Jump to content

Historical reenactment

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Kriegaffe (talk | contribs) at 15:07, 31 August 2007 (added link to Amphitheatre). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Reenactors of the American Civil War

Historical reenactment is an activity in which participants recreate some aspects of a historical event or period. It may be a narrowly-defined time period, such as a specific war or other event, or it may be more broadly defined.

Activities related to "reenactment" are not new. Tournaments in the Middle Ages had Roman or other earlier themes (while the Romans themselves staged recreations of famous battles within their amphitheaters as a form of public spectacle), and the Victorians recreated medieval furnishings such as tapestries. However, historical reenactment in pursuit of practical historical interest, beyond merely re-inventing history as an entertainment to suit contemporary convenience or sensibilities, seems to be an invention of the 20th century.

The term living history describes attempts to bring history to life, either for an audience or for the participants themselves. The primary distinction between reenactment and a period dramatic performance is the degree of immersion and the amount of improvisation. Historical reenactment can be considered a form of live-action role-playing within a historical context.

Reenactment groups

Main article: Comparison of historical reenactment groups

Most groups and individuals who are dedicated to reenactment are amateurs who pursue reenactment as a hobby. Participants within this hobby are extremely diverse. The ages of participants range from young children whose parents bring them along to events, to the elderly. Among adult participants, people from all different walks of life can be found - college students, firemen, lawyers, members of the armed forces, doctors, and even professional historians.[1]

Period

Reenactment covers a wide temporal span. This is a reenactment of the Roman legion XV Apollinaris, from Austria.

The period of an event is the range of dates . See authenticity (reenactment) for a discussion of how the period affects the types of costume, weapons, and armour used.

Popular periods to reenact include:

The Company of St. George recreating a small medieval military camp in France, 2006.

Clothing and Equipment

Reenactor displaying buckskins

Small cottage industries abound that provide not only the materials but even the finished product for use by re-enactors. Uniforms and clothing made of hand woven, natural dyed materials are hand-sewn (or machine-sewn, as the case might be) using the sartorial techniques of the period portrayed. The same holds true for headgear, footwear, camp gear, accoutrements, military equipment, weapons and so on. These items, which are generally much more expensive than clothing and uniform in modern production, offer the wearer an actual life like experience in the use of these materials, authentic tailoring techniques, and manufacture.

Also, it is hoped that spectators will have a better experience when attending an event in which a high level of authenticity is attained in both individual clothing and equipment, as well as equipment used in camp.

Experimental archaeology

Experimental archaeology is an important part of many authentic living history events, where crafts and techniques are evaluated to see whether they make sense in the appropriate historical setting. For example, various combinations of armour can be tried to see if an item for which no historical evidence exists is actually easy to make with the tools available and practical to use in the battles of the time.

A British school-based Tudor re-enactment group show off their authentic clothing

Events

Main article: list of historical reenactment events

Permanent events

There are a number of locations which have set up a permanent authentic displays:

Creative history and Fantasy events

Jousting knights on horseback perform at the Texas Renaissance Festival.

Technically, creative history and fantasy events should not be listed along with historical re-enactment, as these types of events allow clothing and equipment that is not historically correct (for example, Polyester clothing for a setting in the Middle Ages), or that may have no basis in history whatsoever (Fantasy groups). The purpose of re-enactment is the authentic recreation of a time period, not merely playing "dress up" in "clothing that kinda looks historic".

Although some historical reenactment groups follow a very loose interpretation of history (sometimes mixing equipment from closely related periods or often just the use of inauthentic materials: eg. cotton clothes in a medieval setting), some groups go a step further and mix historical elements with elements of the Fantasy genre or incorporate modern technology or culture into a historical setting (often simply reducing the level of authenticity for increased safety or reduced costs, eg. making melee weapons out of rubber or plastic rather than iron or steel).

A common example for this variation on the theme is the Society for Creative Anachronism and Renaissance Faires, which blend medievalish customs, dress, and activities within historically inspired fantasy kingdoms.

However many Renaissance Faires have begun to rein in the fantasy elements and have a more historical feel.

Commercial reenactment

Many castles, museums, and other historical tourist attractions employ actors or professional reenactors as part of the experience. These usually address the recreation of a specific town, village, or activity within a certain time frame. Commercial reenactment shows are usually choreographed and follow a script.

See also: list of tourist attractions providing reenactment
This is a reenactment of the Corps Franc Wallonie, from Poland, Mai 2007, Sanok-Błonia
Members of the recreated Corps Franc Wallonie an Sd.Kfz.250 fighting vehicle, from Poland, Mai 2007, Sanok-Błonia

Publications

Over the years, there have been a number of publications devoted to covering the subjects of historical reenactment and its close cousin, living history. These have included the Camp Chase Gazette and, at various times, two different magazines named Living History (the most recent of which last appeared in 1997 and was published by Great Oak Inc. and edited by history author Michael J. Varhola).

Another popular book is The Medieval Soldier by Gerry Embleton and John Howe, 1995. It has been translated to French and German. It was later followed by Medieval Military Costume in Colour Photographs.

For the Napoleonic Period there are 2 books of interest that cover life in the military at that time and Living History; "The Napoleonic Soldier" by Stephen E. Maughan, 1999 and "Marching with Sharpe" by B.J. Bluth,2001. The various Napoleonic re-enactment groups, some of whom are listed in the External Links below, now cover the history of their associated regiment as well as try to describe and illustrate how they approach recreating the period. The aim to be as authentic as is possible from the various source materials has led many serious re-enactment societies to set up their own research groups to verify their understanding of the uniforms, drill and all aspects of the life that they strive to portray. In this way re-enactment plays a vital role in bringing history to life, keeping history alive and in expanding the knowledge and understanding of the period.

Media Support

Motion picture and television producers often turn to re-enactment groups for support; films like Gettysburg and Glory benefited greatly from the input of reenactors, who arrived on set fully equipped and steeped in knowledge of military procedures, camp life, and tactics.[1]

In a documentary about the making of the film Gettysburg, actor Sam Elliott, who portrayed Union General John Buford in the film, said of reenactors:

I think we're really fortunate to have those people involved. In fact, they couldn't be making this picture without them; there's no question about that. These guys come with their wardrobe, they come with their weaponry. They come with all the accoutrements, but they also come with the stuff in their head and the stuff in their heart.

[2]

Criticism

Reenactors are sometimes looked on with suspicion, particularly by military veterans, but also by elements of the general public. It is often difficult for veterans or the public to understand why reenactors do what they do, or there may be questions as to the motivation, or the knowledge of the reenactors.

Common criticisms revolve around motivation, as well as concerns about the level of immersion found in some arenas, notably those involving 20th Century conflicts where combatants had stricter regulations regarding personal grooming.[3] Another commonly voiced criticism is that many reenactors are more corpulent than actual soldiers in the period they are portraying. [4] The average age of reenactors is also generally far higher than the average age of soldiers in most conflicts. Few reenactment units discriminate, however, based on age and physical condition.[5] However, there has been criticism about the exclusion of women from some American Civil War combat reenactment units. While hundreds of women may have fought in the conflict, almost all of them did so disguised as men. Attitudes on this topic seem to vary widely. [6]

A final concern mentioned by Thompson's book is the "fantasy farb", or tendency of reenactors to gravitate towards "elite" units such as commandos, paratroopers, or Waffen-SS units resulting in an under-representation in the re-enactment community of what were the most common types of military troops in the period being re-enacted. This is largely drawn from an North American perspective, although there are parallel issues on the European scene. In the UK there are multi-period events such as 'History in Action' where groups get to look at each other's appearance and performances as well as perform for the general public.

There is certainly much criticism from within reenactment organisations as to meritocracy, leadership and so-on. On the whole reenactors could be guilty of projecting their own, present-minded attitudes onto their historical alter egos.

See also

General

WW2 Authenticity Forum *[4]

Ancient
Roman
Hun
Dark Ages
Medieval
17th Century


18th Century


19th Century
20th Century

WW2 Authenticity Forum*[8]

References

  1. ^ Details may be found in the "making of" featurettes on the DVD versions of both films.
  2. ^ This documentary can be found on the DVD of the film Gettysburg.
  3. ^ Thompson, Jenny. Wargames: Inside the World of 20th Century Reenactors (Smithsonian Books, Washington, 2004). ISBN 1-58834-128-3
  4. ^ Website that makes fun of 'fat reenactors'
  5. ^ Thompson, op.cit.
  6. ^ Women Military Reenactor's Homepage
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Historical_reenactment&oldid=154820941"