Laser hair removal
Epilation performed by laser was performed experimentally for about 20 years before it became commercially available in the mid 1990s. Laser and light-based methods are sometimes called phototricholysis or photoepilation.
In addition to lasers, some light-based epilators use a xenon flash lamp which emits full-spectrum intense pulsed light (IPL) . Treatment with this device is sometimes popularly referred to as laser hair removal, though the device is not a laser per se.
Mechanism of action
The primary principle behind laser hair removal is selective photothermolysis. Lasers can cause localized damage by selectively heating dark target matter in the area that causes hair growth while not heating the rest of the skin. Light is absorbed by dark objects, so laser energy can be absorbed by dark material in the skin (but with much more speed and intensity). This dark target matter, or chromophore, can be naturally-occurring or artificially introduced.
Hair removal lasers selectively target one of three chromophores:
- Carbon, which is introduced into the hair follicle by rubbing a carbon-based lotion into the skin following waxing (this lotion is an "exogenous chromophore"). When irradiated by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser, the carbon causes a shock wave capable of mechanically damaging nearby cells. This method has been abandoned since it does not cause permanent loss. (It has been replaced with the long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser which targets endogenous melanin in the follicle.)
- Hemoglobin, which occurs naturally in blood (it gives blood its red color). It preferentially absorbs wavelengths from argons, and to a lesser extent from rubies, alexandrites, and diodes. It minimally absorbs the Nd:YAG laser wavelength. Hemoglobin is not a primary target for laser hair removal.
- Melanin is considered the primary chromophore for all hair removal lasers currently on the market. Melanin occurs naturally in the skin (it gives skin and hair its color). There are two types of melanin in hair: eumelanin (which gives hair brown or black color) and pheomelanin (which gives hair blonde or red color). Because of the selective absorption of photons of laser light, only black or brown hair can be removed.
Any laser light beam intended for topical use can only penetrate skin tissue two millimeters deep. [citation needed] As such, there has been great controversy surrounding the laser industry claims to what most people think of when they hear the word "permanent".
The dermal papilla is the only appropriate target of destruction, as it is the only substructure of the hair shaft which can reproduce a new root system, and therefore a new hair shaft. [citation needed] The dermal papilla is located at a depth of 7-8 millimeters for coarse hair, and so is beyond the reach of laser.
No form of laser is capable of permanent hair removal without scarring. [citation needed] At most, 5% of hair in a given area can be removed, which adheres to the common usage of the word "permanent", usually because the hair root has no pigment, or is not very deep or thick in diameter and is therefore within the two millimeter range of the laser. This is why laser technicians are required by law to use the term "reduction". [citation needed]
For a short list of approved lasers, the Food and Drug Administration permits the use of the phrase "permanent reduction." The use of the phrase "permanent removal" is not permitted for any laser whatsoever. However, this differentiation is not advertised to the public. Virtually all clinics choose to use the phrase "laser hair removal." Unsuspecting clients are not made aware of the differentiation. [citation needed]
Clinics performing laser hair removal usually recommend at least six treatments. For this reason treatments are often sold in packages. High pressure sales tactics and discounts are often used to influence clients. Fees must be payed in full before treatment can begin. This often inhibits careful attention to terms and conditions. Guarantees are commonly used to distract from the fine print. Currently no clinica offers a money-back guarantee. At best clients are offered 2-3 years of additional hair removal.
There are no long-term clinical studies on the effectiveness of laser hair removal. Few studies follow results longer than a matter of months, and none longer than two years. Semi-long term clinical studies show a direct relationship between time after laser treatment and hair growth. It is likely that most lasered hairs are forced into a prolonged dormancy of a few years as the follicle recovers from shock.
Laser parameters that affect results
Several wavelengths of laser energy have been used for hair removal, from visible light to near-infrared radiation. These lasers are usually defined by the lasing medium used to create the wavelength (measured in nanometers (nm)):
- Argon: 488 or 514.5 nm
- Ruby: 694 nm
- Alexandrite: 755 nm
- Pulsed diode array: 810 nm
- Nd:YAG: 1064 nm
Pulsewidth is an important consideration. It has been observed in some published studies that longer pulsewidths are safer in darker skin.
Wavelength is a critical factor. Longer wavelengths are safer in darker skin.
Spot size, or the width of the laser beam, affects treatment. Theoretically, the width of the ideal beam is about four times as wide as the target is deep. Most lasers have a round spot about the size of your little finger (8-10 mm).
Fluence or energy level is another important consideration. Fluence is measured in joules per square centimeter (J/cm2).
Repetition rate is believed to have a cumulative effect, based on the concept of thermal relaxation time. Shooting two or three pulses at the same target with a specific delay between pulses can cause a slight improvement in the heating of an area.
Epidermal cooling has been determined to allow higher fluences and reduce pain and side effects, especially in darker skin. Four types of cooling have been developed:
- Clear gel: usually chilled
- Contact cooling: through a window cooled by circulating water
- Cryogen spray: immediately before/after the laser pulse
- Air cooling: forced cold air at -34 degrees C (Zimmer Cryo 5 unit)
Multiple treatments have been shown in numerous studies to be more effective for long-term reduction of hair. Current parameters suggest a series of treatments spaced at 1 month for the face, 2 months for the chest and 3 months for the legs.
Laser energy also gets less effective the deeper into the skin it must travel. Think of it like putting your hand over a flashlight. A little light penetrates the thinner skin (the reddish glow), but can't penetrate the thicker areas. Light that enters the skin is either absorbed or scattered and reflected back out of your hand. When this happens to a laser beam, this scattering is called attenuation. The more tissue light has to travel through, the more attenuation will occur. That means at deeper levels, less energy reaches the target.
Other uses
Hair removal lasers are effective treatment for pseudofolliculitis barbae (commonly called ingrown hairs or "shaving bumps"). For darker skin patients with black hair, the long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser with a cooling tip can be safe and effective when used by an experienced practitioner.
They have recently been reported as helpful treatment for pilonidal cysts, since they eliminate the ingrown hairs that produce the troublesome foreign body reactions in this congenital malady.
Laser Hair Removal Costs
The costs of laser hair removal vary by region. The US average price for laser treatments is $429.00 according to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons.