User talk:2600:100B:B121:641B:BC3D:F627:68AB:859
Name of article: Talk:Mud (2012 film)
This movie shows the wildness of Arkansas nature and the nature of man. I can't wait to watch this again under the guise of research.
Lead evaluation The lead paragraph was not written to preface the page. It was written to inform the reader about the movie, not the page. The addition of a lead paragraph would give the opportunity for a reader to know right away whether the content they are looking for will be available within the article.
Content evaluation After reviewing a few other higher grade movie pages, I determined that this article is well-written but could use a few additions that would give the reader less reason to leave the page seeking more information.
Tone and balance evaluation The authors did not seem to impart their own likes or dislikes into their descriptions. They have done a good job in relating that there were accolades and criticism about this movie.
Sources and references evaluation All links are active and the authors have taken care to reference their sources.
Organization evaluation The writers have done a great job in submitting a well-written, easy to read page. The leading paragraph heads right into revealing the cast and crew members and basic movie information. The addition of a lead paragraph would be an improvement to this article.
Images and media evaluation This article could be improved by adding more images from the movie showing other characters and also images from award shows.
Talk Page This article is several years old and there seems to be no other interest in improving the page. It is in class 3 and could be improved with some additions and very little changes to current content.
Overall evaluation This article has been carefully constructed to reveal the plot, cast and crew, the awards and critic reviews of the movie. While organized and well-written, the addition of a leading paragraph and more images would give this article a step up. A user should not have to find other articles to see quotes or images from this movie.
This is the discussion page for an IP user, identified by the user's IP address. Many IP addresses change periodically, and are often shared by several users. If you are an IP user, you may create an account or log in to avoid future confusion with other IP users. Registering also hides your IP address. |