Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Islam:The Muslim Guild
Start
Salam Aleikom!
Since this is a new Guild, it would benefit if everyone made it known that this guild exists.
Rules
- Be polite :)
Projects
Front page
Ex Muslim
Muwaffaq wants to add the class "ex-Muslim" to the front page.
- I object to that. I argue that we are not going to have a category for every single belife or lack of belife or ex-something. Only "muslim" or the lack of it, that is "non-Muslim". It is evident that he only whant to add that category to make a statement. Its is done in bad spirit, and i object to it, this is a pro-Islam guild, not the opposite. --Striver 01:19, 30 July 2005 (UTC)
- This is a collaboration. You have made your point. I think it is important to classify ex-muslims as ex-muslims. Please clarify why do you think this is done in bad spirit? You are free to object to it, but please limit your objection to the talk page.
SIIEG
the Wikipedia:WikiProject_Islam:SIIEG have their agendas, and we analyze them here.
Prophet
They have decided to remove "prophet" before "Muhammad".
- I dont realy know what to make of it, any other comments? --Striver 01:19, 30 July 2005 (UTC)
- Only Muslims believe Muhammad is a prophet. He's not a universally acknowledged prophet. To push him as a universal prophet is POV. Muwaffaq 21:00, 30 July 2005 (UTC)
Holy
They have decided to remove "Holy" before "Quran".
- I dont realy know what to make of it, any other comments? --Striver 01:19, 30 July 2005 (UTC)