Talk:Genesis of Aquarion
 | Anime and manga B‑class | |||||||||
| ||||||||||
Genre Of This Anime
Despite what AnimeNewsNetwork says, this series definately more of a drama than it is a comedy. Also, the entire plot revolves around romance. - The Norse 00:53, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
- What are you using as the source for those genres? Remember that we shouldn't engage in original research, especially when listing genres. And saying, "I've seen the series and it is this" is not only original research but also is an editorial point of view. --TheFarix (Talk) 14:34, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
ANN's content is user-submitted like Wikipedia so they're information is also from an "editorial point of view", making them no more correct than I am. Anyone who has watched the series would agree that the very heavy amounts of drama(melodrama? It's hard to tell) and the heavily-romantic backstory overshadow the comedy in the series, which really only exists in a couple early episodes and non-plot related episodes. It's no more of a comedy than say... Trigun and Fullmetal Alchemist are. -The Norse 20:45, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
Aquarion and mythology
Well, since I tagged the section and nothing's happening, perhaps I should explain why...
There's a lot of nominal reference to various bits of mythological information, but my beef with this section (not to mention the chakra section) is that other than using the names, the series itself doesn't seem to put any more significance on its terminology. I might be wrong, of course, but unless this section has sources specifically tying the listed material with Aquarion, it's original research and it's got to go. Magus Melchior 12:04, 16 November 2006 (UTC)
- Stop complaining over something so stupid. There's no reason to remove the section just because it's directly referenced in the show, it's still information that has a bearing on how the show is perceived and should be noted(The chakra section is much more of a stretch and should be summarized, in my opinion). Instead of focusing your attention on raping this article of it's content, you could be pushing for someone to provide a better plot synopsis or something that the page needs. The Norse 01:44, 17 November 2006 (UTC)
- At least one person disgreed with your assessment of this issue. If it's in the show, I'd like to see citations to the episodes. Or at the very least, quotes from the show. You can't just put something in and say "it's in the show" when it may or may not be verifiable. Magus Melchior 02:17, 17 November 2006 (UTC)
- Okay then, let's see here:
Age of Aquarius: Referenced in the show various times.
- The Angels strive to create a new "era of holy genesis".
- The series main plot revolves around solving the conflict between the Angels and Humans.
- During the final episode, Aquarion literally unites with the Earth and brings about a new era of peace and such.
Yoga: The definition provided in the article is almost world-for-word the opening lines of the series' first episode and that theme of uniting body, mind and soul remains constant throughout the series.
Prapti/Mugen Punch: Probably the most obvious and recognizable reference. During the first part of episode 6, Fudo was training the Element Users in this concept, the concept of negating distance and time with your mind and touching things very far away. Later in the episode, Apollo masters this concept by hitting an impossbile-to-hit enemy and driving it to the moon's surface with a single punch.
In a kind of comical way, this series took these metaphorical concepts and made them quite literal.
Apollonius: Or maybe this one is the most recognizable. Apollo/Apollonius' pasts and connection tie perfectly to the summary provided in the article. Apollo getting his name(and identity, pretty much being born) after walking out of a lake looks to be a direct reference Apollo, the God. Apollo's "birth" is covered in episode 5, Apollonius' betrayal, death and rebirth are tied with the main plot of the show and are covered in several episodes.
Atlantis/Asgard/Tree of Life: Atlantis and the Tree of Life definately play a huge roll in Aquarion's central plot. The place where Atlantis is located is Asgard. The rest of the things here seem to be duplicated from Escaflowne, which was also directed by Kawamori. This part doesn't require much argument due to the likenesses and same names being used as the myths.
Kay? - The Norse 03:17, 17 November 2006 (UTC)
Well, I meant the article, not the talk page ;)
In general, I can see the connections you're making, having seen the anime. However, the problem is that we need verifiable sources somewhere that make these connections as well (WP:CITE is a great guideline for this), because not everyone will grok the reasoning. The idea being, we don't rely on "Hey, these two ideas are similar, therefore they must be connected" sort of reasoning you might see on fansites (which is an example of OR).
Age of Aquarius: "Aquarion as a name is an obvious reference to this concept". One would need to find a publication (in the case of anime, a magazine, interview, DVD extras or other merchandise) that makes this connection, otherwise we don't know if the creators actually used the ideas in that particular book.
Yoga: I think this paragraph might be better worded somehow, but the strongest way of presenting this is, again, a publication of some sort.
Prapti: I'd caution against using the word "prapti" here, unless it was mentioned in the show (which to my recollection, it wasn't). Maybe one could place this as a paragraph under "Yoga", since it looks like some ideas from yoga. Therefore, verifying the yoga section properly will verify this one as well.
Apollonius: As this is an actual character, the material here is the strongest, but the "seems inspired" phrase sounded to me like a weasel word. (Apollonius gave fire to humans? Can you point me to where that was mentioned in the show?)
Atlantis: The connection with Yggdrasil could use a source. Also, just because Kawamori directed both Escaflowne and Aquarion, doesn't mean he's transplanted ideas from one to the other (no matter how commonplace this may be in anime studios). Generally, one would find this sort of information in interviews and/or staff commentaries (if they exist).