Power Stage

The Power Stage (abbreviated as PS) is a special stage that usually runs as the final stage of a rally in the World Rally Championship (WRC)^[a] and European Rally Championship (ERC). Additional championship points are available to the fastest five crews through the stage regardless of where they actually finished in the rally.^[2] Unlike normal special stages, which are timed to a tenth of a second, the timing of the Power Stage is to a thousandth of a second.^[3]

Points scoring systems

The bonus scoring system was once used at the 1999 Tour de Corse and 1999 Rally Finland.^[4]^[5] Re-introduced in 2011, the top three crews through the stage could score extra bonus points, with the fastest crew receiving three points, the second-fastest receiving two points, and the third-fastest receiving one point.^[5] In 2017, the scoring system was amended so the five fastest drivers through the stage were awarded points from five for first to one for fifth.^[6] Manufacturers, WRC-2 and WRC-3 categories were also eligible to score Power Stage points in 2021. From 2022, WRC-2 awarded Power Stage points from three for first place, to one for third place. However, it was axed from 2024 onwards.^[7] Power Stage points are no longer awarded in WRC-3.

Power Stages were also introduced during the 2022 European Rally Championship, using the final stage of each rally and awarding points to the five fastest crews in a similar fashion to the WRC.^[8]^[9]

Seasons	Category	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th
1999, 2011–2016	WRC	3	2	1
2017–present	WRC	5	4	3	2	1
2022–2023	WRC-2	3	2	1
2022–present	ERC	5	4	3	2	1

Cancelled Power Stages

This list does not include cancelled rallies.

No.	Rally	Stage name	Reason	Ref
1.	2013 Monte Carlo Rally	Lantosque – Lucéram 2	Increase in local traffic due to bad weather.	^[10]
2.	2020 Rally Mexico	El Brinco	The rally ended prematurely in response to increased travel restrictions stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic.	^[11]

WRC Winners

Key
Bold	Drivers or co-drivers active in the World Rally Championship
	World Rally Championship Drivers' or Co-Drivers' champions

By drivers

No.	Driver	Active years	Wins	First win	Last win
1.	Sébastien Ogier	2008–present	44	2011 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Chile
2.	Thierry Neuville	2009–2010, 2012–present	26	2013 Rally Finland	2024 Rally Poland
3.	Ott Tänak	2009–2012, 2014–present	22	2012 Rallye de France	2024 Rally Latvia
4.	Kalle Rovanperä	2017–present	18	2020 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Sweden
5.	Jari-Matti Latvala	2002–2020, 2023	15	2011 Rallye de France	2018 Wales Rally GB
6.	Sébastien Loeb	1999–2013, 2015, 2018–2020, 2022	7	2011 Rally de Portugal	2012 Rallye Deutschland
7.	Kris Meeke	2002–2008, 2011, 2013–2019	6	2011 Rally Catalunya	2019 Tour de Corse
8.	Mikko Hirvonen	2002–2014	5	2011 Rally México	2012 Wales Rally GB
8.	Dani Sordo	2003–present	5	2012 Rally de Portugal	2021 Rally Catalunya
8.	Esapekka Lappi	2011–2013, 2015–present	5	2017 Rally Italia Sardegna	2023 Rally Sweden
11.	Petter Solberg	1998–2012, 2018–2019	4	2011 Rally Argentina	2012 Rally Italia Sardegna
11.	Elfyn Evans	2007, 2011, 2013–present	4	2014 Rallye Deutschland	2023 Central European Rally
13.	Andreas Mikkelsen	2006–present	3	2014 Rally Italia Sardegna	2019 Rally Italia Sardegna
13.	Takamoto Katsuta	2016–present	3	2020 Rally Monza	2024 Central European Rally
15.	Didier Auriol	1984–2003, 2005	2	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Rally Finland
15.	Adrien Fourmaux	2009–present	2	2024 Croatia Rally	2024 Acropolis Rally
17.	Mads Østberg	2006–2021	1	2014 Rally Sweden	2014 Rally Sweden
17.	Hayden Paddon	2007–2019, 2022	1	2016 Rally Argentina	2016 Rally Argentina
17.	Craig Breen	2009–2012, 2014–2023	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan
Notes:^[b]

By co-drivers

No.	Co-Driver	Active years	Wins	First win	Last win
1.	Julien Ingrassia	2008–2021	41	2011 Rally Sweden	2021 Croatia Rally
2.	Martin Järveoja	2010–present	20	2017 Rally de Portugal	2024 Rally Latvia
3.	Jonne Halttunen	2011–2014, 2017–present	18	2020 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Sweden
4.	Miikka Anttila	1999–2020	15	2011 Rallye de France	2018 Wales Rally GB
4.	Nicolas Gilsoul	2007–2008, 2012–2020, 2023	15	2013 Rally Finland	2020 Rally Turkey
6.	Martijn Wydaeghe	2013–2019, 2021–present	11	2021 Rally Italia Sardegna	2024 Rally Poland
7.	Daniel Elena	1998–2013, 2015, 2018–2020	7	2011 Rally de Portugal	2012 Rallye Deutschland
8.	Jarmo Lehtinen	1997–2014, 2018–2020	5	2011 Rally México	2012 Wales Rally GB
8.	Janne Ferm	2011–2013, 2015–present	5	2017 Rally Italia Sardegna	2023 Rally Sweden
10.	/ Chris Patterson	1993, 1997–2018, 2021	4	2011 Rally Argentina	2012 Rally Italia Sardegna
10.	Paul Nagle	2004, 2006–2008, 2011–2022	4	2011 Rally Catalunya	2018 Monte Carlo Rally
12.	Scott Martin	2004–present	3	2021 Rally Finland	2023 Central European Rally
13.	Denis Giraudet	1981–1984, 1989, 1991–1993, 1995–2017, 2019	2	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Rally Finland
13.	Carlos del Barrio	1991–1992, 1994–2000, 2002, 2004–2007, 2010–2014, 2018–2022	2	2012 Rally de Portugal	2013 Rallye de France-Alsace
13.	Ola Fløene	1995, 2000–2019, 2021	2	2014 Rally Italia Sardegna	2015 Rally Catalunya
13.	Marc Martí	1992–1993, 1995–2010, 2012, 2014–2022	2	2017 Rallye Deutschland	2017 Rally Catalunya
13.	Sebastian Marshall	2008, 2010–2019, 2021	2	2019 Monte Carlo Rally	2019 Tour de Corse
13.	Daniel Barritt	2000, 2002–2021	2	2014 Rallye Deutschland	2020 Rally Monza
13.	Jonas Andersson	2002–present	2	2014 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Finland
13.	Alexandre Coria	2016, 2019, 2021–present	2	2024 Croatia Rally	2024 Acropolis Rally
13.	Vincent Landais	2012–present	2	2023 Rally Mexico	2024 Rally Chile
13.	Aaron Johnston	2019–present	2	2024 Rally Finland	2024 Central European Rally
23.	Kuldar Sikk	2003–2015, 2017–2020	1	2012 Rallye de France	2012 Rallye de France
23.	John Kennard	1985, 1987–1989, 1991, 1998, 2007–2017, 2019, 2022	1	2016 Rally Argentina	2016 Rally Argentina
23.	Raigo Mõlder	2009, 2014–2016, 2020	1	2016 Wales Rally GB	2016 Wales Rally GB
23.	Anders Jæger-Amland	2014–2020	1	2019 Rally Italia Sardegna	2019 Rally Italia Sardegna
23.	Cándido Carrera	2010–2016, 2018–2019, 2021–present	1	2021 Rally Catalunya	2021 Rally Catalunya
23.	Benjamin Veillas	1999, 2008, 2015–2019, 2021–present	1	2022 Rally Catalunya	2022 Rally Catalunya
23.	James Fulton	2020–present	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan
Notes:^[b]

Most wins per season

Key
Bold	Won the World Championship in the same year

Year	Driver(s)	Wins	Races
1999	Didier Auriol	2	2^[c]
2011	Sébastien Ogier	4	13
2012	Sébastien Loeb	4	13
2013	Sébastien Ogier	7	12^[d]
2014	Sébastien Ogier	6	13
2015	Sébastien Ogier	9	13
2016	Sébastien Ogier	7	13
2017	Thierry Neuville	4	13
2018	Thierry Neuville Ott Tänak Esapekka Lappi	3	13
2019	Ott Tänak	6	13
2020	Thierry Neuville Kalle Rovanperä	2	6^[e]
2021	Ott Tänak	4	12
2022	Kalle Rovanperä	7	13
2023	Kalle Rovanperä	6	13

WRC Point scorers

Key
Bold	Drivers or co-drivers active in the World Rally Championship
	World Rally Championship Drivers' or Co-Drivers' champions

By drivers

No.	Driver	Active years	Times	First score	Last score	Points
1.	Sébastien Ogier	2008–present	113	2011 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Chile	324
2.	Thierry Neuville	2009–2010, 2012–present	91	2012 Rallye de France	2024 Rally Chile	290
3.	Ott Tänak	2009–2012, 2014–present	73	2012 Rally de Portugal	2024 Rally Chile	250
4.	Jari-Matti Latvala	2002-2020, 2023–present	72	2011 Rally Sweden	2023 Rally Finland	154
5.	Kalle Rovanperä	2017–present	36	2020 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Chile	150
6.	Elfyn Evans	2007, 2011, 2013–present	53	2014 Rallye Deutschland	2024 Rally Chile	145
7.	Esapekka Lappi	2011–2013, 2015–present	26	2017 Rally de Portugal	2024 Rally Finland	78
8.	Dani Sordo	2003–present	36	2011 Rallye de France	2023 Acropolis Rally	75
9.	Sébastien Loeb	1999–2013, 2015, 2018–2020, 2022	27	2011 Rally Sweden	2022 Safari Rally	57
9.	Andreas Mikkelsen	2006–present	28	2012 Rallye Deutschland	2022 Rally Estonia	57
11.	Kris Meeke	2002–2008, 2011, 2013–2019	23	2011 Rally Catalunya	2019 Rallye Deutschland	55
12.	Takamoto Katsuta	2016–present	23	2020 Rally Monza	2024 Acropolis Rally	45
13.	Mikko Hirvonen	2002–2014	17	2011 Rally Mexico	2014 Rallye Deutschland	43
14.	Craig Breen	2009–2012, 2014–2023	14	2017 Tour de Corse	2023 Rally Sweden	32
15.	Mads Østberg	2006–2021	12	2012 Rally México	2023 Rally Italia Sardegna	25
16.	Teemu Suninen	2014–present	9	2018 Rally de Portugal	2023 Rally Finland	22
17.	Petter Solberg	1998–2012, 2018–2019	10	2011 Rally México	2012 Rally Italia Sardegna	21
18.	Adrien Fourmaux	2022–present	6	2022 Safari Rally	2024 Acropolis Rally	17
19.	Hayden Paddon	2007–2019, 2022–present	4	2016 Rally Mexico	2017 Rally Sweden	7
20.	Didier Auriol	1984–2003, 2005	2	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Rally Finland	6
20.	Juho Hänninen	2006–2011, 2013–2015, 2017, 2023-present	4	2017 Monte Carlo Rally	2013 Rally Finland	6
20.	Evgeny Novikov	2007–2009, 2011–2013	4	2012 Monte Carlo Rally	2013 Wales Rally GB	6
20.	Stéphane Lefebvre	2013–present	2	2017 Monte Carlo Rally	2017 Rally Poland	6
24.	Tommi Mäkinen	1987–2003	2	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Rally Finland	4
24.	Gus Greensmith	2022–present	2	2022 Safari Rally	2022 Acropolis Rally	4
24.	Mauro Miele	2018–present	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan	4
27.	Robert Kubica	2013–2016	2	2015 Tour de Corse	2015 Wales Rally GB	3
28.	Kevin Abbring	2007–2012, 2014–2018, 2020–2021	1	2016 Rally Italia Sardegna	2016 Rally Italia Sardegna	2
28.	Oliver Solberg	2019–present	1	2022 Rally New Zealand	2022 Rally New Zealand	2
29.	Carlos Sainz	1987–2005	1	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Tour de Corse	1
29.	Toni Gardemeister	1996–2008, 2010	1	1999 Rally Finland	1999 Rally Finland	1
29.	Nasser Al-Attiyah	2004–2015	1	2012 Rally Argentina	2012 Rally Argentina	1
29.	Emil Lindholm	2022–present	1	2022 Croatia Rally	2022 Croatia Rally	1
29.	Fabrizio Zaldivar	2019–present	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan	1
Notes:^[b]

By co-drivers

No.	Co-Driver	Active years	Times	First score	Last score	Points
1.	Julien Ingrassia	2008–2021	96	2011 Rally Sweden	2021 Rally Monza	276
2.	Martin Järveoja	2010–present	69	2017 Rally Mexico	2024 Rally Chile	241
3.	Nicolas Gilsoul	2007–2008, 2012–2020, 2023	53	2012 Rallye de France	2020 Rally Italia Sardegna	159
4.	Miikka Anttila	1999–2020	71	2011 Rally Sweden	2019 Rally Turkey	153
5.	Jonne Halttunen	2011–2014, 2017–present	36	2020 Rally Sweden	2024 Rally Chile	150
6.	Martijn Wydaeghe	2013–2019, 2021–present	37	2021 Monte Carlo Rally	2024 Rally Chile	131
7.	Scott Martin	2004–present	46	2017 Tour de Corse	2024 Rally Chile	127
8.	Janne Ferm	2011–2013, 2015–present	26	2017 Rally de Portugal	2024 Rally Finland	78
9.	Paul Nagle	2004, 2006–2008, 2011–2022	25	2011 Rally Catalunya	2022 Acropolis Rally	57
10.	Jarmo Lehtinen	1997–2014, 2018–2020	20	2011 Rally Mexico	2020 Monte Carlo Rally	51
10.	Daniel Elena	1998–2013, 2015, 2018–2020	24	2011 Rally Sweden	2020 Rally Turkey	51
12.	Aaron Johnston	2019–present	22	2021 Rally Finland	2024 Acropolis Rally	43
13.	Vincent Landais	2012–present	13	2023 Monte Carlo Rally	2024 Rally Chile	36
14.	Anders Jæger-Amland	2014–2020	15	2016 Monte Carlo Rally	2019 Rally Finland	35
15.	Daniel Barritt	2000, 2002–2021	12	2014 Rallye Deutschland	2020 Rally Monza	30
15.	Carlos del Barrio	1991–1992, 1994–2000, 2002, 2004–2007, 2010–2014, 2018–present	15	2011 Rallye de France	2021 Monte Carlo Rally	30
17.	Marc Martí	1992–1993, 1995–2010, 2012, 2014–present	12	2015 Rally Argentina	2017 Rally Catalunya	27
18.	/ Chris Patterson	1993, 1997–2018, 2021	10	2011 Rally México	2012 Rally Italia Sardegna	21
19.	Sebastian Marshall	2008, 2010–2019, 2021	6	2016 Rally Italia Sardegna	2019 Rallye Deutschland	19
20.	Ola Fløene	1995, 2000–2019, 2021	10	2014 Rally Italia Sardegna	2015 Wales Rally GB	17
20.	Alexandre Coria	2022–present	6	2022 Safari Rally	2024 Acropolis Rally	17
22.	Jonas Andersson	2002–present	14	2012 Rally México	2022 Acropolis Rally	16
22.	Cándido Carrera	2010–2016, 2018–2019, 2021–present	6	2021 Rally Catalunya	2023 Acropolis Rally	16
24.	Benjamin Veillas	1999, 2008, 2015–2019, 2021–present	4	2022 Croatia Rally	2022 Rally Catalunya	12
25.	Torstein Eriksen	2011–2012, 2015, 2017–present	3	2018 Rally Finland	2022 Rally Estonia	10
26.	Mikko Markkula	2001–2019, 2021–present	3	2018 Rally de Portugal	2023 Rally Finland	8
27.	Denis Giraudet	1981–1984, 1989, 1991–1993, 1995–2017, 2019	3	1999 Tour de Corse	2012 Monte Carlo Rally	7
27.	John Kennard	1985, 1987–1989, 1991, 1998, 2007–2017, 2019, 2022–present	4	2016 Rally Mexico	2017 Rally Sweden	7
29.	Gabin Moreau	2013–2018	2	2017 Monte Carlo Rally	2017 Rally Poland	6
29.	Marko Salminen	2008, 2011–2021	3	2019 Monte Carlo Rally	2019 Rally de Portugal	6
29.	Isabelle Galmiche	2007, 2013, 2017, 2022–present	2	2022 Monte Carlo Rally	2022 Safari Rally	6
29.	James Fulton	2020–present	2	2022 Rally Japan	2023 Rally Sweden	6
33.	Ilka Minor	1997–2007, 2010–2016, 2018–present	3	2013 Acropolis Rally	2013 Wales Rally GB	5
33.	Raigo Mõlder	2009, 2014–2016, 2020	2	2015 Rally Poland	2016 Wales Rally GB	5
33.	Kaj Lindström	1996–2006, 2009–2015, 2017, 2019	3	2017 Monte Carlo Rally	2017 Rally Catalunya	5
36.	Risto Mannisenmäki	1982, 1986–1990, 1992–2001, 2003	2	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Rally Finland	4
36.	Kuldar Sikk	2003–2015, 2017–2020	2	2012 Rally de Portugal	2012 Rallye de France	4
36.	Luca Beltrame	2007, 2017–present	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan	4
39.	Maciej Szczepaniak	1999–2000, 2002–2003, 2006–present	2	2015 Tour de Corse	2015 Wales Rally GB	3
40.	Borja Rozada	2007, 2009–2018, 2020–present	2	2021 Rally Italia Sardegna	2021 Safari Rally	2
40.	Elliott Edmondson	2013, 2015–present	1	2022 Rally New Zealand	2022 Rally New Zealand	2
42.	Luis Moya	1988–2002	1	1999 Tour de Corse	1999 Tour de Corse	1
42.	Paavo Lukander	1996–2004	1	1999 Rally Finland	1999 Rally Finland	1
42.	Giovanni Bernacchini	1998–2017, 2020	1	2012 Rally Argentina	2012 Rally Argentina	1
42.	Reeta Hämäläinen	2022–present	1	2022 Croatia Rally	2022 Croatia Rally	1
42.	Marcelo Der Ohannesian	2011, 2015, 2018–present	1	2022 Rally Japan	2022 Rally Japan	1
Notes:^[b]

Most points per season

Key
Bold	Won the World Championship in the same year

Year	Driver(s)	Points	Races
1999	Didier Auriol	6	2^[c]
2011	Sébastien Loeb	19	13
2012	Sébastien Loeb	19	13
2013	Sébastien Ogier	28	12^[d]
2014	Jari-Matti Latvala	25	13
2015	Sébastien Ogier	27	13
2016	Sébastien Ogier	26	13
2017	Sébastien Ogier Thierry Neuville	34	13
2018	Sébastien Ogier	37	13
2019	Sébastien Ogier	41	13
2020	Ott Tänak Thierry Neuville	18	6^[e]
2021	Thierry Neuville	35	12
2022	Kalle Rovanperä	50	13
2023	Kalle Rovanperä	43	13

Gallery

The Col de Braus mountain pass, which was contested as the power stage of Monte Carlo Rally.
Kris Meeke and Paul Nagle driving a Citroën DS3 WRC at Vargåsen, which was the power stage of 2014 Rally Sweden.
Sébastien Ogier and Julien Ingrassia driving a Volkswagen Polo R WRC at Colin's Crest Arena during 2014 Rally Sweden.
Hyundai's Andreas Mikkelsen and Anders Jæger-Synnevaag on the Col de Braus mountain pass in 2018.
The Ford Fiesta WRC of Elfyn Evans and Daniel Barritt jumping at the Rally de Portugal's iconic Fafe stage.
The Hyundai i20 Coupe WRC of Hayden Paddon and Sebastian Marshall during the power stage of 2018 Rally Italia Sardegna.
2018 Rally Finland winning crew Ott Tänak and Martin Järveoja driving through the power stage in a Toyota Yaris WRC.

Notes

^ 2018 Wales Rally GB used fourth to last stage as the power stage.^[1]
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Statistics updated as of the Central European Rally.
^ ^a ^b 1999 consisted of 14 rallies, but Power Stage was only run on two.
^ ^a ^b 2013 consisted of 13 rallies, but Power Stage was cancelled in Monte Carlo.
^ ^a ^b 2020 consisted of seven rallies, but Power Stage was cancelled in Mexico.

References

^ "2018 Dayinsure Wales Rally GB" (PDF). walesrallygb.com. Wales Rally GB. 14 August 2018. Archived from the original (PDF) on 24 October 2018. Retrieved 19 August 2018.
^ "World Motor Sport Council: 08 September 2010". fia.com. Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile. 8 September 2010. Archived from the original on 11 September 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2010.
^ "Regulations". fia.com. Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile. Retrieved 16 December 2018.
^ "Season 1999". e-wrc.com. Retrieved 3 November 2019.
^ ^a ^b Beer, Matt (8 September 2010). "WRC adds bonus points for TV stages". autosport.com. Haymarket Publications. Archived from the original on 11 September 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2010.
^ "2017 WRC dates confirmed". wrc.com. WRC Promoter GmbH. 28 September 2016. Retrieved 29 September 2016.
^ Barry, Luke (14 November 2023). "WRC2 Powerstage axed for 2024". dirtfish.com. DirtFish. Retrieved 14 November 2023.
^ "What is ERC". ERC – European Rally Championship. Retrieved 19 March 2023.
^ "ERC 2022: What has changed?". Azoresrallye. Retrieved 19 March 2023.
^ Evans, David (19 January 2013). "Monte Carlo Rally: Loeb wins as final stages cancelled". Autosport.com. Haymarket Publications. Archived from the original on 21 January 2013. Retrieved 19 January 2013.
^ Ramirez, Luis (14 March 2020). "WRC Rally Mexico to end early as more travel restrictions loom". autosport.com. Motorsport Network. Retrieved 15 March 2020.

External links

[2] 2018 Wales Rally GB used fourth to last stage as the power stage.^[1]

[update-13] Statistics updated as of the Central European Rally.

[ninetynine-14] 1999 consisted of 14 rallies, but Power Stage was only run on two.

[thirteen-15] 2013 consisted of 13 rallies, but Power Stage was cancelled in Monte Carlo.

[twenty-16] 2020 consisted of seven rallies, but Power Stage was cancelled in Mexico.

[1] "2018 Dayinsure Wales Rally GB" (PDF). walesrallygb.com. Wales Rally GB. 14 August 2018. Archived from the original (PDF) on 24 October 2018. Retrieved 19 August 2018.

[3] "World Motor Sport Council: 08 September 2010". fia.com. Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile. 8 September 2010. Archived from the original on 11 September 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2010.

[4] "Regulations". fia.com. Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile. Retrieved 16 December 2018.

[5] "Season 1999". e-wrc.com. Retrieved 3 November 2019.

[auto-6] Beer, Matt (8 September 2010). "WRC adds bonus points for TV stages". autosport.com. Haymarket Publications. Archived from the original on 11 September 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2010.

[7] "2017 WRC dates confirmed". wrc.com. WRC Promoter GmbH. 28 September 2016. Retrieved 29 September 2016.

[8] Barry, Luke (14 November 2023). "WRC2 Powerstage axed for 2024". dirtfish.com. DirtFish. Retrieved 14 November 2023.

[9] "What is ERC". ERC – European Rally Championship. Retrieved 19 March 2023.

[10] "ERC 2022: What has changed?". Azoresrallye. Retrieved 19 March 2023.

[11] Evans, David (19 January 2013). "Monte Carlo Rally: Loeb wins as final stages cancelled". Autosport.com. Haymarket Publications. Archived from the original on 21 January 2013. Retrieved 19 January 2013.

[12] Ramirez, Luis (14 March 2020). "WRC Rally Mexico to end early as more travel restrictions loom". autosport.com. Motorsport Network. Retrieved 15 March 2020.

[a]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[b]

[c]

[d]

[e]

[1]