The critical aggregator website Metacritic awarded Atlanta Millionaires Club a Metascore of 81, based on reviews by 15 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".[1]
Anna Gaca of Pitchfork said "Few R&B albums have a pedal steel; few alt-country albums have a rap feature. Faye Webster's Atlanta Millionaires Club somehow has all of the above. Even stranger, she manages to smooth these apparent contradictions into serene folk-pop with a mellow soul tinge."[7] Writing for Rolling Stone, Angie Martoccio noted that "The 21-year-old's Atlanta roots allow her to effortlessly coalesce R&B with indie-folk."[8]