User:Orfen/RfA and XfD Contributions
Appearance
Inspired by Cynical's user subpage this is a subpage with easy access to the different decisions I have made along with the outcome of said discussions. I do this to allow users easy access to the decisions I have made in the past and the reasons for these decisions. I think by doing this I can provide increased transparency of the contributions I have made to both RfA and XfD. This is also to help me see some of the ways I have gone about things in the past and help me improve upon things. All contributions are listed in chronological order with the oldest contributions first.
Summary
RfA
- Total:
- Number of Support: 75
- Number of Oppose: 34
- Number of Neutral: 8
- Total Successful: 70
- Total Unsuccessful: 45
XfD
- Total:
- Number of Keep: 10
- Number of Delete: 27
- Number of Other[1]: 3
RfA
Support
- Metros232 {successful)
- Tango (successful)
- Gnangarra (successful)
- Dina (successful)
- Can't sleep, clown will eat me Arbitration Committee Elections December 2006 (unsuccessful)
- Shirahadasha 2nd Nomination (successful)
- TerriersFan (successful)
- Ragesoss (successful)
- Badlydrawnjeff 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- AndonicO (successful)
- Mallanox (successful)
- Sam Blacketer (successful)
- Krimpet (successful)
- Adambro (successful)
- Scientizzle (successful)
- Bibliomaniac15 (successful)
- Selket (successful)
- Matt Britt 2nd Nomination (successful)
- Prolog (successful)
- TwinsMetsFan (successful)
- Stephen (successful)
- The Rambling Man (successful)
- Errabee (did not succeed)
- AGK (successful)
- Sr13 (successful)
- Eyrian (successful)
- DGG (successful)
- Slumgum (successful)
- MastCell (successful)
- BigrTex (successful)
- David Fuchs (successful)
- Moreschi 2nd Nomination (successful)
- CattleGirl (successful)
- MZMcBride (successful)
- Rettetast (successful)
- Pastordavid (successful)
- Dekimasu (successful)
- Searchme (successful)
- Seattle Skier (successful)
- AQu01rius (successful)
- After Midnight (successful)
- Ikiroid 2nd Nomination (successful)
- Dweller (successful)
- Khukri 2 (successful)
- BrendelSignature (successful)
- Cecropia 2nd RfB Nomination (successful)
- C.Fred (successful)
- Anas Salloum (successful)
- Masamage (successful)
- Maxsem (successful)
- Carioca (successful)
- Audacity (successful)
- Alvestrand (successful)
- Lucasbfr (successful)
- Arctic.gnome (successful)
- Nihiltres (successful)
- Yonatan (successful)
- Akradecki (successful)
- Bobak (successful)
- Yamamoto Ichiro (successful)
- Spurious (successful)
- PeaceNT (successful)
- Booksworm (did not succeed)
- Ocatecir (successful)
- Christopher Parham (successful)
- Pascal.Tesson 2nd Nomination (successful)
- The Transhumanist 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- DanMS (successful)
- Vassyana (successful)
- WilyD (successful)
- Bedford (successful)
- RyanLupin 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- Cailil
- StephenBuxton
- Matthewedwards
Oppose
- Doctor Evil (did not succeed)
- MoRsE (did not succeed)
- DavidJJJ (did not succeed)
- Hello32020 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- SteveBaker (did not succeed)
- Lllama man (did not succeed)
- TonyTheTiger 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- the juggsd86 (did not succeed)
- Max Naylor (did not succeed)
- Nima Baghaei 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- Retiono Virginian (did not succeed)
- Martinultima (did not succeed)
- Bloodpack (did not succeed)
- SFGiants (did not succeed)
- G1ggy (did not succeed)
- Jhfireboy (did not succeed)
- Pupster21 (did not succeed)
- Nenyedi (did not succeed)
- PeeJay2K3 (did not succeed)
- StephenHjellum (did not succeed)
- Dynaflow (did not succeed)
- Nardman1 (did not succeed)
- Roastytoast (did not succeed)
- Tenebrae 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
- Bjelleklang (successful)
- N734LQ (did not succeed)
- TenPoundHammer (did not succeed)
- Marcschulz (did not succeed)
- Redfarmer (did not succeed)
- The Transhumanist 5th Nomination (did not succeed)
- Tkgd2007 (did not succeed)
- Ilyushka88 (did not succeed)
- Headbomb (did not succeed)
- Golich17 (did not succeed)
Neutral
- Moralis (did not succeed)
- Eukesh (did not succeed)
- Slgrandson (did not succeed)
- Dark Dragon Flame (did not succeed)
- Blueboy96 (did not succeed)
- William Pietri (successful)
- Benon 6th Nomination (did not succeed)
- LessHeard vanU (successful)
XfD
Keep
- Letterbomb (speedy redirect to Mailbomb)
- Items in the Metroid series (keep)
- Give 'Em Hell, Kid (keep)
- American Idiot (film) (delete for now)
- Jason Freese (keep)
- The End. (relisting in individual AFDs)
- Eddy (Ed, Edd n Eddy) (keep)
- Henry Potty and the Pet Rock (keep)
- Template:User vandalized (withdrawn by nominator)
- Atomic bombings of Japan as a form of state terrorism (2nd nomination) (no consensus to delete defaulting to keep)
Delete
- The Patient (delete)
- List of characters in fighting games (delete)
- Under pressure (my chem & the used song) (delete)
- Star wars (fan film) (delete)
- Tommy Gun (Green Day album) (delete)
- RuneScape mini-games (delete)
- Rayfield (band) (delete)
- Filming mistakes from That's So Raven (delete)
- Crown Tranceiver (delete all)
- Numbers in music (deleted)
- Astro Empires (deleted)
- Wikipedia:WikiProject RuneScape (no concensus-default keep)
- Wikipedia:Esperanza (decentralize Esperanza)
- The Patient (2nd nomination) (keep)
- Servers of City of Heroes and City of Villains (delete)
- Astro Zombies EP (delete)
- Starships! (regular delete)
- Sleep (My Chemical Romance song) (redirect back to The Black Parade)
- User:Cyberoidx/cbvsreal (withdrawn)
- My Chemical Romance's Upcoming Fourth Studio Album (delete)
- Bunnies (song)
- Evolver (John Legend album)
- The Sly Serpent
- American Idiots: The Motion Picture
- Sorry (Jonas Brothers song)
- Shelf (Jonas Brothers song)
- Love Bug (Jonas Brothers song)
Other
- It's Not a Fashion Statement, It's a Deathwish (redirect)
- Anic (redirected)
- Myspace Girl
Notes
- ^ Other includes redirects, merges, or other decisions without a delete or keep.