Talk:Wooden Ships

Songs Stub‑class

	This article is within the scope of WikiProject Songs, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of songs on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.SongsWikipedia:WikiProject SongsTemplate:WikiProject Songssong
Stub	This article has been rated as Stub-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.

What happened to the previous song explanation in this article? Here it is:

The song depicts the horrors of a post-nuclear war where presumably two sides have virtually annihilated the world and one man from each side stumbles upon the other.

If it's a song about the Civil war or Vietnam war, who are the "silver people on the shoreline"? Things don't seem to add up here, and I vote that we revert to the original explanation.

Kganser 08:55, 24 February 2007 (UTC)[reply]

I always thought that this song was about the American Civil War.

If you listen to the woodstock live album, they introduce the song as described in this article.

What's the deal with the current given explanation? Different sides of a war always have different uniforms. The rest of the lyrics don't make any sense in that context either. And why would a protest group write a song about the civil war? ASWilson 23:36, 23 January 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Writing Credits

This article credits the song to both Crosby and Stills, but Stills recorded a version of "Wooden Ships" in 1968 (part fo the "Just Roll Tape") before meeting Crosby or Nash. The link does not look credible. So who really wrote it? This acoustic version is actually the best in my opinion. ramblinmindblues

It's a Vietnam War protest song, you silly goose

At Woodstock, I believe it was Stephen Stills who introduced the song by saying that it was about "after the Apocalypse, and the survivors are escaping in the Wooden Ships." He made no mention of the Civil War. There was no "apocalypse" associated with the American Civil War. The "apocalypse" that Stills was referring to was the perceived, impending threat in 1969 that the Vietnam War could escalate to a nuclear conflict. Many of the lyrics in the song specifically point to a foreign war (and if it wasn't the Vietnam War, there are very few choices left, e.g. Korean War). "If you smile at me, I will understand 'Cause that is something everybody everywhere does in the same language." Clearly, the two speakers (presumably, deserters from opposing armies) speak different languages. I am not aware of any such stories or tales from the Civil War (i.e., two deserters, one of whom does not speak English). The coat reference is to the North Vietnamese Army uniform, which was a long-sleeved cotton shirt with two front pockets. "purple berries" probably refers to the fruit of the Sim tree, which was a favorite fruit roughly equivalent to N. America's wild blueberries in central Vietman. "Go, take your sister then, by the hand, lead her away from this foreign land": notice the word "foreign"; I am not aware of any "foreign lands" involved in the American Civil War (unless you consider West Virginia to be a foreign land, which some Easterners no doubt still do). And, finally, CSN&Y, in 1969 when the song was released, was a Vietnam War Protest Band (capitalization intentional). CSN&Y was not a Civil War Protest Band. OreRockOn 16:54, 16 February 2007 (UTC)OreRockOn[reply]

I have to agree with the above paragraph. When I heard it at the time it was released, in the context of the Vietnam war and possible nuclear war with the USSR, my impression was that it was about the Apocalypse. It would be kind of silly to sing about the Civil war during the Vietnam war.

It's a Science Fiction story; the Vietnam war was not the main focus

The song isn't "about the Vietnam war." It is a science fiction story about an apolcalyptic war, partly nuclear, that would destroy civilization or nearly so. The expectation was certainly that the apocolyptic war would arise out of the same source as the Vietnam War, the cold war itself. It wasn't necessary to think it would escalate directly from the Vietnam War. The "Other Side" isn't the NVA, it's the Soviets and all their allies or, if the singer's PoV is reversed, it is us and all our allies. Vietnam was an ongoing tragedy but WWIII was big in the mind of Pual Kantner and didn't have to have much to do with Vietnam. And Paul Kantner was the science fiction writer involved. 71.234.37.144 (talk) 01:10, 12 July 2008 (UTC)Will in New Haven71.234.37.144 (talk) 01:10, 12 July 2008 (UTC)[reply]