed the Taif Agreement in an attempt to end the Civil War, but Michel Aoun opposed the agreement, since it did not provide a deadline for the withdrawal of Syrian troops.[8]

Leaders involved

In East Beirut, Aoun's provisional government consisted of himself (prime minister), Colonel Issam Abu Jamra (Greek Orthodox), and Brigadier General Edgar Maalouf (Greek Catholic). President Gemayel's decree, signed 15 minutes before his term expired, on 22 September 1988, also included three Muslim ministers (Sunni, Shiite, Druze), but all three rejected the posts and immediately resigned. Despite this, Aoun insisted he was the legal Prime Minister.[9]

In West Beirut, Hrawi's government consisted of a cabinet equally divided between Christians and Muslims, with Salim Al-Huss as Prime Minister. The Commander-in-chief of the LAF, General Emile Lahoud, had been appointed on 28 November 1989. In March 1990, the cabinet selected General Elie Hayek as commander of the Mount Lebanon region.

The Lebanese Forces (LF) - headed by Samir Geagea - were headquartered in La Quarantaine (directly bordering Achrafieh from the East), and were in control of East Beirut, the coastal Metn and Baabda. They held the entire districts (cazas) of Keserwan, Jbeil, Batroun, Koura, Bcharri, and parts of Zgharta.

Events

War begins

Michel Aoun during the Lebanese Civil War

On 15 February 1989 General Aoun launched an offensive, with those Lebanese Army Brigades loyal to him (30% of whom were Sunni),[10] against Geagea’s Lebanese Forces (LF) positions around Christian East Beirut. At the time it was estimated that Aoun’s portion of the army amounted to 16,000 men, while the LF had 10,000; both sides were equipped with tanks and heavy artillery.[11] Nine days later, 24 February, with seventy people killed and the intervention of the Maronite Patriarchate, the LF agreed to hand over to Aoun control of Beirut’s port’s fifth basin with its estimated $300,000 per month tax revenue. Suleiman Frangieh, in the north, also returned control of Ras Salaata port in Batroun District[12] The following month Aoun launched a blockade against the unregulated seaports south of Beirut at Jieh and Khalde. On 8 March 1989 Aoun’s patrol boats intercepted a boat heading for PSP controlled port at Jieh. This percipitated a series of indiscriminate artillery barrages, with Amal shelling East Beirut harbour and Jouneh port, and Aoun’s army brigades shelling Souq El Gharb. On the 12 March Aoun ordered the closure of Beirut International Airport and two days later launched an hour long bombardment of West Beirut which killed 40 civilians.[13] At the end of the month Aoun announced a ceasefire with the issue of the militia-run ports unresolved. The area had seen the worst violence for three years with over 90 people killed and several hundred wounded.[10][14][15][16][17][18]

Aoun under siege

In April 1989, as General Aoun continued to blockade the militia sea-ports South of Beirut, the Syrian Army and their proxy militia, the Druze PSP, began intermittent shelling of Beirut harbour and the ports at Jounieh and Byblos. Simultaneously the Arab League was making intense efforts to establish a truce between Aoun and Syria. On the 4 April Kuwait’s Foreign Minister flew to Damascus for talks. On 19 April twenty-three Christian Members of Parliament called for a cease fire. Ignoring this appeal the Lebanese Forces (LF) in East Beirut joined in the exchanges of fire. At the start of the month there was a massive fire at a fuel depot in Dora, close to Beirut harbour. The sound of one of the liquid gas containers exploding was heard 40km away in Sidon. Civilians had begun to leave both sides of Beirut. It was reported that 10,000 Beirut residents had arrived in Limasol in the six weeks to the end of April.[19] The Arab League called for a three month truce and an end of the ports blockade but continued shelling of East Beirut by the PSP ensured that the truce did not hold and the exchanges of fire grew in intensity.[20] On 16 May 1989 Grand Mufti Hassan Khaled, spiritual leader of Lebanon’s Sunni Muslims, was assassinated while being driven through Beirut by a car bomb which killed at least 20 other people.[21]

By late June Aoun’s gunners were launching barrages against Syrian positions which lasted for 5-7 hours. The area under his control was blockaded by land and sea. In June an oil tanker was destroyed off Jouneh.[22] The Arab League peace initiative, led by Algeria, Saudi Arabia and Morocco, managed to get Iraq to stop selling weapons to Aoun and the following month a shipment of 50 Frog missiles was intercepted in Aqaba. On 4 July a truce allowed the opening of the crossings between East and West Beirut for the first time in three months. The airport remained closed because of the threat of Aoun’s guns and two Syrian frigates were maintaining the blockade. Daily shelling continued, mostly from Syrian positions. The electricity supply in the city was reduced to one hour a day and there was an acute shortage of fuel.[23]

On 17 July the LF joined forces with Aoun to launch a blitz on West Beirut in which ‘scores’ were killed. With nightly artillery exchanges continuing the Arab League announced on 31 July that they had ended their efforts to end the conflict. On 10 August the Syrians launched a massive artillery offensive on targets in the Christian enclave, culminating three days later in a PSP ground offensive against Aoun’s positions in Souq El Gharb overlooking the palace at Baabda and the Ministry of Defence at Yarze. The attack failed with 20-30 PSP men killed. Aoun’s forces retaliated by bombarding Syrian positions in the Beqaa Valley. Two weeks later, 29 August, the Sun Shield, a Danish registered fuel tanker was hit by shellfire, caught fire and sank in Jouneh bay. Nine crew members were killed.[24][25]

It was estimated that by this time only between 10% and 15% of the civilian population remained in Beirut. There had been no water or electricity for two weeks.[26][15][27]

On 6 September 1989, without prior announcement American Ambassador John Thomas McCarthy and 29 staff were airlifted out of the US embassy in Aoun’s enclave. Police counts for the previous six months gave 828 people killed and 2,455 wounded.[28]

In September 1989 Saudi Arabia presented a seven-point peace plan which Aoun accepted and on 22 September a cease fire was announced and Beirut airport was re-opened having been closed for six months.[29] People began returning to the city and schools re-opened on 10 October. The Syrian blockade of fuel for the city’s power station in the Christian enclave meant there was only electricity for two hours a day.[30] Meanwhile sixty-two members of parliament, half Christian and half Muslim, were meeting in Taif. After three weeks of negotiations they came to an agreement which Aoun rejected on 22 October. Dany Chamoun, one of Aoun’s loyal supporters, was in favour of the deal. George Saadeh, leader of the Kataeb Party (the political wing of the LF), had been one of the key Christian negotiators in Taif.[31][32] In an attempt to derail the Taif timetable, on 3 November, Aoun announced that he was dissolving parliament and tens of thousands of his supporters took to the streets. Thousands gathered around the Presidential palace in Baabda and a large group invaded the Maronite headquarters in Bkerké where they abused the Patriarch, Nasrallah Sfeir. Geagea sent two hundred LF militiamen to protect the Kataeb radio station, Voice of Lebanon. On 5 November an assembly of members of Parliament, including thirty arriving from exile in Paris, met in Qoleiat air base North Lebanon, and elected Rene Muawad as President. He was recognised by the International Community as the legitimate President of Lebanon[32] but was killed by a car bomb seventeen days later. Twenty-three other people were killed in the explosion. During December thousands remained encamped in Baabda acting as a human shield around Aoun.[33][8]

War of Elimination (حرب الإلغاء)

Samir Geagea (1988)

On 31 January 1990,[34] General Aoun launched an offensive against the Lebanese Forces (LF), led by Samir Geagea, in East Beirut. The two week offensive brought destruction and casualties, 500 killed and 2,000 wounded, that East Beirut had not seen during the Civil War or the Israeli invasion. Aoun could only depend on battalions from 3 loyal Brigades, the 5th, 8th and 10th. It had been anticipated that the LF would be defeated in 48 hours but Aoun’s troops were only able to capture Dbayeh on 6 February.[35] On 15 February Aoun’s forces resumed their attack, capturing Ain al-Rummana and Furn al-Shibbak. Once again there was massive destruction of property. The LF forces escaped via Syrian controlled West Beirut. Two days later, 17/18 February, a truce was agreed to allow 200 of Aoun’s elite commands to leave their base at Adma airfield where they had been trapped since the start of the fighting.[36] The battles left Geagea’s fighters in control of East Beirut and the harbour, as well as Kisrawan and Jbeil provinces. On 24 February an unidentified naval patrol boat attacked the Larnaca-Jounieh ferry ordering it to turn back to Cyprus. One passenger was killed and 17 wounded.[37] Another unsuccessful attack was launched against the East Beirut suburb Sin el Fil, 1 March, and a week later, despite continued sniping and occasional clashes and with the frontline running along the Dog River and around East Beirut, Aoun announced a unilateral ceasefire and his willingness to enter negotiations.[38][8]

The war became known as the war of elimination[39][40][41][42][43] (حرب الإلغاء), a term used by the LF denoting the act of war launched by General Aoun to try to "eliminate" it, but Aoun used another term; Weapon Unification Battle (معركة توحيد البندقية),[44] meaning to unify and submit all the arms in Lebanon into the hand of the Lebanese Army.[45]

LF hands over territory to Hrawi Government

On 1 April 1990, Hrawi’s government mandated Fleet Admiral Elie Hayek (who had been appointed commander of the Mount Lebanon region by the cabinet on 11 March)[citation needed] to take over LF barracks in the governorate. This was part of an agreement between Geagea and Hrawi whereby the army would militarily and politically take over 2/3 of the Christian canton (the remaining 1/3 being the Northern governorate and Achrafieh in East Beirut), but the militia’s 10,000 strong force would remain intact for the time being.[46]

Aoun, however, had publicly stated that he would not accept the handoff or any alliance between the LF and the Hrawi government. As the Elimination War was ravaging East Beirut and its suburbs (up to the Metn), the handoff actually began in Keserwan district – at the level of Nahr el-Kalb – up to Barbara.[47]

By May, however, the LF had taken over the entire coastline from Jounieh to Beirut from Aoun’s troops, completely cutting off naval supply routes.[48] In addition, Geagea placed Hayek in an LF barrack in Jounieh as a symbol of his willingness to integrate with the government, defying Aoun’s refusal of any Hrawi-LF alliance.[49] These developments, combined with the Syrian army’s support, dramatically shifted the odds in favour of the Taef agreement and its government.

Defeat - October 1990

On the evening of 1 October 1990 several hundred people gathered for a candlelit vigil on the edge of the enclave around the Presidential Palace at Ba’abda. General Aoun had been besieged in the Palace for two years and the demonstration was a response to a new blockade imposed by the Hrawi government on the Aounist areas. Gunmen opened fire on the crowd with automatic weapons. Twenty-five people were killed and up to a hundred injured, some in the stampede that followed. The US State Department and Western diplomats were of the opinion that Geagea’s Lebanese Forces were responsible for the shooting.[50] Eleven days later, 12 October, a lone gunman fired two shots at General Aoun whilst he was addressing a crowd outside the palace. Aoun was not hit but one of his bodyguards was killed. Early on the morning of Saturday 13 October the general took refuge in the nearby French Embassy. At 7.00am a pair of Syrian Sukhoi Su-7s made two bombing runs over the palace. At 8.30am General Aoun made a broadcast from the French Embassy calling on his troops to surrender. At the same time he telephoned his officers in the palace asking them to keep resisting for another four or five hours.

There followed a series of atrocities. Soldiers in the Palace displayed white flags but then opened fire on Syrian soldiers approaching, killing 150. Once they had overcome the defenders the Syrians executed perhaps as many as 80 them. With Aoun gone all resistance collapsed. On the Metn the Syrian army used breakaway Lebanese Forces fighters commanded by the Elie Hobeika as well as members of the Syrian Social Nationalist Party to take over Aounist positions. The fighting was accompanied by murders, looting and rape. An estimated 800 combatants and civilians were killed. A week later, 21 October, Dany Chamoun, another militia leader and major Aoun supporter, was murdered along with his wife and two of their children.[51][18]

When the Syrian army took over the Ministry of Defence building they removed all the Deuxiceme Bureau (Military Intelligence) files.[52][50]

Aoun’s wife and three daughters were allowed to leave the country. On arrival in Paris $200,000 cash was found in their entourage’s luggage.[53]

Aftermath

The attack on the Aoun government marked the end of the Lebanese Civil War. Syria would dominate the political life of the country for the following 15 years, under the auspices of the Taif Agreement.

On 16 October 1990, militias in Beirut began dismantling the Green Line, and on 13 November they completed their withdrawal from Beirut, before the 19 November deadline provided by the Taif agreement.[8]

References

  1. ^ The Lebanese Forces: Emergence and Transformation of the Christian Resistance, page 162
  2. ^ Hijazi, Ihsan A. (12 March 1990). "Lebanese President Rejects Offer To Negotiate With Rebel General". The New York Times.
  3. ^ a b Hijazi, Ihsan A. (28 February 1990). "Divisions harden in Lebanese fight". The New York Times.
  4. ^ a b "Lebanese Christian General Flees Compound Under Syrian Bombing". The New York Times. Associated Press. 13 October 1990.
  5. ^ "Aoun's departure strategy". Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada. 1 November 1990.
  6. ^ Hijazi, Ihsan A. (17 February 1990). "Christian General Drives His Rivals From East Beirut". The New York Times.
  7. ^ HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH WORLD REPORT 1990: An Annual Review of Developments and the Bush Administration's Policy on Human Rights Worldwide, January 1991, Human Rights Watch, page 507.
  8. ^ a b c d Refugees, United Nations High Commissioner for. "Refworld | AOUN'S DEPARTURE CHRONOLOGY". Refworld. Retrieved 14 August 2019.
  9. ^ "Military Cabinet Named in Lebanon in Political Crisis". Associated Press.
  10. ^ a b Middle East International No 347, 31 March 1989, Publishers Lord Mayhew, Dennis Walters MP; Jim Muir pp.3,4
  11. ^ Hirst, David (2010) Beware of Small States. Lebanon, battleground of the Middle East. Faber and Faber. ISBN 978-0-571-23741-8 p.210
  12. ^ Middle East International No 345, 3 March 1989; Jim Muir pp.8,9
  13. ^ Middle East International No 346, 17 March 1989; Jim Muir pp.6,7
  14. ^ "MIDEAST TENSIONS; Chronology of 15 Years Of Civil War in Lebanon". The New York Times. 14 October 1990. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 14 August 2019.
  15. ^ a b "Lebanon's Legacy of Political Violence: A Mapping of Serious Violations of International Human Rights and Humanitarian Law in Lebanon, 1975-2008" (PDF). pp. 64, 65.
  16. ^ "Aoun calls majority cowards for not waging war on Syria". Ya Libnan. 25 April 2008. Archived from the original on 26 April 2008. Retrieved 18 May 2008. During this period Aoun became critical of American support for Syria and moved closer to Iraq, accepting arms supplies from Saddam Hussein.
  17. ^ "Aoun calls majority cowards for not waging war on Syria". Lebanese Forces Official Website. 26 April 2008.
  18. ^ a b Middle East International No 390, 21 December 1990; Jim Muir p.12
  19. ^ Middle East International No 348, 14 April 1989; Jim Muir p.7. No 349, 28 April 1989; Jim Muir p.9
  20. ^ Middle East International No 350, 12 May 1989; Jim Muir pp.6,7
  21. ^ Middle East International No 351, 26 May 1989; Jim Muir pp.11,12
  22. ^ Middle East International No 353, 23 June 1989; Godfrey Jansen pp.9,10
  23. ^ Middle East International No 354, 7 July 1989; Jim Muir pp.6-7. No 355, 21 July 1989; Jim Muir p.3-4.
  24. ^ Middle East International No 358, 8 September 1989; Jim Muir pp.6-8
  25. ^ 29 August 1989
  26. ^ Middle East International No 356, 4 August 1989; Jim Muir p.6. No 357, 25 August 1989; Jim Muir pp.3-4
  27. ^ Preston, Matthew (30 September 2004). Ending Civil War: Rhodesia and Lebanon in Perspective. I.B.Tauris. p. 75. ISBN 9781850435792.
  28. ^ Middle East International No 359, 22 September 1989; Jim Muir p10; Donald Neff p.6
  29. ^ Middle East International No 359, 22 September 1989; Jim Muir p.9. No 360, 6 October 1989 Jim Muir pp.6-7
  30. ^ Middle East International No 361, 20 October 1989; G.H. Jansen p.4
  31. ^ Middle East International No 362, 3 November 1989; Jim Muir pp.3-5
  32. ^ a b Middle East International No 363, 17 November 1989; Jim Muir pp.4–5
  33. ^ Middle East International No 365, 15 December 1989; Jim Muir pp.7,8
  34. ^ "January 15, 1986: Geagea overthrows Hobeika to lead the LF". L'Orient Today. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  35. ^ Middle East International No 369, 16 February 1990; Jim Muir pp.5-6
  36. ^ Middle East International No 370, 2 March 1990; Jim Muir pp.6,7,8
  37. ^ Middle East International No 370, 2nd March 1990; Michael Jansen p.7
  38. ^ Middle East International No 371, 16th March 1990; Jim Muir pp.9,10
  39. ^ "Interview with Etienne Sakr: "A dark future for this poor country called Lebanon"". dis:orient (in German). Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  40. ^ "Aoun Floats Idea of Lebanese Military Govt to 'Save' Bassil". Asharq AL-awsat. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  41. ^ "The 'Impossible' Relationship and History of Disputes between Lebanon's Aoun, Jumblatt". Asharq AL-awsat. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  42. ^ "Michel Aoun and the death of Lebanon's Taef accord". Middle East Eye. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  43. ^ "Lebanon's ruling elite are under fire. But who are they?". gulfnews.com. 20 October 2019. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  44. ^ "من لعنة حربي التحرير والإلغاء إلى زلزال بيروت: عهدٌ من النكبات والأزمات | سعد الياس". القدس العربي. 8 August 2020. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
  45. ^ "Lebanon profile - Timeline". BBC News. 25 April 2018. Retrieved 12 July 2021.
  46. ^ "Arab Times".
  47. ^ Mideast Mirror 22 Oct. 1990, 23
  48. ^ "Both sides pounded the Christian enclave daily claiming the lives of 615 people died, and more than 2,000 were wounded, half of them civilians". 21 October 2014.
  49. ^ "Le procès dans l'affaire Murr prendra fin lundi avec les plaidoieries de Karam et du chef des FL Naïm qualifie d'illégale la procédure judiciaire et Rizk souligne le ralliement de Geagea à Taëf(photos)". 8 March 1997.
  50. ^ a b Middle East International No 385, 12 October 1990; Gerald Butt pp.9,10
  51. ^ Middle East International No 386, 26 October 1990; G.H. Jansen pp.8,9
  52. ^ Middle East International No 386, 26 October 1990; G. H Jansen p.9
  53. ^ Middle East International No 386, 26 October 1990; Robert Swann p.10

Literature

  • William Harris, Faces of Lebanon. Sects, Wars, and Global Extensions (Markus Wiener Publishers, Princeton, USA 1996)

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=War_of_Liberation_(1989–1990)&oldid=1249657485"