Jump to content

User contributions for 203.45.182.172

Results for 203.45.182.172 talk block log logs global block log filter log
Search for contributionsshowhide
⧼contribs-top⧽
⧼contribs-date⧽

20 August 2011

19 August 2011

  • 23:3423:34, 19 August 2011 diff hist −387 Fiona Graham Please discuss these issues properly on the Living Person's Noticeboard instead of engaging in disrupting editing. New geisha are not allowed to reveal their age and it is obvious that Wikipedia is causing harm to a living person by doing so. Tag: references removed
  • 23:3123:31, 19 August 2011 diff hist −378 Fiona Graham Liza Dalby "debuted" a couple of days after it was first suggested as it says in her book. This is not a real debut as described on Wikipedia geisha section. Please also see the consensus on Wikipedia's Liza Dalby page. Tag: references removed
  • 23:2523:25, 19 August 2011 diff hist −389 Fiona Graham Wikipedia is bound by the policy on Living Persons. Many people have made it clear that Sayuki has to operate in a traditional world where breaking rules is not taken lightly. Please resolve this on Living Persons Noticeboard. Tag: references removed
  • 08:4408:44, 19 August 2011 diff hist +4 Fiona Graham "dokuritsu suru" in Japanese means having your own geisha house. You have translated this article wrong. Sayuki was allowed to be a geisha, but not allowed to have her own geisha house as a foreigner.
  • 08:4108:41, 19 August 2011 diff hist −5 Fiona Graham Your translation of the Japanese article is wrong. "dokuritsu suru" means to have your own geisha house, not as you have translated it. This has been corrected already by other people.
  • 08:3908:39, 19 August 2011 diff hist +168 Fiona Graham Liza Dalby's page stated correctly that she was not a geisha previously, and the consensus on the discussion board is that she was not a geisha. The Wikipedia geisha page says it usually takes a year to debut. Liza took a couple of days.
  • 08:3408:34, 19 August 2011 diff hist −389 Fiona Graham Edited out mention of age. Sayuki is a geisha and needs to respect geisha tradition as is obvious from the very long discussion on various noticeboards. Tag: references removed

6 April 2010

5 April 2010

12 February 2010