Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Islam

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by HyperGaruda (talk | contribs) at 07:27, 18 July 2020 (→Discussing specific issues: remove stale decade-old discussions; use the talk page if you want to get attention). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Islam Wikiproject
Islam Portal What is Islam? Indices Wikiproject Categories
Main pageAssessmentMembersArticlesNew articlesPortalHelp
WikiProject Islam
Main project page + talk
Style guide (templates) talk
Announcements and open tasks talk
 → Nominations for deletion talk
Articles Recent changes
Article alerts talk
Assessment department talk
Category (WikiProject) talk
Cleanup listing talk
Portal talk
Review department talk
Things you can do talk
Project organization
Members talk
Experts
Awards
Project history
Task forces
Main task forces
Ahmadiyya talk
Hadith talk
Islam and Controversy talk
Mosques talk
Muslim history talk
Muslim scholars talk
Religious texts talk
Salaf talk
Shi'a Islam talk
Sunni Islam talk
Jesus work group talk
Related WikiProject and task forces
Early Muslim military history talk
Middle Eastern military history talk
Ottoman military history talk
Religion talk

Mission and scope

The mission of WikiProject Islam is to ensure that Islam-related articles on Wikipedia are written in an encyclopedic style, in a neutral and non-sectarian manner, using verifiable and reliable scholarly sources. This is the best place to discuss issues which affect Islam-related articles in general. Discussions about particular articles should be handled on the talk pages of those articles.

The scope of this WikiProject is to improve the quality and quantity of information about Islam available on Wikipedia.

Guidelines for editing Islam articles

Main page: Wikipedia:Manual of Style (Islam-related articles)

If you are a newcomer, the most important and often over-looked point to remember while editing Wikipedia is: You cannot insert your own particular viewpoints into articles. Articles should typically reflect the verifiable opinions of qualified academic scholars, in neutral and balanced prose. The Qur'an and hadith are considered primary sources but they shouldn't be quoted in support of a particular argument unless also backed up by a cite to a reliable secondary source. Also remember to cite your sources correctly. If you feel a viewpoint merits mention, you can find some material which may constitute a reliable source by checking books, journals, articles, newspapers and other sources.

To promote consistency in the way articles are written and edited, a manual of style with recommended guidelines exists. Visit its talk page for current discussion.

To do

  1. Place the project banner {{WikiProject Islam|class=|importance=}} on the talk pages of all articles that fall within the scope of the project.
  2. Add the articles to the Wikipedia:WikiProject Islam/Articles list by category.
  3. Check the recent changes for recent improvements, vandalism, and other changes.

Participants/members

Departments

Departments are specific group of members who do the meta work. Tasks include keeping the project going, maintaining the project pages, related portals, assessing articles, participating in peer reviews, managing the consensus within the project and so on. The following is a list of departments within the WikiProject. WikiProject Members may not necessarily do only departmental tasks. They can contribute content as a member of Work Groups as well.

Assessment

The assessment department focuses on assessing the quality of Wikipedia articles related to Islam. While much of the work is done in conjunction with the WP:1.0 program, the article ratings are also used within the project itself to aid in recognizing excellent contributions and identifying topics in need of further work.

Statistics

WP:Islam article rating and assessment scheme
(NB: Listing, Log & Stats are updated on a daily basis by a bot)
Daily log of status changes
Current Statistics
Islam-related articles by quality and importance
Quality Importance
Top High Mid Low NA ??? Total
FA 1 8 9 15 33
FL 1 1 2
FM 20 20
A 1 1 2
GA 7 13 39 79 13 151
B 81 119 240 459 111 1,010
C 112 155 425 1,597 369 2,658
Start 39 87 453 3,734 1 981 5,295
Stub 7 10 198 3,006 802 4,023
List 1 13 116 194 3 48 375
Category 5,594 5,594
Disambig 63 63
File 39 39
Portal 325 325
Project 93 93
Redirect 6 8 31 140 609 794
Template 425 425
NA 7 15 13 600 635
Other 89 89
Assessed 254 421 1,527 9,239 7,861 2,324 21,626
Unassessed 1 8 477 486
Total 254 421 1,528 9,247 7,861 2,801 22,112
WikiWork factors (?) ω = 64,579 Ω = 4.90

Peer review

The peer review department conducts peer reviews of Islam-related articles on request; this helps to obtain ideas for further improvement by having contributors who may not have previously worked on particular articles examine them. Project members are invited to submit articles to the department in lieu of using the generic peer review process.

Task forces

Articles

Wikipedia:Version 1.0 Editorial Team release version selections

Current issues

Although members of the project are usually aware of current problems and specific tasks to perform in Islam articles, non-members – who are encouraged to help with these – may not be. Generally, discussions of articles take place on talk pages of those articles, but below is a list of some important problems and tasks.

Open tasks for WikiProject Islam
Top priorities Cleanup / Wikify Missing articles Expansion





Merges Discussions Maps, Pictures, Timelines etc.
Neutrality and Factual accuracy disputed Original or Unverified articles GA and FA articles
Islamic terms

Notable persons

Historical issues

Contemporary issues

Other issues

Featured articles

Good articles

FA review

A class review

Peer review

GA review

To see the complete list refer to here

Vandalism/sock puppet alerts

Please watch out for editing behaviors of these banned puppet masters and revert their edits when suspected:

Articles affected

Tasks

  • Standardise references to Qur'an translations.
  • Placing articles in the most appropriate category or categories.
  • Fix inadvertent placing of new Islam articles in Category:Islam when a better category (or more) can be chosen.
  • Sandbox

Deletions

Cleanup listing

A list of articles needing cleanup associated with this project is available. See also the tool's wiki page and the index of WikiProjects.

Templates

What to type What it makes Usage
{{WikiProject Islam}}
WikiProject iconIslam Unassessed
WikiProject iconThis article is within the scope of WikiProject Islam, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Islam-related articles on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.IslamWikipedia:WikiProject IslamTemplate:WikiProject IslamIslam-related
???This article has not yet received a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.
 Template to be placed on talk page of an article within the scope of WikiProject Islam. See the assessment department for more information.
{{Portal|Islam}} For optional use at the bottom of articles within the scope of WikiProject Islam, right before the categories listing.
{{User WikiProject Islam}}
This user is a participant in WikiProject Islam.
 Userbox for members to direct and inform others about this WikiProject.
{{User WikiProject Islam/Userbox2}}
This user is a participant in WikiProject Islam.
 Userbox for members to direct and inform others about this WikiProject. Second option.
{{User WikiProject Islam2}}
This user is a participant in
WikiProject Islam.
 Userbox for members to direct and inform others about this WikiProject. Third option.
{{User Islam related}}
This user edits Islam-related pages.
 Userbox for people who edit Islam related articles
{{WPIslam-invite}} Invite other editors to participate in WikiProject Islam.

Barnstar awards

Image What to type Description
The Islam WikiProject Barnstar {{subst:Islamic Barnstar Award|message ~~~~}} The WikiProject Islamic Barnstar is to be used for the recognition of any excellent contributions to Islam-related articles. Designed and introduced by User:LatinoMuslim in May 2006.
Islamic Barnstar {{subst:The Islamic Barnstar|message ~~~~}} May be awarded to an editor who contributes, spreads, or posts helpful information about Islam.

Categories

Click on "►" below to display subcategories:
Islam
Click on "►" below to display subcategories:
WikiProject Islam

Resources

Reference materials

In accordance with general directives on reliable source usage, Wikipedia should quote qualified scholars of Islam, as Wikipedia policy dictates that authors must be "authoritative in relation to the subject at hand." Other indicators of reliability is whether or not the work is published in a scholarly, peer-reviewed press, or whether the work is itself the subject of independent academic reviews. As per WP:REDFLAG, It is especially important for the source to be of high quality (and perferably there should be multiple sources) when assertions about Islam are made which are unsupported by mainstream academic opinion.

The editors should not write for example "Some Muslims argue X" and then reference it to some Muslim websites unless they could show that the website is representative of the thought of a particular significant group.

    • Please note that websites such as "Answering-Christianity.com" are not reliable sources, because they are neither written by famous scholars nor peer reviewed works. Articles at islamic-awareness.org are usually signed by the authors. For those articles, if one can establish that the authors hold an official academic degree (Western or Islamic) and are notable, they could be used when properly attributed to the authors. Articles at islamic-awareness.org are more likely to have references. So, if you found something there, try to look up for its source and then look up the original source. If you are lucky, you'll get a good sourced piece of information.

Arabic Wikisource has many relevant works in the Arabic language. See the Islamic collection there.

How to find good sources

General tips

  • Encyclopedia of Islam and Encyclopedia of the Qur'an are a very good scholarly resources and one can find information on almost everything. But it is not free unless you belong to an organization that provides access to this for you. Encyclopædia Iranica online is an exception that contains many articles pertinent to Islam, which are peer-reviewed and free to the public, and which may provide additional information not found in the other encyclopedias.
  • You can have free (but limited) online access to many of these books at books.google.com or amazon.com. You can also search for a word (like Islam) in books.google.com and find good books. It is useful to memorize names of some reputed scholars of Islam, most of whom are listed on the 'List of Islamic studies scholars'. Since the scholarly books are usually published by "University of X" presses, you can also add "university" in the appropriate box in the advanced search to get the more scholarly works.
  • If you can afford $15 a month for access to an online library, Questia has a spotty selection of Islam-related books. They don't have everything one would want, but they have enough to justify the money, IMHO. You can search the library without joining.
  • In the U.S., if you have a library card at the local public library (usually free to city residents) you can often get a card at the library of a nearby public university or community college. This may get you access to their online databases like Lexis/Nexis, Jstor, and the Oxford English Dictionary.

From whom you can ask

Please see: Expert Wikipedians in Islamic issues, where you may find a Wikipedian who can help you with your questions about Islamic issues.

Associated Wikimedia

Lists

Books

People

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Islam&oldid=968258018"