Jump to content

James Fitzjames

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is the current revision of this page, as edited by Smasongarrison (talk | contribs) at 18:05, 17 November 2024 (Moving from Category:Explorers of the Arctic to Category:British explorers of the Arctic Diffusing per WP:DIFFUSE and/or WP:ALLINCLUDED using Cat-a-lot). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this version.

(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
For other people with similar names, see James FitzJames (disambiguation).

James Fitzjames
Fitzjames in 1845
Born(1813-07-27)27 July 1813
London, England
Diedc. May-June 1848 (aged 34)
King William Island, North-Western Territory (now Nunavut, Canada)
Branch Royal Navy
Service years1825–1848
RankCaptain (Royal Navy)
  • Wars
  •  
  • Expeditions

James Fitzjames (27 July 1813 –  c. May 1848) was a British Royal Navy officer and explorer.

The illegitimate son of a man with ties to the Navy, Fitzjames distinguished himself in an ill-conceived expedition to establish a steamship line in Mesopotamia in the 1830s, and in combat during the Egyptian–Ottoman War and the First Opium War. In 1845, Fitzjames was tapped by Sir John Barrow as a potential leader of an expedition to the Northwest Passage, but was instead named as captain of HMS Erebus under Sir John Franklin.

Franklin's lost expedition became trapped in the Arctic ice off King William Island in 1846. Following Franklin's death the next year, Fitzjames became second-in-command to Captain Francis Crozier of HMS Terror. The ships were abandoned in April 1848 and the survivors set out for the Canadian mainland. Fitzjames and twelve others died in the vicinity of Erebus Bay, 80 kilometres (50 mi) from where they abandoned the ships. His remains were rediscovered in 1993 and forensically identified in September 2024.

Early life

[edit]

Family and birth

[edit]

James Fitzjames was born the illegitimate son of Sir James Gambier on 27 July 1813.[1] He was baptised on 24 February 1815 at St Marylebone Parish Church in London, but his parents were listed as "James Fitzjames" and "Ann Fitzjames."[2] As of 2024, his mother's identity remains unknown.[1]

As an illegitimate child, his friends and relatives took great pains to conceal his origins, both during his life and after. Though biographer William Battersby initially believed Fitzjames was born in Rio de Janeiro in what was then Colonial Brazil,[3] he later issued a correction on his website stating Fitzjames was more likely born in London, England, as Fitzjames stated on his naval entry papers.[2]

The identification of his true family had been unknown until Battersby's publication in 2010.[4] In different sources it had been suggested that he was a foundling;[5] that he was of Irish extraction, an illegitimate son of Sir James Stephen, or a relative of the Coninghams.

Although not always successful, the Gambier family were prominent in the Royal Naval service. Sir James's cousin was a controversial sea lord Admiral Lord Gambier. His father, and James Fitzjames' grandfather, was Vice Admiral James Gambier.

Sir James Gambier had married Jemima Snell in 1797 and the couple had 12 children altogether. At the time of Fitzjames' birth, Sir James was in grave financial difficulties. He had been appointed British Consul-General in Rio de Janeiro in 1809 and held this office until 1814. However the Gambiers returned to England in 1811 on account of Lady Gambier's health, never to return to Brazil.[6] Cut off from the revenues he expected to receive in Rio, Sir James ran up enormous debts, only saved from bankruptcy when a syndicate of his relatives and creditors, led by Admiral Lord Gambier himself, William Morton Pitt and Samuel Gambier, took over his financial affairs and placed them in trust.[citation needed] In 1815, with his financial affairs in the hands of trustees, Sir James resumed a diplomatic career by being appointed Consul-General to the Netherlands at The Hague, a position he held until 1825.

Adoptive family

[edit]

Presumably shortly after his birth, Fitzjames was given into the care of the Reverend Robert Coningham and his wife Louisa Capper, who wrote philosophical and poetical works. The Coninghams were well-off members of an extended family of Scots/Irish ancestry.

The Coningham family lived at Watford and Abbots Langley in Hertfordshire, and also at Blackheath. In 1832 they acquired a substantial 30 acre country estate called Rose Hill in Abbots Langley. Robert and Louisa had one son, William Coningham, who was James Fitzjames' closest friend; the two boys were brought up together as brothers.[7] The Coninghams were a well-educated couple who had extensive connections in British intellectual circles of the time. Robert Coningham was a Cambridge-educated clergyman although he never took a living. His nephew was the author John Sterling, a friend of such intellectuals as Julius Hare and Thomas Carlyle. Before she married, Louisa Coningham had taught at the Rothsay House girls' school in Kennington and was the author of two books.[8]

This intellectual background enabled them to provide Fitzjames and William Coningham with an exceptionally high level of education. William Coningham was briefly sent to Eton College while Fitzjames was away at sea serving on HMS Pyramus. On Fitzjames' return to the Coningham household, William Coningham was withdrawn from Eton and the boys' education was provided at home by private tutors, including a son of Robert Towerson Cory, who later tutored the Prince of Wales for Queen Victoria and Prince Albert.[9] Fitzjames was brought up by the Coningham family as a son, and he always referred to them as 'uncle' and 'aunt'.

[edit]

Under captains Gambier and Sartorius

[edit]

Fitzjames entered the Royal Navy at the age of 12 in July 1825 as a volunteer of the second class on HMS Pyramus, a frigate under the command of captain Robert Gambier.[10] He served on Pyramus until 15 September 1828, being promoted to volunteer of the first class on 1 July 1828. Captain Robert Gambier was James Fitzjames' second cousin, and it was through this covert family connection that he obtained this position. This captain resigned his position a year later due to the unexpected death of his wife, leaving Fitzjames vulnerable as he had no connection with the new captain, George Sartorius.[citation needed]

Fitzjames won the confidence of Captain Sartorius, who promoted him to Volunteer of the First Class in 1828. During this commission Pyramus first sailed to Central America and the United States on diplomatic missions and was then involved in scientific research as part of the Experimental Squadron under Admiral Sir Thomas Hardy. Later, the Pyramus served as British guardship at Lisbon.[citation needed]

After this Fitzjames was determined to resume his Royal Naval career and eventually took the position of Midshipman on HMS St Vincent from 1830 to 1833.[10] St Vincent was the flagship of the Royal Navy's Mediterranean Fleet but spent much time in port at Malta.[citation needed]

Fitzjames served detached duty on a cutter, HMS Hind, sailing twice to Constantinople, and on HMS Madagascar, during which time Madagascar conveyed Otto of Greece from Trieste to Nauplia, where Otto was crowned King of Greece. During this time Fitzjames passed his exams for promotion to lieutenant.[10] Returning to Britain on St Vincent in 1833, he almost immediately obtained a position on HMS Winchester, Vice Admiral Hyde Parker's flagship.[11]

Euphrates Expedition

[edit]

Robert Coningham was very close to a relative of his, Major Colin Campbell, who after Fitzjames' death became famous as Field Marshal Lord Clyde. Campbell introduced Fitzjames to Francis Rawdon Chesney, then a captain of the engineers, who was putting together an expedition to establish a steamship line in Mesopotamia.[citation needed]

The venture became known as the Euphrates Expedition, and served as a precursor to the creation of the Suez Canal as it linked the Near East across Mesopotamia to the river systems that flowed into the Persian Gulf. Rather impulsively, Fitzjames immediately resigned his position on HMS Winchester to join Chesney's expedition.[12]

Fitzjames served on the Euphrates Expedition from 1834 to 1837.[13] Before the expedition had even sailed, he distinguished himself by diving into the River Mersey fully clothed to rescue a drowning man. He was awarded a silver cup and the Freedom of the City of Liverpool for this feat of bravery.[citation needed]

Although the expedition was promoted with great energy, it was not a success. The two steamers, Tigris and Euphrates, had to be transported in pieces 130 miles (210 km) across the mountains and desert terrain of northern Syria from the Mediterranean coast to the river Euphrates, a tremendous effort which took over a year long to complete. The smaller steamer, Tigris, sank with heavy loss of life in a sudden storm and the draught of Euphrates, the surviving vessel was too deep to sail on the river for much of the year. In addition there were tremendous difficulties caused both by political complications and the outbreak of disease.[13]

While Chesney was determined to continue, he would not release officers, including Fitzjames, the expedition was eventually halted by the British government and East India Company, its two major sponsors. In 1836, with the steamer Euphrates unable to sail up the shallows of the river, having broken its engine, Fitzjames volunteered to take the India Office mails she was carrying 1,200 miles (1,900 km) across what is now Iraq and Syria to the Mediterranean coast and from there convey them to London.[citation needed]

Resumption of naval career

[edit]

After many extremely dangerous adventures (he was nearly kidnapped and trapped in a besieged town) Fitzjames succeeded in returning to London.[13] Here he was reunited with the surviving members of the expedition as they straggled back home. While he was away, Robert Coningham died suddenly, on 21 May 1836.[citation needed]

On the expedition, Fitzjames formed a close friendship with one of the other Royal Navy officers participating, Edward Charlewood. Charlewood and Fitzjames found that contrary to the understanding of Colonel Chesney, the Admiralty refused to credit their service on the Euphrates Expedition as 'sea-time', and it therefore would not count toward their promotion. Chesney did everything in his power to support his subordinates, and after nearly a year the Admiralty relented and granted the officers their promotions.[citation needed]

Fitzjames resumed Royal Naval service and followed a much more conventional career path. Together with Charlewood, he next served on HMS Excellent, the recently established gunnery school, where he passed out with very high marks. At this time he also formed a close, albeit also professionally extremely useful, friendship with John Barrow, the son of Sir John Barrow, a highly influential Second Secretary to the Admiralty. From this point on the two men corresponded regularly.[14]

Egyptian–Ottoman War

[edit]

A highly qualified gunnery lieutenant, James Fitzjames was in demand: together with his experience of the Middle East, this won him the position of gunnery lieutenant on HMS Ganges in the Egyptian–Ottoman War of 1839 to 1840. He was regarded as an effective officer and was especially commended by Admiral Sir Charles Napier for landing at night to distribute a proclamation to Egyptian soldiers at their camp. It was a risky enterprise, but he escaped back to Ganges.[citation needed]

When informed of this daring exploit Ibrahim Pasha, the Egyptian general, put a price on Fitzjames' head.[15] Before service was completed, James Fitzjames was selected by Admiral Sir William Parker as gunnery lieutenant on HMS Cornwallis, his flagship for the force being assembled in Britain to fight the First Opium War.[16]

First Opium War

[edit]

His service in this war was again marked by notably reckless bravery, he was almost killed during the capture of Zhenjiang; he was evacuated to Cornwallis when a musket ball passed through his arm into his back, lodging against his spine. Senior officers took further notice of an extrovert; Fitzjames wrote and published a 10,000-word humorous poem, The Cruise of HMS Cornwallis, describing the First Opium War and his part in that particular uprising, which was published in The Nautical Magazine. Ostensibly anonymous, he referred to himself under the byline "Tom Bowline".[17]

En route to war, HMS Cornwallis spent five days at Singapore. While there on shore leave, Fitzjames had some sort of encounter with Sir George Barrow, the eldest surviving son of Sir John Barrow. It was William Battersby's theory that Barrow was clearly in a highly compromised situation, and Fitzjames appeared to have paid someone off and thereby covered up whatever scandal would otherwise have broken over the Barrow family. Battersby believed that thenceforward Sir John Barrow blatantly favoured Fitzjames, promoting his candidacy at any available opportunity; the first fruits were accelerated promotion to commander and appointment to command HMS Clio.[18] Joining the Clio in Bombay, the new captain cruised the Persian Gulf and carried out various diplomatic duties before returning to Portsmouth in October 1844.[19]

Franklin's lost expedition

[edit]

Returning to England, Fitzjames lived with William Coningham, his wife Elizabeth (née Meyrick) and their two young children at their home in Brighton. He was on half-pay, meaning he was available for naval service but not presently working on a ship.[20]

Sir John Barrow, a prime mover of what became the Franklin expedition, campaigned to have Fitzjames appointed to lead it. He asked for his friend Edward Charlewood to be appointed as second in command. Barrow was unable to provide the Board of the Admiralty with a persuasive argument to support these appointments, and Fitzjames was discounted due to his relatively young age, so after some prevarication Sir John Franklin and Francis Crozier were appointed instead.[21]

Fitzjames was appointed to serve under Franklin as the Captain of HMS Erebus.[21] Once appointed to the Franklin Expedition, Fitzjames was given the responsibility of recruitment of expedition personnel.[20] He selected many persons he was familiar with, including George Henry Hodgson.[22]

The ships sailed from Greenhithe on 19 May 1845. One of the ports they stopped at on the way north was Stromness, Orkney. Fitzjames gave permission to two Orcadian sailors — Captain of the Foretop Robert Sinclair and Able Seaman Thomas Work — to row ashore and visit their families in Kirkwall.[23] Fitzjames wrote daily letters, which he had sent home when the ships came into port in Disko Bay, Greenland.[24]

The ship were last seen by Europeans at the end of July 1845, when two whalers sighted them in northern Baffin Bay. The Admiralty promoted Fitzjames to the rank of Captain on 31 December 1845, but he was in the Arctic at the time and never learned of it.[25]

Captaincy and death

[edit]

After the death of Sir John Franklin on 11 June 1847, Captain Francis Crozier of HMS Terror became the expedition leader. Fitzjames became second in command of the expedition, as well as command of Erebus.[1] Fitzjames wrote an addendum to the 'Victory Point note' explaining their circumstances. Crozier indicated after Fitzjames that they were headed for Back's Fish River.[26]

Fitzjames died on King William Island, in the vicinity of Erebus Bay, likely in May or June 1848, alongside Erebus engineer John Gregory and at least eleven other sailors from the expedition, only eighty kilometres south of Victory Point.[1] Fitzjames's remains were subjected to cannibalism by survivors.[1] Because John Franklin and Lieutenant Graham Gore had already died, upon Fitzjames's death, command of the Erebus would have passed to H. T. D. Le Vesconte, assuming he was still alive.[1]

The "Victory Point" note.

Discovery and identification of remains

[edit]

The site of Fitzjames's death in Erebus Bay also contained a ship's boat. The boat and the human remains were first found by Inuit in 1861, and they reported that cannibalism had taken place there.[1]

The site was rediscovered by Anne Keenleyside in 1993. The site is known to archaeologists as NgLj-2, and contained more than 400 bones belonging to 13 different members of the expedition, including Fitzjames.[27][28]

In September 2024, researchers Douglas Stenton, Stephen Fratpietro, and Robert W. Park, from the University of Waterloo and Lakehead University, announced that they had positively identified a skeletal mandible as belonging to Fitzjames through DNA testing. An unbroken Y-chromosome DNA match was made from a living descendant of Fitzjames's great-grandfather James Gambier; the DNA donor, Nigel Gambier, is second cousin five times removed to Fitzjames. By doing genealogical research, historian Fabiënne Tetteroo determined that Nigel Gambier was an eligible match for Fitzjames. Tetteroo contacted Nigel Gambier and he agreed to provide the DNA sample that conclusively identified Fitzjames.[29][30][1] Fitzjames' mandible shows signs of cut marks consistent with cannibalism.[1]

Fitzjames is the highest-ranking member of the expedition to be identified as of 2024, and the second to be positively identified by DNA testing, the first being Erebus engineer John Gregory in 2021.[31] Fitzjames is the first expedition member to be identified as a victim of cannibalism.[1]

Character

[edit]

Fitzjames struggled to find his position in early 19th-century British society. While illegitimacy was not unusual, it caused great difficulties for the children concerned, who were not expected openly to refer to their blood families and could not depend on any support from them. In Fitzjames' case the controversial reputations of his Royal Naval ancestors, and the disreputable behaviour of his father, compounded this. In addition, the underhand way he obtained his promotion to midshipman made his position in the Royal Navy extremely vulnerable leaving his career up until 1838 open to challenge.

While his family position was always vulnerable, he did have several advantages. He was physically fit and strong, being tall and well-built. He was handsome, extremely personable, and very skilled in winning the confidence of his superiors, he possessed charm and charisma. Added to this he was highly intelligent and had been very well educated; an excellent sense of humour rounded off a personality that was the life and soul of any party or other situation. To judge by his surviving letters and drawings, he was a sensitive writer and an excellent artist.

But he was always very conscious of the insecurity of his social position and this may explain the extreme personal and professional recklessness which he displayed throughout his life. Whether jumping into the River Mersey to rescue the drowning man, entering the Egyptian soldiers' camp or leading the assault on the walls of Zhenjiang, the impression left was that he was potentially willing to risk or even honourably sacrifice his life if the opportunity arose in order to demonstrate that he was as good as, or better than, his legitimate contemporaries.

Legacy

[edit]

After the disappearance of the Franklin Expedition, Fitzjames' loss was recorded on various monuments to it, such as one statue at Waterloo Place in London. He was idolised by Sir Clements Markham as the beau ideal of an Arctic officer. Furthermore, he may have inadvertently acted as a model for Captain Robert Falcon Scott.

The only overt tribute to Fitzjames was in a family record 'The Story of the Gambiers', written in 1924 for private circulation by Mrs. Cuthbert Heath, a descendant of Sir James Gambier and published in 1924, in which Mrs. Heath wrote:

At this point mention must be made of a Gambier who bore the 'bar sinister', but is worthy to rank with the most distinguished of the legitimate kinsman. Sir James Gambier, Ambassador to the Brazils, had a natural son, James FitzJames, RN, well known to the Gambier family, who styled him the 'Knight of Snowden'. As Captain of HMS Erebus, he accompanied Sir John Franklin on his disastrous attempt to discover the North West Passage in 1845, and shared his leader's fate. His signature appears on one of the last entries of the great explorer's log-book, and his name stands in the place of honour next to that of Sir John Franklin on the well-known monument in Carlton House Terrace.[32]

[edit]

James Fitzjames appears as a character in the 2007 novel, The Terror by Dan Simmons, a fictionalized account of Franklin's lost expedition, as well as the 2018 television adaptation, where he is portrayed by Tobias Menzies.[33]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Stenton, Douglas R.; Fratpietro, Stephen; Park, Robert W. (24 September 2024). "Identification of a senior officer from Sir John Franklin's Northwest Passage expedition". Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports: 104748. doi:10.1016/j.jasrep.2024.104748. ISSN 2352-409X.
  2. ^ a b "James Fitzjames - Important Correction: Brazil". 6 February 2012. Archived from the original on 6 February 2012. Retrieved 6 December 2021.
  3. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 27.
  4. ^ Battersby 2010, pp. 21–35.
  5. ^ Woodman, David C. (1992), Unravelling the Franklin Mystery: Inuit Testimony, McGill-Queen's University Press. ISBN 0773509364
  6. ^ FO 63/104, The National Archives
  7. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 31.
  8. ^ Perkins, Mary Ann (23 September 2004). "Capper [married name Coningham], Louisa (1776–1840)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/4599. Retrieved 20 January 2019. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  9. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 182.
  10. ^ a b c O'Byrne, William R. (1849). A Naval Biographical Dictionary: Comprising the Life and Services of Every Living Officer in Her Majesty's Navy, from the Rank of Admiral of the Fleet to that of Lieutenant Inclusive. Compiled from Authentic and Family Documents. Vol. 1. London: John Murray. p. 363.
  11. ^ Battersby 2010, pp. 45–46.
  12. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 67.
  13. ^ a b c Guest 1992.
  14. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 196.
  15. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 120.
  16. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 124.
  17. ^ Battersby 2010, pp. 139–140.
  18. ^ Battersby 2010, pp. 138, 164.
  19. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 149.
  20. ^ a b Lloyd-Jones, Ralph (2005). "The Men who Sailed with Franklin". Polar Record. 41 (4): 311–318. Bibcode:2005PoRec..41..311L. doi:10.1017/S0032247405004651. ISSN 0032-2474.
  21. ^ a b Sandler, Martin W. (2006). Resolute: the epic search for the Northwest Passage and John Franklin, and the discovery of the Queen's ghost ship. New York: Sterling Pub. Co. pp. 65–74. ISBN 978-1-4027-4085-5.
  22. ^ Stein, Glenn M. (2007). "Scattered Memories and Frozen Bones: Revealing a Sailor of the Franklin Expedition, 1845-48". Orders and Medals Research Society. 46 (4).
  23. ^ Lloyd-Jones, Ralph (2011). "Further light on Franklin's men". Polar Record. 47 (4): 379–382. Bibcode:2011PoRec..47..379L. doi:10.1017/S0032247411000179. ISSN 0032-2474.
  24. ^ Potter, Russell A.; Koellner, Regina; Carney, Peter; Williamson, Mary, eds. (2022). May We Be Spared to Meet on Earth: Letters of the Lost Franklin Arctic Expedition. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press. ISBN 9780228011392.
  25. ^ Sir John Barrow, 'Voyages of Discovery and Research Within the Arctic Regions, from the Year 1818 to the Present Time', (London: John Murray), 1846, X.
  26. ^ Battersby 2010, p. 187.
  27. ^ Stenton, Douglas R.; Fratpietro, Stephen; Keenleyside, Anne; Park, Robert W. (2021). "DNA identification of a sailor from the 1845 Franklin northwest passage expedition". Polar Record. 57: e14. Bibcode:2021PoRec..57E..14S. doi:10.1017/S0032247421000061. ISSN 0032-2474.
  28. ^ Keenleyside, Anne; Bertulli, Margaret; Fricke, Henry C. (March 1997). "The Final Days of the Franklin Expedition: New Skeletal Evidence". Arctic. 50 (1): 36–46. doi:10.14430/arctic1089.
  29. ^ Potter, Russell (27 September 2024). "Finding Fitzjames: the search for Sir John Franklin's senior officer". Canadian Geographic. Retrieved 27 September 2024.
  30. ^ Weber, Bob (26 September 2024). "Pride, sorrow mix for Franklin expedition descendant after DNA match with Erebus captain". CBC. Retrieved 27 September 2024.
  31. ^ "Another Franklin expedition crew member has been identified". University of Waterloo. 24 September 2024. Retrieved 24 September 2024.
  32. ^ Battersby, William. "About Sir James Gambier". Archived from the original on 13 April 2013. Retrieved 20 April 2021.
  33. ^ Andreeva, Nellie (9 September 2016). "'The Terror': Tobias Menzies Stars In AMC Scott Free Anthology Series". Deadline Hollywood. Retrieved 13 September 2016.

Online

[edit]

jamesfitzjames.com - Website by historian Fabiënne Tetteroo containing new research, primary sources and much more.

Bibliography

[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=James_Fitzjames&oldid=1258012231"