User:Boissière/FL spring clean
Lists promoted in the month of August. Each section is rated on a scale of 0 to 3 where 0 means no problems and 3 means serious problems.
Set of common problems
[edit]This is to aid with assessment. Evidently some of these are more subjective than others.
- Lead too short
- Lead states "This is a list of..."
- Lead doesn't contain enough references
- Bold text used incorrectly (very few things should need bold text)
- Colour used on its own in tables to highlight types of data
- Info in tables not adequately referenced
- Tables contain irrelevant info
- Tables are too wide for normal screen size
- Tables are unattractive
- Too few elements
- Web References have dead links
- References not reliable or independent
- Maintenance categories - Dated statements
- List not updated with recent info
- Images need alt text
- Contains deleted images
- Unacceptable Images (copyright-wise - it would be difficult to claim fair use for an image in a list)
- Articles proposed for merger
- List significantly overlaps another
- Criteria for inclusion not sufficiently clear
- Columns on similar separate lists don't line up
- All entries in sortable columns should be wikilinked
- Unexpected volatility of article
- Unusual sortable columns