The event saw the incipient feud between Raven and Tommy Dreamer develop, with Raven delivering a promo in which he revealed that his girlfriend, Beulah McGillicutty, had been spurned by Dreamer at a summer camp as a teenager and had now aligned herself with Raven to seek revenge. During the bout between Raven and Dreamer, Beulah interfered on Raven's behalf and was given a piledriver by Dreamer. Dreamer later described the match as the first time the ECW fans "truly accepted [him]".[1][2]
Hostile City Showdown also saw The Sandman challenge Shane Douglas for the ECW World Heavyweight Championship. Earlier that month, The Sandman's valet, Woman, had turned on The Sandman, aligning herself with Douglas. During the bout, Woman struck Douglas in the knee with a Singapore cane while he was applying a crossface chickenwing to The Sandman, enabling The Sandman to pin Douglas and end his year-long title reign. Woman then reunited with The Sandman, revealing her alliance with Douglas as a ruse. Following the match, Douglas donned a Monday Night Rawt-shirt and insulted the audience, reflecting his imminent departure from ECW to join rival promotion the World Wrestling Federation.
During the main event bout between, Terry Funk and Cactus Jack (Mick Foley), a member of the audience held up a sign reading "Cane Dewey", a reference to Foley's infant son. Foley channeled the event during his heelturn later that year.[3][4]