Talk:Santa Ana winds

Seems to me the link to Santa Ana Winds (the band) needs some disambiguation from the page it's on?

Season

In southern California, Santa Ana winds occur from September until April, with a peak occurrence in November, December and January of more than 3 events/month (Raphael MN, 2003, The Santa Ana winds of California, Earth Interactions 7(8): 1-13). Alanterra (talk) 22:18, 1 November 2010 (UTC)

Vandalism

On 21 Oct 2004 large section of this article was deleted by 67.171.229.13. I reverted it to the previous version (20:38, 25 Sep 2004). Rsduhamel 07:41, 26 Oct 2004 (UTC)

Adiabatic Warming

The link in the article goes to a different article, which doesn't seem to explain what it is (to me, anyway).

Can someone explain to me how adiabatic warming works in this case? Santa Ana events often have temperature increases of 10–20° C, which corresponds to an altitude loss of 1,500–3,000 m. Yet if the high pressure system is over the Great Basin, average elevation is not really high enough to create this temperature difference (even before allowing for heat loss as the air flows 500+ km). Alanterra (talk) 22:22, 1 November 2010 (UTC)

Etymology

We on Wiktionary have done a bit of research. The "Santana" etymology is almost certainly an urban legend. It's much more likely that the original form was "Santa Ana wind" and that "Santana" is a perfectly ordinary contraction. The main holes in the "Santana" story are:

• No one seems to know what native languages were involved.
• Sanatanas does appear to be Spanish, but Satanàs is much more common. Note that it's stressed differently from Santana (but then, buckaroo and vamoose also shifted stress)
• The name Santa Ana goes back centuries in the area, and Santana is a natural contraction of it. It would be surprising if Santa Ana didn't get turned into Santana.
• Checking google and google books, the only hits for "vientos de Sanatanas" are in versions of the "Santana winds" theory. "vientos de Satanàs" also appears very rare. If the Santana theory is correct, you'd expect to find the Spanish phrase from which it was supposed to have been borrowed.
• Checking google books, Santa Ana wind appears in the 1800s, while Santana wind doesn't appear until 1958.

See here for more discussion. -Dmh 16:13, 17 January 2007 (UTC)

There is a reference for the "Santanas" theory on Google books. I'm a little bit reluctant to reference it directly, as it might give the impression that the "Santanas" theory is correct. As above, it's most likely wrong, but I'm not sure where there's a good source for the "Santa Ana" theory. Right now the text is weasely, but bringing in the arguments above might make the eytmology section disproportionately large. OTOH, the "Santanas" folk etymology is well-known, so perhaps it deserves more discussion than it would otherwise get. -Dmh 07:39, 18 January 2007 (UTC)

The link to the Wiktionary debate does not show anything for Santana. If someone finds the debate, can you please post it here? Thanks. Gigglesworth 20:42, 25 October 2007 (UTC)

---

As a native Angeleno, I can tell you that the winds are univerally spelled "Santa Ana," but are generally pronounced "Santana." I just marked it up to all the other weird pronunciations we have, starting with Sepulveda Blvd. A good way to spot people not from the region. Also, if I remember my Spanish correctly, they don't insert glottal stops between identical adjacent vowels, so the two a's would tend to merge in pronunciation in the native language anyway.

---

The unsigned author above believes that Santa Ana is generally pronounced "Santana". As a native Angeleno myself, I can say that during wildfire season, broadcast news reporters consistently pronounce the Spanish name as two distinct words, just as they would for nearby cities Santa Monica or Santa Clarita. I speak Spanish fluently and can add that the word merging that would occur in Spanish would be for the same reason as in English: laziness in pronunciation rather than being an accepted contraction of such words. On the matter of "vientos de Sanatanas", the phrase would leave the Spanish-language reader with the impulse to "correct it" to "vientos de Satanás". It seems incongruous, though, that the early Christian missionaries - that named nearly all Southern California areas - would break from their tradition of honoring saints to name the winds after a daemon. Just a thought. 66.134.232.226 00:53, 22 October 2007 (UTC)

I grew up in the San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara regions, within the influence of these winds. Locals and the local meteorologists use both terms, 'Santa Ana' and 'Santana'. I've been a life-long Santanaista, although it's hard to maintain this position considering the evidence presented above. Thanks for the research! Gigglesworth 20:39, 25 October 2007 (UTC)

As another native Angeleno, growing up in the 1950s, I never heard or saw "Santa Ana" in reference to the wind until I was an adult. To us, it was just "the Santana." In 1957 or 1958 I was given a fire preparedness book (and a junior fire ranger badge!) published by the County of Orange that referred to the wind as "Santana", accompanied by a line drawing of a devil's head blowing. Jim 16:42, 1 November 2007 (UTC)

As above I grew up in Los Angeles in the 30's and 40's and it was always referred to as the "Santana" winds. I was told that the winds were named thus after General Santana who was known as a particularly nasty man. Often he was called a "devil" and so the winds were also known as the "Devil Winds" or ----Santana winds. I would think that the whole controversy could easily be settled by going into the weather reports of back issues of the LA Times or the Herald Examiner.

Another angeleno born in 1950, I recall the dictionary definition as "santana; an Indian word meaning devil wind; a hot wind off the high desert". In the sixty's it was defined in the dictionary this way, I thought the Santa Ana became a later pronunciation for many of the same reasons listed above. however to me santana was before santa ana pronunciation. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Ridescloud (talk • contribs) 04:01, 14 October 2008 (UTC)

I moved to the high desert (Victorville) in 1969. I was also a wildland firefighter for the state from 1985 to 1991. I had NEVER heard anyone refer to the Santa Ana winds as the 'Santanas' until I heard someone in Denver, Colorado mention it in 2008 !! I thought 'you have no clue what you're talking about!' It seems to me, based on the above entries, Santana Winds or Santanas stopped being used in the 70's. I have discussed this will all the Californians I know and not ONE have ever heard the winds referred to as the Santanas —Preceding unsigned comment added by 75.70.169.187 (talk) 13:25, 19 November 2008 (UTC)

Another native of the LA/Orange County area, born in 1952, and my grandparents being original settlers of my hometown, La Habra, we all referred to the winds as Santanas as did everybody we knew. The use of "Santa Ana's" seemed to coincide with the influx of out-of-state newscasters who also had trouble pronouncing place names like Cajon and San Jacinto with the proper Spanish "J." George Fishbeck was a great meteorologist and did not mispronounce the name of the winds, he was using the correct regional, native-born population's name for them. I have written to The Weather Channel about the misuse of the name, "Santa Ana" for the winds and received a reply explaining that the name comes from the Santa Ana river. This is ridiculous, given the actual geographical origins and range of the winds. The town of Santa Ana has absolutely nothing to do with the winds, nor does the Santa Ana River or any other formation with the name "Santa Ana." The winds existed long before the Spaniards came to California and as children, we were taught that the word, "Santana" was an approximation of the name given to the winds by an indigenous California people.Basquettecase (talk) 05:11, 12 December 2008 (UTC)basquettecase

I grew up in San Diego County during the 50s and 60s, and I do not believe I ever heard other than the 2 words "Santa Ana"; certainly that was the common and accepted pronunciation. I do recall some ideas floating around that the correct pronunciation of the Mexican General Santa Ana (of Alamo fame) was "Santana", but I do not recall any attempt to link that to the name of the winds. Wschart (talk) 00:10, 4 September 2009 (UTC)

Not a Fohn

A Fohn wind results from precipitation on the windward side of a mountain range which releases latent heat into the atmosphere which is then warmer on the leeward side (e.g. the Chinook or the original Fohn). The Santa Ana winds do not originate in precipitation, but in the bone-dry high deserts. The Santa Ana is actually not a Foehn. It has in common only the adiabatic compressive heating caused when the air descends from the high desert down to sea level. Tmangray (talk) 06:47, 27 December 2007 (UTC)

Appearance of original research in literature

The literature section includes a bullet point stating that "Richard Henry Dana's 1840 journal/book, "Two Years Before the Mast" includes a description of a wind event that can only be categorized as a "Santa Ana." The author never mentions the word "Santa Ana" but his description is unmistakable." This appears to be original research on the part of the editor. No reliable source has been given that draws this conclusion. I will leave this on for a few days per policy with this tag, but unless a citation is given it should be deleted. Alanraywiki (talk) 05:29, 28 May 2009 (UTC)

Problem with the way a line is written.

In the "Similar Winds" section of the description, the second paragraph starts with the line "Winds blowing off the elevated glaciated plateaus of Greenland and Antarctica experience the most extreme form of katabatic wind, of which the Santa Ana is a type, for the most part." The last part of that sentence "...for the most part." is what I feel needs to be cleaned up. It seems to fit into a general pattern of loose scientific sounding facts that are not cited. I did go trough and add several Citation Needed tags as well.

This article is full of information, I think it just needs to be cleaned up.

Indian Summer

The song; "Indian Summer", mentions Santa Ana winds.68.231.189.108 (talk) 21:27, 10 October 2009 (UTC)

California Gold

The novel; "California Gold"; by John Jakes; copyr. 1989 by Random House; mentions: " Santan winds"--I have never heard of this, I think it is a spelling error for "Santan"; or "Santa Ana", as I always heard it. He mentions "earpiece" when he means "receiver" of a telephone, so it is probably an error..68.231.189.108 (talk) 21:27, 10 October 2009 (UTC)

Geographical sources

On many occasions when we experience elevated temperatures and high north-easterly winds in So. California, the weather reports identify the source as a high pressure system located over the Four Corners region. If memory serves, these also occur most frequently from September through November, although they can happen at any time of year.

Presumably, meteorologists are referring to the Colorado Plateau with this language, and not the Great Basin. The Geography section of the WP Four Corners article notes that the area is "...a center for weather systems, which stabilize on the plateau then proceed eastward through Colorado and into the central states." The high pressure systems that affect So. California also tend to stabilize, and create elevated wind and temperature events that often last 1-3 weeks.

Do meteorologists also regard these as Santa Ana wind events? Are they also drainage winds, coming as they do off of a high plateau? The article does indicate that winds from the Great Basin are also driven by high pressure systems... --96.251.23.32 (talk) 15:00, 6 July 2011 (UTC)

In terms of the large-scale (synoptic scale) high-pressure systems that cause Santa Anas, the Great Basin and Four Corners aren't that far apart. The inflowing airmass to Southern California will simply have a small difference in angular direction, but as the air compresses and descends the mountain passes, it becomes irrelevant. So, yes. Darkest tree (talk) 22:46, 1 December 2011 (UTC)

Popular Culture section

First, let me say that I wish as much time and effort were devoted to the science and meteorology content of this article as has been devoted to finding obscure mention of the Santa Ana winds in song lyrics and movies. It irks me that every time we have a Santa Ana wind event (you could practically chart them based on dates of edits to this article) people rush here to either vandalize the article or police up all the pop culture content.

That said (rant over), the Santa Ana winds are a major phenomenon in Southern California life. It's about the closest thing we have to major severe weather here. So, as long as we're going to have a list of mentions of Santa Ana winds in pop culture, I don't really think that any mention is too small or too trivial to include. All of this art, music, and movies touch on the Santa Ana winds because they're a big deal to us here. Maybe the MoS says otherwise, in which case I'll defer to whatever consensus emerges regarding this list of trivia, but that's where I stand.

The Raymond Chandler Red Wind quote, in particular, is one of the most famous and widely-recognized descriptions of the Santa Ana winds and definitely is significant enough to merit inclusion in this article. Maybe it even belongs at the top.

Consider this my challenge to the {{trivia}} tag that appeared today. Darkest tree (talk) 22:41, 1 December 2011 (UTC)